UNI MUM Mafia (Day 3, Stay Gold Pony)

[RolePlay25]

Posts since TN has claimed Sharky as a scum read without a vote:

5

I win if I lynch all the scum, not all the "distractions to the town". Anyone else?

[Jeanne11]

RolePlay is right. Stop this tomfoolery, please.

[Jeanne11]

@Klingon I tried, but they responded by attacking me as a player, forcing me to defend myself.

[Klingoncelt]

But roles need to be alive to do stuff. But if I am lynched anyway, might as well fullclaim.

Town Weak Tracker Neighbourizer.

Don't you feel silly now?

That's it? That's the mighty role you were flipping out over?

It's a PR, yes. It's useful, yes. But is it worth the noise you threw all over it? No.

[RolePlay25]

And my biggest pet peeve is when people try to lynch townie even if said townie has high utility to town. And no, I am not saying this just to save myself, but I sincerely believe it. For instance, if you were trying to lynch one of my townreads, I would be saying the same thing. In this case, it just so happens that I have utility.

But nobody else knows that. In fact, for all we know you're bullshitting us.

Look, the thing to do here is simply push whoever you think is scummy. OMGUS isn't the best reason, by the way.

Don't make yourself the center of attention, direct attention to your scumpicks.

So who is scummy, Mr mafia theory? Check your private topic for clues, please.

[Davsto]

Surely, TN, by letting yourself be distracted by Jeanne, you're doing exactly what the scum wants?

Your logic is flawed.

Jeanne is being kept alive to distract us from scum so you're going to vote her, distracting you from scum

Sounds like someone wants a mislynch but is already set up to be justified when Jeanne flips town.

VOTE: tn

[Klingoncelt]

KlingonCelt

Once again, I ask you to review the ISO: http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... er_sort=Go

This is not the ISO of a town player. Outside of rolefishing, and assuming that someone wasn't scum, he um... discussed mafia theory. And rolefished harder. And discussed mafia theory.

There isn't too much to discuss because he's actually doing literally nothing. And none of it's town.

This RolePlay toy amuses me.

I'll keep my vote on it.

[Klingoncelt]

And my biggest pet peeve is when people try to lynch townie even if said townie has high utility to town. And no, I am not saying this just to save myself, but I sincerely believe it. For instance, if you were trying to lynch one of my townreads, I would be saying the same thing. In this case, it just so happens that I have utility.

But nobody else knows that. In fact, for all we know you're bullshitting us.

Look, the thing to do here is simply push whoever you think is scummy. OMGUS isn't the best reason, by the way.

Don't make yourself the center of attention, direct attention to your scumpicks.

So who is scummy, Mr mafia theory? Check your private topic for clues, please.

You're really observant, aren't you?

I like the way you read my pronoun and everything.

[Cerberus v666]

Actually...shit. I actually agree with everything roleplay is saying. Fuck, that's terrible. Granted, it'd all low hanging fruit, as it were, but that doesn't mean his analysis isn't accurate. tns contradictions with regard to Jeanne are probably the most damning thing in the thread though.

tn, how can you go from stating she's capable of pulling off complex effective plays, while simultaneously calling her incompetent?

[Cerberus v666]

Oh, I should probably clarify that Im not necessarily sold about KC, but there could be merit. Titus, why aren't you pushing KC for their lack of "fire" this game?

[Edgar Allan Pro]

Ayo. Varsoon here. I'm on pretty limited connection so, like, don't expect a lot of me for the next four or five days.
Also the other head of this hydra is visting me IRL so, uh, you probably should just expect a lot less activity from this slot altogether.
I think it's fair to just go ahead and be like

V/LA until January 1st.

I haven't fully caught up yet but;

he did not mention Var's vote at all

i assumed his vote was in jest, a la the 'scary avatar' schtick he pulls every single game, ergo didn't think it important enough to mention

YOUR AVATAR ALWAYS CREEPS ME OUT AND THIS IS NOT A SCHTICK.

[Edgar Allan Pro]

Oh, I should probably follow Davsto onto this TN wagon.
Mostly because confient Davsto is only ever wrong when Davsto is scum, right?

[Edgar Allan Pro]

That should read 'confident'*

[Edgar Allan Pro]

Gonna also back the Cerberus horse (dog?) here and forward that question;
Titus, you saw scum Klingon get a little overwhelmed in Suikoden Mafia. What's different here?

[Edgar Allan Pro]

Garsh, this is like a 40 page shit show.
Blank slate me, cap.

[Edgar Allan Pro]

I really should get some food in my system,
I think I just tried to reference Goof Troop, Captain America, and Total Recall all at once.

But on the real, what's good?
Also I'm a reflexive friendly neighbor but only to the first person who targets me so whoever wants to confirm me as town can go ahead and do that.
The way it's worded is a little weird, you might not get confirmation until the night phase or following day or something I'll ask Dram but yeah

[Edgar Allan Pro]

Actually, reading over it, my role is kinda super vague, but at the very least its pro-town as heck, should confirm me as town (to one person) if used right, and yeah that's pretty much about it. Jury's still out on exactly how it works, so don't ask me about it. Like I said, if you wanna be my friend, target me before some other mook does.

[Learned Hand]

Not liking EAP saying neighbor = town.

If singlball, Klingon is almost certainly town. There's a big difference between here and Suikoden and her other scumgames. Not liking the OMGUS but Kling has always been focused on herself.

To that end, while I don't see any glaring flaws with Roleplay's analysis, the fact he's equally confident both are scum is jarring me. If Klingon is town and they are both equally scummy...that would make Sharky town.

I will flag Drixx and let him use our vote as he wishes till I feel better.

[Cerberus v666]

Not liking EAP saying neighbor = town.

If singlball, Klingon is almost certainly town. There's a big difference between here and Suikoden and her other scumgames. Not liking the OMGUS but Kling has always been focused on herself.

To that end, while I don't see any glaring flaws with Roleplay's analysis, the fact he's equally confident both are scum is jarring me. If Klingon is town and they are both equally scummy...that would make Sharky town.

I will flag Drixx and let him use our vote as he wishes till I feel better.

He said he's a reflexive friendly neighbor. I take that to mean at least one other party will get confirmation of his alignment.

[Learned Hand]

Oh friendly neighbor, I hate those.

~Titus

[Edgar Allan Pro]

It's like a weird, crummy version of cop.
What's there to hate?

[Learned Hand]

I caught scum d1. They fake claimed fn, changed from full FJ to three shot fn, had a buddy vouch and won flawlessly. InuYasha mafia.

Gtg to work.

~Titus

[Sharky5x]

This is going to sound bad.

Who shall I vote?

[Klingoncelt]

This is going to sound bad.

Who shall I vote?

Yes, it does sound bad.

'For

whom

shall I vote?'

And it still sounds bad.

[Elbirn]

Either way the answer is yourself.