Newbie 1667: Bushfire! (Game Over)

[goodmorning]

PC is not the Cop. I know this because I have a Role that can't exist in a setup with a Cop. This means I am one of {Tracker, JK, BP.} No, I'm not telling you which.

Vote: PC

That's a lynch. I'll try and answer questions before threadlock.

[goodmorning]

217 is a good post. Mort is not Scum.

224: It's already been answered, and I told you that it's already been answered.

More tomorrow! Anyone around should post as much as they can in twilight!

[goodmorning]

People I want to look at a little harder tomorrow: Vettrock, Performer, maybe shrike? Probably not shrike.

[PhantomCobalt]

I'll put up my condensed reads once I get access to a computer.

[Cheery Dog]

Votecount 1.08

PhantomCobalt (5) Radical Rat; vettrock; MortFeld; shrike; goodmorning;
AzoriusSenate (2) ai_shuuu; PhantomCobalt;
vettrock (0)
shrike (1) Performer;
Radical Rat (0)
MortFeld (0)
Performer (0)
ai_shuuu (0)
goodmorning (0)

Not voting: AzoriusSenate;

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch

Day 1 Deadline: (expired on 2015-12-12 19:02:24)

[Cheery Dog]

And the fire goes out inside PhantomCobalt.

PhantomCobalt,

Vanilla Townie

, has been lynched Day 1.

Night 1 has now begun. 48 hours to send in actions if you have them.

(expired on 2015-12-06 18:38:30)

[Cheery Dog]

Fire, fire, go away, come again another day.

Nobody died during the night.

It is now Day 2, with 8 alive, it will take 5 to lynch.

Day 2 Deadline (expired on 2015-12-20 18:42:02)

.

[AzoriusSenate]

PhantomCobalt gets the honorary mafia badge for what the hell were you thinking.

[ai_shuuu]

Lol...
im sort of waiting him to do condensed read, and instead he claiming cop...
Didn't see this coming

[goodmorning]

Yeah, this is why we don't fakeclaim as Town in a SemiOpen setup. It just outs PRs and gets us lynched anyway.

So. I'm still a Town PR. If anyone wants to CC me, do it now. If there is a 2nd PR, they should not claim.

I'm going to reread D1 now, with attention to when people vote the PC wagon and why.

[Radical Rat]

So. I'm still a Town PR. If anyone wants to CC me, do it now. If there is a 2nd PR, they should not claim.

Why would you bother to say this?

You say if there's a second PR they shouldn't claim, and I agree with you. But why say if anyone wants to CC you, do it now... if you don't want anyone else to claim?

[goodmorning]

If anyone is going to COUNTERCLAIM me, as in, say I am not a Town PR because THEY are the Town PR, that sets us up as almost certainly 1-Town-1-Scum, which is very helpful for obvious reasons.

If there is a 2nd PR, they're not going to CC me because they likely have quite a good idea what setup we're in and what I am. If there isn't a 2nd PR then it doesn't matter.

[goodmorning]

Oh, and does everyone understand how to read the setup matrix?

[Radical Rat]

If anyone is going to COUNTERCLAIM me, as in, say I am not a Town PR because THEY are the Town PR, that sets us up as almost certainly 1-Town-1-Scum, which is very helpful for obvious reasons.

If there is a 2nd PR, they're not going to CC me because they likely have quite a good idea what setup we're in and what I am. If there isn't a 2nd PR then it doesn't matter.

Ah. Alright, thank you for clarifying.

[Radical Rat]

Also, as you may have guessed, my V/LA period is over.

Rather convenient how it coincided with the end of the Day and Night phase.

[goodmorning]

Hmm.

[ai_shuuu]

first, how do ppl cc if you don't say your exact pr?
well, if its a fake
"This means I am one of {Tracker, JK, BP.} No, I'm not telling you which."
Only a cop can cc you, and thats bad move for a cop to do that when he can use his power at you instead
so, no. don't. It would harm town more than helping it
for now i'll take things as it is, unless some fact tell me otherwise.
One thing for sure there is either a jk, bp, or doc in this setup
===
Some say real hunt begin after someone died.
Will be back later to answer some question directed on me...

[goodmorning]

A Cop wouldn't need to use his power on me, because he'd already know I was lying.

Anyway a 1-for-1 trade, PR for Scum, is absolutely worth it for Town.


Scum could have no-killed. It's unlikely though.

[ai_shuuu]

@GM ah... I see
If thats the case thats a smart move to do as cop
cc you and clear 1 ppl of his alignment

But idk, maybe im just getting paranoid after phantom fake claiming

[shrike]

People I want to look at a little harder tomorrow: Vettrock, Performer, maybe shrike? Probably not shrike.

I assume this was based on the assumption that PC was mafia. How did him flipping town change your views?

Oh, and does everyone understand how to read the setup matrix?

Yes

[shrike]

shrike's 209 is something I've seen scum do - address some topics, put off other topics to follow-up on later. Looking through his profile, he has 13 posts so he looks new but his L-1 vote without announcing L-1 on PC, makes me continue scumreading him.

This post has some more scumhunting effort put into it than your last one. Your vote was a bit tunnely though, and I would have heavily suspected you if PC flipped maf, but now I'm not so sure.
I've only been addressing some topics because I underestimated the amount of time it takes to play forum mafia. There are other lurkers who you could also have accused, Which is why I see this as tunneling. If there's anything specific you want me to address (I bet there isn't) then please tell me.
I've played a lot of IRL mafia, but I'm new to forum mafia. It didn't occur to me to announce that PC was L-1 because I'm used to people carefully considering their votes and counting the votes before placing their own. I'll endeavour to do so in the future though.

[ai_shuuu]

@performer
190well, not so much involved when i vote him. To see this you should see his early post before i vote him @52

191
Town :
radical rat 52
Gm, well she's uncced pr. But even before her claim, she is true to his word

Scum :
Azorius

For another person ill try to get better read about them in this phase...

[Performer]

PhantomCobalt gets the honorary mafia badge for what the hell were you thinking.

Seriously lol.
Fake claims typically cause more issues than it resolves.

[Performer]

If anyone is going to COUNTERCLAIM me, as in, say I am not a Town PR because THEY are the Town PR, that sets us up as almost certainly 1-Town-1-Scum, which is very helpful for obvious reasons.

If there is a 2nd PR, they're not going to CC me because they likely have quite a good idea what setup we're in and what I am. If there isn't a 2nd PR then it doesn't matter.

Ah. Alright, thank you for clarifying.

Radical I can't recall if you expounded on what is your FM experience. Can you tell me about that?

I know we just came out of night phase yesterday, but I noticed vet and shrike have been quiet.

[Performer]

@performer
190well, not so much involved when i vote him. To see this you should see his early post before i vote him @52

191
Town :
radical rat 52
Gm, well she's uncced pr. But even before her claim, she is true to his word

Scum :
Azorius

For another person ill try to get better read about them in this phase...

Since you voted him because he wasn't so involved by post 52, your view is the same on him being disinterested scum? That's odd.
-----
Sorry shrike - was catching up and saw you did post.

I don't see how you think I was tunneling you.