Alrighty guys. I'm replacing someone but i'm not sure who yet.
I've read the thread and i'm just going to throw out that I find Eroto really strange. I'm not saying suspicious as i'm leaning toward town but PG really ruined it for Eroto. If i'm ever a mod I highly doubt i'll let PG play in my game. I'm kinda surprised he didn't quote his role pm.
We've got waaaaaaaay too many overly wordy people in this game. There's no need for these massive posts Cicero and Gorgon. I find it just clutters the thread when you could've just said what you needed to say in a paragraph or two. However, that's your individual playstyles so i'll just try and manage. We're on page 13 with almost nothing to go on. PG usurped a major portion of this thread. I'm thinking we should all post our scumdars so we can start to focus on who's the most suspicious and when we get a scum we can look at they're list.
Shaka, way too tunnelvisioned. I'd like to see Shaka express opinions on more than BM because we can't win if we only focus on one person. Shaka seems to have shown little interest in this thread outside of BM and that alarms me. There's too little to go on for me to make much more than a guess on Shaka's alignment.
Slightly scummy
SSF, actively lurked until being called out for it. SSF, what was the point of your lurking? Were you trying to show us something? You never explained it, you just started to integrate back into the game without an explanation and i'd like one. Has seemed to add very little substance to the game overall and for that i'm going to
FoS: SSF
.
Theo, i'm currently playing a game or two with him and this seems to be his playstyle. I don't agree with most of his ideas but generally he has seemed to want to contribute when he's got time. I'm not going to FoS him but IGMEOY Theo.
AlyG, i'm in a game with him right now and he's lurking there too. I'm not sure what to make of it because I don't know his alignment but generally lurkers hurt us more than help us. I'm not for lynching lurkers but i'm all for pressuring them to vote. Currently sinse it's the best it's my best (and only) tool i'm going to
Vote: AlyG
. Start posting, add contribution, post your scumdar, set up a case against someone and stop lurking.
CA, can't really say much. Heavy lurking but I can't really get on him for it because of his computer having trouble. CA, post your scumdar, i'd really like to hear your opinions on things so far.
BM/Kekeng, i've gotta say, i've read a few games with BM in them and I definitely don't see BM as the same in those games as town compared to this game. I'm very suspicious of him but i'd like to give the replacement time to add their thoughts and opinions before I lynch. Currently this is who i'm most suspicious of but i'd prefer to pull lurkers out of lurking right now than lynch a 60% scum candidate.
Gorgon, with quite a few large posts i've found myself reading them and at the end wondering two things. 1) Why in the world did it take so long to say that? and 2) What was added that wasn't already out there? I have struggled to find where Gorgon has actively contributed much more than "I agree and here's how"s. However i'm not at all inclined to lynch him today as there are bigger fish showing their stripes (hmm, that doesn't sound right).
Cicero, honestly i'm getting a sincere read from him but i'm not liking what I see. If I were to vote solely on gut, this is where my vote would go. I've seen quite a bit of arguing game mechanics and strikingly little scumhunting.
FoS: Cicero
. I can't go much further on a gut reaction though.
Pwayne, seems to be acting normally. There was something in the earlier parts of this game that struck me as odd and I can go back and get it if asked for but that's really the only thing that stands out to me. Seems town.
Jalyn/Daedalus, lurker. There's pretty much nothing to say here other than that if you weren't just replacing and AlyG hadn't acted strangely earlier my vote would be on her.
It seems you were just what was needed to kickstart this game again.