Newbie 1673: University of Mafiascum Class 108 - D4- OVER!

[Usted]

so both scum were on both trains.

[Zar]

Day 3, Votecount 1

Not Voting (5)

: newbieinmafia, Usted, soulmonarch, Extrapolated Eagle, Workdawg

With 5 alive it takes 3 to lynch or to no lynch.

Deadline

: Saturday February 13, 2016 8:15 PM  New York Time. (GMT-5)

Countdown to deadline

: (expired on 2016-02-13 21:15:00)

[Workdawg]

That's actually a really interesting, and disappointing, observation. It would make vote count analysis a lot more tricky. I don't really subscribe to VCA necessarily, but I know some people do. I guess I haven't seen much of it in this game though.

Also, I was pretty busy with work yesterday, but I hope it'll be a slower day today so I can finish up my post. I've been prepping another wagon analysis like I did for Ness' wagon but it's not quite done yet.

[Workdawg]

Alright, so here we go...

Post 457 - EE votes (L-3), possibly a lurker?
Post 471 - newbie votes (L-2), reasoning in post 440, Partly PoE (giving Workdawg and Kahlan town reads and Usted's claim) "feels like she's coasting"
Post 474 - No vote, but soul has "healthy distrust" of Huntress do to quiteness
Post 489 -

Usted votes (L-1)

- because his vote on EE didn't spark any interest?
Post 492 -

newbie unvotes (L-2)

- no reason given
Post 499 - EE says "Huntress is number one" (scum read)
Post 508 - soul says he'd prefer a Huntress lynch because of her play "would be very wise if she were scum"
Post 510 - Workdawg expresses frustration over her slot still not really contributing much
Post 518/519 - Workdawg engages Huntress attempting to get content
Post 524 - newbie reiterates that soul and Huntress are her top scum picks
Post 539 -

soul votes (L-1)

, citing previous comments about her being on the top of his list and says its time to "vote or get off the pot"
Post 551 - newbie gives intent to hammer
Post 553 - Workdawg says "... large ping on scumdar for Huntress" after the "RVS voting shenanigans"
Post 557 -

Usted unvotes (L-2)

and posts intent to hammer Eagle at the same time. Says switching to Huntress was only to test to see who would unvote from her.
Post 568 - Workdawg expresses concern about Huntress again based on the "RVS voting shenanigans"
Post 574 -

Workdawg votes (L-1)

, due to new revelations in the "RVS voting shenanigans"
Post 587 - newbie states intent to hammer due to deadline
Post 589 - Eagle reaffirms scum read on Huntress
Post 590 -

newbie hammers

(Eagle, soul, Workdawg, newbie)

I really don't see anything particularly interesting about this wagon, unfortunately. EE starts it out and the rest of it us sort of mosey on to it for various reasons. Newbie hammered but she was already on the wagon early on and someone had to hammer at that point.

Looking at it objectively, I would say that my voting probably looks the most suspect since I got on the wagon near the end of the day. However, I actually developed a case against her and truly thought that she was scummy (not just due to a lack of content at that point), so I feel it was justified. Everyone else seems like they were on the wagon because of a lack of content. No one really responded (other than soul making a couple of comments here and there, and Eagle commenting right at the end) which is a little bit curious to me, but oh well.

[Zar]

soulmonarch, newbieinmafia, and Extrapolated Eagle are being prodded

[Extrapolated Eagle]

Hi. Don't prod me!

~.Nope. All three of you are still gaining the prod. ~~~.Zar

[Extrapolated Eagle]

Sorry, I got distracted mid read. I'll keep trying to catch up, this is a big game

[newbieinmafia]

Sorry, I have gotten pretty busy this week so I haven't finished rereading. I will try to finish by Friday and give a more content (sort of-- since I am not good with long posts) read list on either Friday or Saturday.

Post 492 - newbie unvotes (L-2) - no reason given

I gave my reason in the same post.

To me, the "RVS voting shenanigans" case is grasping at straws at best. I have said it before that I like 581 as I kind of agree with what Huntress said. I would say your case against EE or soul is stronger than your "RVS voting" case against Huntress.

[Usted]

So here is how I see it.
I am pretty much confirmed town. Kahlan being tracker backs my story.
We have 2 VT's and 2 Goon's floating around. Now, at this point, other than myself, everyone is going to claim to be a VT and try to play like one. However, we have 2 actual VT's. Since I am confirmed town EACH of these two townies have a 2/3 chance of picking scum. Basically at this point everyone needs to post their reads on everyone else. As to not skew anyones opinions I would like to go last (I only have a 50-50 randomly picking scum, where as the VT's have significantly better odds).

[Workdawg]

That seems pretty reasonable. Would you like to pick the order?

[Usted]

That seems pretty reasonable. Would you like to pick the order?

I don't want to influence this in any way. Just post yours when you have it, and that goes for everyone.

[Workdawg]

I think that since you are the only known town you should call the shots here. IMO, you call out people in the order that you feel they are scum so that their answers can't be adjusted based on what everyone else says.

[soulmonarch]

Hey folks, been busy the last few days. Coming back later this evening to catch up!

[Usted]

Alphabetical
Extrapolated Eagle, newbieinmafia, soulmonarch, Workdawg

I'll go last

[soulmonarch]

Out of respect for the above, I'll hold my opinions.

Besides, I could use the extra time anyway. I wasn't kidding when I said I've been busy. ><

[Zar]

Day 3, Votecount 2

Not Voting (5)

: newbieinmafia, Usted, soulmonarch, Extrapolated Eagle, Workdawg

With 5 alive it takes 3 to lynch or to no lynch.

Deadline

: Saturday February 13, 2016 8:15 PM  New York Time. (GMT-5)

Countdown to deadline

: (expired on 2016-02-13 21:15:00)

[Workdawg]

That kind of defeats the purpose of my suggestion, unless your scum reads happen to be in that order. But whatever floats your boat.

[Usted]

Me posting my scum reads before everyone else defeats the purpose. I dont want to influence any of the other 4 players reads

[Usted]

Eh, I am kinda over this game.
VOTE: eagle

[newbieinmafia]

I haven't finished reading. I still don't think Eagle is scum though.

[Extrapolated Eagle]

Usted I'm not caught up yet but please don't just throw the game away just because you don't care about it anymore. It's anti town and I'd hate to lose in lylo because conftown got apathetic.

[Usted]

UNVOTE:

[Usted]

Eagle/Newbie mafia. they are clearly lurking
VOTE: eagle

[Extrapolated Eagle]

You mean .... We're posting more than everyone else? That wasn't the definition of lurking the last time I looked. But if you'd like to keep your vote on me, do so. I guess I can't hold myself to blame for the loss based on the apparent thought-void in the one person who shouldn't have gotten a role that could be conftown. You want me to catch up or do you want me to sit around and do nothing like everyone else? Or would you rather I bs a bunch of reads like you since apparently you don't care about this game and no one else should either.

Screw you if you aren't going to give me time. Screw you if you're going to sit there impatiently screaming in the back seat "are we there yet?" How about you nag one of the people who hasn't even seemed to attempt to put anything into the game yet?

[Extrapolated Eagle]

I'm sorry for the rant. If you were just going to throw the game away after me reading seventeen pages in between real life and other games, I wish you would have told me earlier, I would much rather have had that time to do other things