The Resistance (Game Over)

[pablito]

@Bowser and Talah, how do you feel about Jal?

[ForWhomTheJellyRolls]

BNL What do you think about putting me on the team?

[Fluminator]

I don't like Flum and will probably reject it.

</3

Feeling a soft bus from scum here as my instinct. I'll still be sending out Molla and Lilith, after a quick iso I think I'll use Fluminator as the forth person, is that OK?

I think putting me on is a bad idea because I think the majority of people will reject it and it'll be a waste of your suggestion, sadly.

Really? You're pretty obvtown to me.

Chances are, there was only 1 scum on that team. Either BNL or Jal. Lilith has a town aura from her too. I'll laugh super hard if she ends up being scum though.
We still have a mission of 4, a mission of 5 which can afford 1 scum, and a final mission of 5 with no scum.

If we do the originals with a new person, and it passes, then we can probably assume Jal was the scum last round, and rule the original 3 as all town and we keep the same setup for mission 4 (+ the next towniest member) and the chances will be very low there are two scum on that mission unless there was a sleeper agent

and

we picked scum as the newest edition. And even then we'd have mission 5 to try to fix things.
If it fails, then we have two plausible scenarios. One of the originals was a sleeper, and the other 4 people are town, or we rule Jal + the new fourth member as scum together and the original 3 as town.
I'd be fine with BNL putting me on the mission as 4th, because I like information and it increases our odds.

Out of the people not gone yet, Bowser and Coug don't do it for me. I actually didn't have much of a problem with Dragons or FWTJR posting wise. And nothing negative stood out for me on Pablito.
Voting wise, Talah and Bowser both accepted the last one which makes me think it's more likely they knew there was a scumbuddy on so they lose a few marks.
So taking into account both voting and posting, my order would be
Pablito/FWTJR
Talah/Cougar
Bowser
3 of these are scum, If you add me in there as an unknown, we have a pool of 6 with 50% scum.

I still think whoever asked JDGA the question she just answered should claim, because I'd rule them as town. Or is that against the spirit of the game or something?

[JDGA]

I still think whoever asked JDGA the question she just answered should claim, because I'd rule them as town. Or is that against the spirit of the game or something?

Please don't.

[Bowser]

@Bowser and Talah, how do you feel about Jal?

Not sure. Let me go check my notes.

[Bowser]

Last mission Jal was on, it failed. either Jal's scum or scum's trying to trick us.

Actually, now that I'm thinking on it a little, Flum MIGHT be town,

[pablito]

I'm cool with bnl choosing whom he wants and us figuring out by our votes. When we give leaders carte Blanche to choose the team (even by pre-deciding in a benign manner), we lose an essential game function that is offered to us. I'll use my vote to show my hand and am willing to explain after ward.

I think right now our biggest info is in the last vote and it should be used accordingly.

[talah]

@Bowser and Talah, how do you feel about Jal?

The first mission succeeded and he was on the second, so I don't want him on the third.

However, thinking about the composition of the first mission I think it's also pretty likely that Molla and/or BNL are spies since they agreed pretty readily with that, and we ended up with a scenario where subsequent leaders were in the initial pool. There's almost no chance a leader would not include themself in a mission (I'm surprised that's even a thing actually) so If there are 2 spies in the first 3 or 4 players that makes it pretty easy to get 2 failed missions in a row.

Anyway I'll have to have a more detailed look back prior to voting this time.

[BBmolla]

If I'm being real I passed the second cause I didn't want to wait another week for mission 2 (selecting new mission, getting that one accepted, etc)

[StrangerCoug]

If I'm being real I passed the second cause I didn't want to wait another week for mission 2 (selecting new mission, getting that one accepted, etc)

Huh?

[talah]

If I'm being real I passed the second cause I didn't want to wait another week for mission 2 (selecting new mission, getting that one accepted, etc)

For me it was more about the first mission passing and I didn't see much wrong with the team (and thought we'd get lucky I guess). I'm more cautious about you from the perspective of shoving in the first 3 as the first team O.o

There seems to be a fair bit of agreement with this strategy so I wonder if I'm just missing something here.
Leaders are (almost?) always going to pick themselves and so what's the advantage to locking in the next two leaders as part of the first mission (which typically succeeds regardless of faction)?
Seems like an easy way to guarantee fails considering there are 4 spies and 10 players.

