Jake from State Farm (2) goodmorning; Performer;
Performer (2) ai_shuuu; shrike;
Radical Rat (2) AzoriusSenate; This is my username;
AzoriusSenate (1) Radical Rat;
shrike (0)
This is my username (0)
ai_shuuu (0)
goodmorning (0)
Not voting: Jake from State Farm;
With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch
Day 2 Deadline (expired on 2015-12-20 18:42:02)
.
Last edited by Cheery Dog on Fri Dec 18, 2015 2:10 am, edited 1 time in total.
Holder of the Longest Continuous Weekly Mafiascum Post Record. 1 July 2012 - 16 Feb 2023
*It may be held by someone else if you discount the major downtime in 2012 and 2014, I'm not doing the research.
@goodmorning
I think it's coming up on a time where we need to decide on a lynch for today. I notice you have your vote on Jake. I 100% agree that Jake's slot has been leaning scum for me most of the game. I think I would lynch in Rat/Jake today.
Could you provide thoughts on who would be the best lynch for town or give us some people that we should look at? I would feel more comfortable with lynching my own scumreads or at the very least the scumreads of someone who is more experienced in forum mafia and is 99% town.
Vettrock's scumminess was based solely on his absence. The fact that he let himself get replaced instead of just filler posting to avoid prods tells me it was likely real life circumstances.
Enter Jake. His motivation to go back through the thread and share his thoughts on everything that happened makes more sense for a Town than a scum who could easily use catching up as an excuse to lurk.
In post 481, Radical Rat wrote:Vettrock's scumminess was based solely on his absence. The fact that he let himself get replaced instead of just filler posting to avoid prods tells me it was likely real life circumstances.
Enter Jake. His motivation to go back through the thread and share his thoughts on everything that happened makes more sense for a Town than a scum who could easily use catching up as an excuse to lurk.
His catch up posts have been about mostly stuff that doesn't even matter anymore. Catch up posts can be made by both town AND scum and the creation of one isn't alignment indicative. It's the content that you need to parse through.
I'm looking at his motivation and willingness here. Scum would use catching up as an excuse for little or poor content. Jake is using it to contribute and ask questions.
Also, I firmly believe that nothing in a Mafia game ever ceases to be important. There isn't a single event that couldn't benefit from having a new perspective on or a new idea about it.
In post 481, Radical Rat wrote:Vettrock's scumminess was based solely on his absence. The fact that he let himself get replaced instead of just filler posting to avoid prods tells me it was likely real life circumstances.
Enter Jake. His motivation to go back through the thread and share his thoughts on everything that happened makes more sense for a Town than a scum who could easily use catching up as an excuse to lurk.
His catch up posts have been about mostly stuff that doesn't even matter anymore. Catch up posts can be made by both town AND scum and the creation of one isn't alignment indicative. It's the content that you need to parse through.
Well I shouldn't say that first part. Obviously reads can be gathered through looking at previous convos. I guess what I was trying to say that most of what he has been saying hasn't been hitting me as particularly relevant.
In post 445, shrike wrote:
I understand that. That's why I think you should've read through the game first and form some opinions before responding to gm's low effort jabs.
Low effort jabs like that one right there? ouch.
That post was really badly phrased. I made it when I was mad at somthing irl and it definitely shows.
In post 468, Performer wrote:Hi all,
shrike's post where he picked apart my previous post , was questionable; but I don't have the time to get into that right now.
Note to Cheery: if others aren't happy about my situation at all, then I am ok with being replaced. But I do sincerely wish to continue on Sunday, if I am not replaced.
I don't really want to see you replaced. People replacing out seems to nullify most of the work we've done building a case against them, and I want to hear a response to my post from you.
In post 474, goodmorning wrote:
Ultimately, though, speculating on a No-Kill is much better for Scum than it is for Town, which is why we should stop it here.
Didn't we decide this about 5 pages ago? Who brought this up again?
Can you elaborate on your read on Performer?
