NY 193 : Werewolf Mania (GAME OVER- TOWN WIN)

[Nero Cain]

He's never pro-town regardless of alignment yet he's also easy to read?

I think I have an ok bead on Ika's meta. I know I know. "META CAN BE MESSED WITH!"

but

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=55&t=60340

and

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=56&t=61893

is what I associate with a scum Ika.

As for his claim-I think there is some possibility that he fakeclaims seer to out any real seer but I'm willing to sit on it for a day or two. If he IS a seer then there's gonna be scum on his wagon.

[JarJarDrinks]

just had a thought:

Silver and Ika said they have a Hydra together. Maybe they're both scum here and were using the hydra thread to discuss this game (basically illegal daytalk)?

[Ricastle]

Ric.

Are you seriously still hung up on that?

[Nero Cain]

no

[TheBlueRose]

just had a thought:

Silver and Ika said they have a Hydra together. Maybe they're both scum here and were using the hydra thread to discuss this game (basically illegal daytalk)?

It would make sense why they both had to be forced replaced. And it would give a reason to the claim earlier that it couldn't be do to two scum revealing roles to one another and making it less likely that was the reason for the replace.

[Xkfyu]

We aren't lynching any of Ika or Almost today: Its ABR or Ric.

With Blackstar, Cobalt and Snowman as maybes.

Well, you've certainly changed your tune about ika.

[Ricastle]

no

Then what?

[Xkfyu]

just had a thought:

Silver and Ika said they have a Hydra together. Maybe they're both scum here and were using the hydra thread to discuss this game (basically illegal daytalk)?

If they are really as good of friends as they say they are, then I'm sure they would have some other means, such as some sort of chat client, of conducting illegal day talk without needing to do it in a thread where mods can see it.

[BlackStar]

They asked to be replaced. That's what makes the whole thing so weird. Do you think the mod would tell us what happened if we asked?

[Nero Cain]

RC is one of the worst town players on the site. You'd do well to ignore him.

:/

i mean, ok sure. I'm willing to buy the "atleast 1 is town" thing but you came in and tried to throw shade my way and that doesn't seem real town to me.

What shade are you even talking about? Like do you really mean RC's telling everyone to slow down? While I didn't see a good enough reason to just stop everything, I don't see why that is casting shade against you. Unless I missed something? But if not I don't get why you'd think that is scummy. Like "Oh no I must kill Ika now or else. Why are you stopping me?"

My post about throwing shade was directed at Ric not RC. Like someone had asked why they (ika and Silver) were replaced. The obvious reason is that they talked about the game outside of the game thread. Thus I said-though I didn't of any implications at the time. In comes Ric who throws shade at me and implied that I was scum that knew that both Silver and Ika were town. From my perspective this looked more like scum trying to find somewhere to go instead of scum hunting. Also given the quoted post above I am more than happy to watch that hang.

[TheBlueRose]

Possibly but if it would involve giving away hints towards the game I don't think the mod would let us know that specific information. The most we may get could just be that they broke the rules.

[Xkfyu]

They asked to be replaced. That's what makes the whole thing so weird. Do you think the mod would tell us what happened if we asked?

Well, Fraggernaut stated that he was waiting on a response from a List Mod. Correct me if I'm wrong because I'm not sure exactly how the hierarchy of the site works, but it seems to me like a "higher-up" decision needed to be made, which leads me to believe that something sketchy was going on.

[Nero Cain]

Do you think the mod would tell us what happened if we asked?

no. I still think they likely talked to each other about the game outside. There IS a possibility that Ika just didn't want me to death tunnel him but since the mod said they were contacting a site mod this is very likely to be a rule break.

[Nero Cain]

also

vote:ABR

[Xkfyu]

Do you think the mod would tell us what happened if we asked?

no. I still think they likely talked to each other about the game outside. There IS a possibility that Ika just didn't want me to death tunnel him but since the mod said they were contacting a site mod this is very likely to be a rule break.

Actually, I don't think it had anything to do with you, at all.

Ika and SilverWolf were perfectly fine with arguing with you, and everyone else, to start with. However, neither of them posted anything, except their replace requests posts, after I posted my case against them in Post 414.

Now, I'm not saying that I was the reason that their slot became compromised, but the fact that they were fighting it out hard before my post, and then completely gave up after it, suggests that something changed their minds between my post and their replace request posts. And all you did in that 4 hour window was post this:

and I don't feel that any of my reads so far necessitate a vote

What are these reads?

[Xkfyu]

EBWOP

Should be Post 414.

[I Am Innocent]

Rough week all, just found out my dad might have prostate cancer. So yeah my head really ain't into this right now.

Been phone reading tho, going to agree with my top two town reads and

unvote blackstar
Vote ABR

I'll do a full reread and thoughts post later

[RadiantCowbells]

ABR wagon is nonsense. where the fuck did it come from?

[Nero Cain]

ABR/Silver is not town bro.

[BlackStar]

ABR/Silver is not town bro.

How do you know?

[BlackStar]

UNVOTE:

[Nero Cain]

ABR/Silver is not town bro.

How do you know?

its called a read, you have those when you are town and scum hunting.

[BlackStar]

Interesting. Have you heard of this thing called explaining your reads? I hear it's all the rage these days

[Nero Cain]

you didn't ask me to explain, you asked me some nonsensical "how do I know" bullshit.

[Xkfyu]

ABR wagon is nonsense. where the fuck did it come from?

Other than Ricastle, which wagon would make sense to you?