[BNL]

Actually, not sure if I want BBmolla on my team. He is being too WIFOMy, and the fact that Bowser is super scummy

and

supported both missions worries me. Then again, I'm not sure who I should pick as the fourth member if I were to kick Molla.

[BBmolla]

If I'm being real I passed the second cause I didn't want to wait another week for mission 2 (selecting new mission, getting that one accepted, etc)

Huh?

I said

IF I'M BEING REAL I PASSED THE SECOND CAUSE I DIDN'T WANT TO WAIT ANOTHER WEEK FOR MISSION 2 (SELECTING NEW MISSION, GETTING THAT ONE ACCEPTED, ETC)

[BBmolla]

If I'm being real I passed the second cause I didn't want to wait another week for mission 2 (selecting new mission, getting that one accepted, etc)

For me it was more about the first mission passing and I didn't see much wrong with the team (and thought we'd get lucky I guess). I'm more cautious about you from the perspective of shoving in the first 3 as the first team O.o

There seems to be a fair bit of agreement with this strategy so I wonder if I'm just missing something here.
Leaders are (almost?) always going to pick themselves and so what's the advantage to locking in the next two leaders as part of the first mission (which typically succeeds regardless of faction)?
Seems like an easy way to guarantee fails considering there are 4 spies and 10 players.

We can reject those missions if we want.

I just wasn't so vehemently against anyone on that mission to reject.

[talah]

Have you played the forum version of this game much?

[BBmolla]

Have you played the forum version of this game much?

No, last time I tried it died from inactivity.

[BNL]

Stuff:
SC and Bowser seem quite scummy
Lilith gut town, but seems to have forgotten about this game
Molla too WIFOMy
Don't want Jal on next mission
Don't want talah on now, but not sure actually due to replacement
Sending Me, lilith, fluminator, and either Molla or Pablito as the last person. Should I send BBmolla or Pablito?

[talah]

Have you played the forum version of this game much?

No, last time I tried it died from inactivity.

Seems like it might work better face to face as far as actually rejecting missions go. I don't really want to shit up the thread given activity here.
But yeah I doubt we're rejecting on a consistent basis because of that.

Stuff:
SC and Bowser seem quite scummy
Lilith gut town, but seems to have forgotten about this game
Molla too WIFOMy
Don't want Jal on next mission
Don't want talah on now, but not sure actually due to replacement
Sending Me, lilith, fluminator, and either Molla or Pablito as the last person. Should I send BBmolla or Pablito?

Put Molla back in I think (and I don't actually have a stake in this team but I probably don't care to reject it.) Send me, remove yourself. fluminator seems fine. lilith seems fine.

That's my suggestion.

[lilith2013]

Sorry, I realize I've been kinda MIA. This is my first time playing resistance and I'm a person who always struggles with reading others, so I feel pretty useless. I do think it was probably Jal who was a spy on the last mission.

[lilith2013]

I'm not comfortable with talah, the replacement may have messed things up but STD rejected the first mission, and then talah accepted the second mission, which had the same people as the first mission. It would have been more telling if STD hadn't been replaced between the missions, but there's a chance talah accepted the second mission because he/she knew there was a fellow spy on the mission (being Jal). It's dependent on Jal being a spy too, though.

[Bowser]

not comfortable with pablito. molla's null

[StrangerCoug]

If I'm being real I passed the second cause I didn't want to wait another week for mission 2 (selecting new mission, getting that one accepted, etc)

Huh?

I said

IF I'M BEING REAL I PASSED THE SECOND CAUSE I DIDN'T WANT TO WAIT ANOTHER WEEK FOR MISSION 2 (SELECTING NEW MISSION, GETTING THAT ONE ACCEPTED, ETC)

Explain please. I don't intend to accept any more missions with you on it at this point.

[BNL]

Unless anyone has any problems, I'm sending Molla, lilith, me, Fluminator. Any final objections?

[StrangerCoug]

I have an objection. Look at the post right above yours.

You don't have to send me if you don't like me, but Jal and BBMolla are the people I don't want on the mission at this point.

[ForWhomTheJellyRolls]

I'm not sure I particularly like that either.