I want to know how you're putting him in the same catergory as Azorius, who you've been tunneling all day.
Not sure how relevant this is, but RR started townreading Jake very early.
He says that he has "good feelings about this slot" in 449 when the only constructive posts Jake has made at this point are 447 and 448
In post 479, AzoriusSenate wrote:@goodmorning
I think it's coming up on a time where we need to decide on a lynch for today. I notice you have your vote on Jake. I 100% agree that Jake's slot has been leaning scum for me most of the game. I think I would lynch in Rat/Jake today.
Could you provide thoughts on who would be the best lynch for town or give us some people that we should look at? I would feel more comfortable with lynching my own scumreads or at the very least the scumreads of someone who is more experienced in forum mafia and is 99% town.
tbh I am not sure. I'm kind of convincing myself I really want a TIMU lynch for ~reasons~ but what will I do if I'm wrong????
In post 445, shrike wrote:
I understand that. That's why I think you should've read through the game first and form some opinions before responding to gm's low effort jabs.
Low effort jabs like that one right there? ouch.
That post was really badly phrased. I made it when I was mad at somthing irl and it definitely shows.
(actually i kind of enjoyed it, don't worry)
In post 474, goodmorning wrote:
Ultimately, though, speculating on a No-Kill is much better for Scum than it is for Town, which is why we should stop it here.
Didn't we decide this about 5 pages ago? Who brought this up again?
Can you elaborate on your read on Performer?
I want to know how you're putting him in the same catergory as Azorius, who you've been tunneling all day.
He's in the same category, not the same strength.
I put him there because my read on him has been suspicious from the start, and as he was starting to look good, he mentioned liking my posts deducing the set-up. Those posts were scummy, and no Townie should have liked them. I had my reasons for posting them pro-Town, but the fact is that post was actually meant to inform the Mafia, not the Town. As such, people liking those posts( TIMU and Performer ) look kinda scummy.
The reason TIMU isn't on my list as well then, is that There are only two scum, and the Most/TIMU slot has been giving me inconsistent reads, while Performer has always looked somewhat suspicious.
In post 479, AzoriusSenate wrote:@goodmorning
I think it's coming up on a time where we need to decide on a lynch for today. I notice you have your vote on Jake. I 100% agree that Jake's slot has been leaning scum for me most of the game. I think I would lynch in Rat/Jake today.
Could you provide thoughts on who would be the best lynch for town or give us some people that we should look at? I would feel more comfortable with lynching my own scumreads or at the very least the scumreads of someone who is more experienced in forum mafia and is 99% town.
tbh I am not sure. I'm kind of convincing myself I really want a TIMU lynch for ~reasons~ but what will I do if I'm wrong????
In post 445, shrike wrote:
I understand that. That's why I think you should've read through the game first and form some opinions before responding to gm's low effort jabs.
Low effort jabs like that one right there? ouch.
That post was really badly phrased. I made it when I was mad at somthing irl and it definitely shows.
(actually i kind of enjoyed it, don't worry)
In post 474, goodmorning wrote:
Ultimately, though, speculating on a No-Kill is much better for Scum than it is for Town, which is why we should stop it here.
Didn't we decide this about 5 pages ago? Who brought this up again?
In post 479, AzoriusSenate wrote:@goodmorning
I think it's coming up on a time where we need to decide on a lynch for today. I notice you have your vote on Jake. I 100% agree that Jake's slot has been leaning scum for me most of the game. I think I would lynch in Rat/Jake today.
Could you provide thoughts on who would be the best lynch for town or give us some people that we should look at? I would feel more comfortable with lynching my own scumreads or at the very least the scumreads of someone who is more experienced in forum mafia and is 99% town.
tbh I am not sure. I'm kind of convincing myself I really want a TIMU lynch for ~reasons~ but what will I do if I'm wrong????
I'm not opposed to a TIMU lunch. While I am uncertain about how I read them right now... I do feel like their flip will be an informative one.
