Mini 1730: Suikoden U-Pick GAME OVER

[Elbirn]

Yeah look I'm about to just hammer pistachi0n with no ragrets and then let klingon vig brantz.

Like that's the play here regardless, kill both of them.

[Reasonably Rational]

Yes, we have our own pt. We just haven't been posting in it much since we claimed, with my thought process being there's no reason to keep our thoughts secret now.

-Cerb

[pistachi0n]

Pistachion, you said you investigated us because you thought we were hard to kill scum. Why did you believe that, and if you truly thought we were scum, why didn't you push us D1? Also, based on what we said D1, it was fairly obvious that we had some plan for proving ourselves to the town. If you were suspicious of us, wasn't it easier to let us hang ourselves by our likely inability to actually prove anything? In addition, why did you cop us rather than just shooting us if you were sure enough that we were scum to make us hated. Actually, as a matter of fact, YOU said you had your hated mark back. The implication there is that you are now hated. Why aren't you lynched yet?

Again, please, nobody hammer until this is resolved.

-Cerb

The answer to your questions is that I trust my power more than my intuitions. I think cop is better than vig. I wasn't certain you were town. So the scenarios I went through were

A) you're scum. I cop you, I share my result. They might not believe me but if they lynched me if flip town and then they'd lynch you.

B) you're scum. I vig you. Win. (But as I said, I wasn't certain.)

C) you're town. I vig you. We lost a strong town player.

D) you're town. I cop you. I know you're town. We still have you around. I also know wgeurts is town, which I wouldn't have known if you were dead. I'm happy with my decision.

[Reasonably Rational]

Pistachion, you said you investigated us because you thought we were hard to kill scum. Why did you believe that, and if you truly thought we were scum, why didn't you push us D1? Also, based on what we said D1, it was fairly obvious that we had some plan for proving ourselves to the town. If you were suspicious of us, wasn't it easier to let us hang ourselves by our likely inability to actually prove anything? In addition, why did you cop us rather than just shooting us if you were sure enough that we were scum to make us hated.

Actually, as a matter of fact, YOU said you had your hated mark back. The implication there is that you are now hated. Why aren't you lynched yet?

Again, please, nobody hammer until this is resolved.

-Cerb

The answer to your questions is that I trust my power more than my intuitions. I think cop is better than vig. I wasn't certain you were town. So the scenarios I went through were

A) you're scum. I cop you, I share my result. They might not believe me but if they lynched me if flip town and then they'd lynch you.

B) you're scum. I vig you. Win. (But as I said, I wasn't certain.)

C) you're town. I vig you. We lost a strong town player.

D) you're town. I cop you. I know you're town. We still have you around. I also know wgeurts is town, which I wouldn't have known if you were dead. I'm happy with my decision.

You didn't answer the bolded.

-Cerb

[pistachi0n]

The PM I got said I was marked, but I got it before wgeurts marked me and at the beginning of the day so I assumed it was my power back (because you were scum reading me.) I said in a later post that I read it again and thought I might be wrong. I didn't elaborate because, frankly, I'm embarrassed.

[wgeurts]

I did what

[BRantz]

He got the PM saying that Ranger had marked him. That seems to be the confusion here. Pistachi0n is obviously paying almost no attention to the game, or at least trying to appear that way.

[pistachi0n]

I got a PM saying I was marked at the beginning of the day.

[Varsoon]

FireKari and Ranger have been prodded.

[FireKari]

I didn't realize has been awhile since I posted!
Prod noted!

Going back to catch up

-Fire

[FireKari]

I haven't really miss much lol.

Anyways, I could insta hammer BRantz but I don't feel like it.
Would much rather one of you hammer pistachi0n. Come on guys, you know you want to!!!

-Fire

[wgeurts]

Pistachi0n is likely town.
Don't hammer him or vig him.
No, vote BRantz.

[Suzune]

So what's the plan here? My gut says not to hammer pistashion

[Reasonably Rational]

Wgeurts, pistachions preferred pronoun is "she". :p. Suzune, I'm not feeling that pistachion is likely to be scum either, but I red to get with Drixx to see if he has a preference. Brantz is basically policy at this point.

-Cerb

[Elbirn]

Pistachi0n is likely town.

Where in the world are you getting this?

Real talk I've been thinking brantz might be town, but not pistachio

[Reasonably Rational]

I find it unlikely that scumstachion would blatantly ignore the part of my post that accused her of being a liar, while quoting the post and address in everything else. That's too easily something that would push a scum slot at l-1 over the edge, especially when the person asking the question isn't on your wagon yet. Pistachion, who would you lynch? Top 3 candidates.

-Cerb

[Elbirn]

Where the hell is ranger

[Reasonably Rational]

Yeah she needs a prod as of 31 hours ago. :p

I apologize for stalling the game btw, but I feel like we're in a very strong position and don't want to squander it by going on autopilot.

-Cerb

[Reasonably Rational]

Kari, how does your double vote function in lylo?

[Ranger]

MOD: If you haven't already replaced me, Emergency V/LA.

I'd have announced it BEFORE having been without internet for 48 hours, but the thing about weather-induced access issues is that they are weather induced and not exactly something that I could have planned for.

Gah, this is annoying. The blasted power's STILL not back, even two freakin' days later, and the 'net I AM borrowing is limited and PAINFULLY slow.

[Reasonably Rational]

MOD: If you haven't already replaced me, Emergency V/LA.

I'd have announced it BEFORE having been without internet for 48 hours, but the thing about weather-induced access issues is that they are weather induced and not exactly something that I could have planned for.

Gah, this is annoying. The blasted power's STILL not back, even two freakin' days later, and the 'net I AM borrowing is limited and PAINFULLY slow.

Sorry to hear that, it sounds quite aggravating, hopefully you get it resolved sooner rather than later.

-Cerb

[Klingoncelt]

MOD: If you haven't already replaced me, Emergency V/LA.

I'd have announced it BEFORE having been without internet for 48 hours, but the thing about weather-induced access issues is that they are weather induced and not exactly something that I could have planned for.

Gah, this is annoying. The blasted power's STILL not back, even two freakin' days later, and the 'net I AM borrowing is limited and PAINFULLY slow.

Sorry to hear that, Ranger, hope the power comes back on soon.

[Klingoncelt]

Pistachi0n is likely town.
Don't hammer him or vig him.
No, vote BRantz.

So who do you want vigged?

[Reasonably Rational]

Pistachi0n is likely town.
Don't hammer him or vig him.
No, vote BRantz.

So who do you want vigged?

Who do you suggest, and why them?

-Cerb

[Klingoncelt]

Pistachi0n is likely town.

Where in the world are you getting this?

Real talk I've been thinking brantz might be town, but not pistachio

Brantz is definitely NOT Town, he said so. He's a survivor.

But, worst case scenario, he could be kingmaker at endgame.