In post 479, AzoriusSenate wrote:@goodmorning
I think it's coming up on a time where we need to decide on a lynch for today. I notice you have your vote on Jake. I 100% agree that Jake's slot has been leaning scum for me most of the game. I think I would lynch in Rat/Jake today.
Could you provide thoughts on who would be the best lynch for town or give us some people that we should look at? I would feel more comfortable with lynching my own scumreads or at the very least the scumreads of someone who is more experienced in forum mafia and is 99% town.
tbh I am not sure. I'm kind of convincing myself I really want a TIMU lynch for ~reasons~ but what will I do if I'm wrong????
Not sure what this is supposed to mean. If you're wrong then you lynch Town, you will be put into potential MyLo, and my flip puts some more evidence against RR and Jake. Don't see why a confirmed Town sees the need to say this. Why am I even pointing out weird statements for confirmed Town? Still, here we go again with you not telling the reason for lynching someone by the way. Please share it with us, we desire the information!
Anyway, I wouldn't mind lynching RR/Jake like Azorius. Speaking of Azor, I actually saw him in Epicmafia today XD
In post 490, Radical Rat wrote:
He's in the same category, not the same strength.
I put him there because my read on him has been suspicious from the start, and as he was starting to look good, he mentioned liking my posts deducing the set-up. Those posts were scummy, and no Townie should have liked them. I had my reasons for posting them pro-Town, but the fact is that post was actually meant to inform the Mafia, not the Town. As such, people liking those posts( TIMU and Performer ) look kinda scummy.
This reasoning confuses me a bit. You're accusing someone for liking posts you see as scummy. Wouldn't a member of the mafia be likely to pretend to dislike scummy posts in order to get a townie mislynched? Why did you make those posts in the first place if you think they help the mafia?
In post 490, Radical Rat wrote:
He's in the same category, not the same strength.
I put him there because my read on him has been suspicious from the start, and as he was starting to look good, he mentioned liking my posts deducing the set-up. Those posts were scummy, and no Townie should have liked them. I had my reasons for posting them pro-Town, but the fact is that post was actually meant to inform the Mafia, not the Town. As such, people liking those posts( TIMU and Performer ) look kinda scummy.
This reasoning confuses me a bit. You're accusing someone for liking posts you see as scummy. Wouldn't a member of the mafia be likely to pretend to dislike scummy posts in order to get a townie mislynched? Why did you make those posts in the first place if you think they help the mafia?
Well, if my posts benefit them, they'd want me alive as an informant. So they'd defend me, and if the rest lynch me they get to say "I told you so" and gain towncred.
That next bit's a difficult question to answer. I'm sorry, but I have to ask you to trust me there.
In post 479, AzoriusSenate wrote:@goodmorning
I think it's coming up on a time where we need to decide on a lynch for today. I notice you have your vote on Jake. I 100% agree that Jake's slot has been leaning scum for me most of the game. I think I would lynch in Rat/Jake today.
Could you provide thoughts on who would be the best lynch for town or give us some people that we should look at? I would feel more comfortable with lynching my own scumreads or at the very least the scumreads of someone who is more experienced in forum mafia and is 99% town.
tbh I am not sure. I'm kind of convincing myself I really want a TIMU lynch for ~reasons~ but what will I do if I'm wrong????
Not sure what this is supposed to mean. If you're wrong then you lynch Town, you will be put into potential MyLo, and my flip puts some more evidence against RR and Jake. Don't see why a confirmed Town sees the need to say this. Why am I even pointing out weird statements for confirmed Town? Still, here we go again with you not telling the reason for lynching someone by the way. Please share it with us, we desire the information!
Anyway, I wouldn't mind lynching RR/Jake like Azorius. Speaking of Azor, I actually saw him in Epicmafia today XD
Well, I can't really explain it because it hinges on things we shouldn't talk about.
If I'm wrong it'll probably destroy my confidence for a solid few days.
