Mini 499: Just Your typical Mafia Game GAME OVER!!!!!!!!

[ChocolateAttack]

Dude CA, there are 14 pages. Surely you've got more than that.

Nope, that is I got, take it or leave it. ;P

Mod Edit

Vote Count

AlyG- 5 (cicero, pwayne66, somestrangeflea, Theo, White)

White- 1 (AlyG)
Jalyn- 1 (Gorgon)
Kakeng- 1 (shaka!!)


Not voting (4): Chocolate Attack, Erotomachia, Jalyn, Kakeng

7 to lynch

[somestrangeflea]

Are you a backup of a specific role (if you are,

don't

say what it is), or will you simply replace the first town power role to die, regardless of what that is?

[shaka!!]

White asked him to claim.

My apologies.

[theopor_COD]

Guys i'm not very interested in the game and i aren't really following it. I'm in a lot more games and i can't really keep up. I don't wish to be replaced

YET

but i might as well claim.

If your not interested and can't keep up, I'd rather you were replaced. If you want to continue then I think if your pro-town you need to apply yourself a little more and do some scum hunting. Who do you suspect?

As for the claim I'm neutral about it. I could see one being used but then again as it's been pointed it can hardly be counter claimed so is an awfully safe claim for scum.

Chocolate Attack's recent postings are poor aswell, Jalyn/Eroto thoughts?

[White]

or will you simply replace the first town power role to die, regardless of what that is?

Ding ding ding. That's what a backup is.

AlyG, i'm pretty frustrated with how you've played. You shouldn't claim and then say you want to be replaced. You do a great disservice to whoever has to pick up the pieces behind you.

However, seems kinda odd for a scum to claim a useless role(on day1) so i'm going to

unvote: AlyG

for now. You're not off the hook by any means though.

Seeing as i've got a free vote....

Vote: ChocolateAttack

I'd suggest you read the thread again and get some opinions because right now you're not helping us find scum, which is scummy.

[cicero]

However, seems kinda odd for a scum to claim a useless role(on day1) so i'm going to

unvote: AlyG

for now. You're not off the hook by any means though.

I would say it is the kind of claim that won't get contradicted, which is the only kind he COULD make on day 1 if he was scum.

[White]

I highly doubt AlyG is so interested in this game as to fake claim backup.

[cicero]

I highly doubt AlyG is so interested in this game as to fake claim backup.

Well then, I suppose we could go back to my idea of lynching Flea...

[somestrangeflea]

Ding ding ding. That's what a backup is.

Meh. Normally, backups are given a specific role, like Backup Doc (Nurse), or things like that.

Meh, whatever...

[pwayne66]

I would say it is the kind of claim that won't get contradicted, which is the only kind he COULD make on day 1 if he was scum.

this is my thinking as well

I highly doubt AlyG is so interested in this game as to fake claim backup.

though this is true as well.

I have to remain absolutely suspicious of this claim though.

[White]

I agree, i'm in now way clearing AlyG and his future replacement (inevitable imo).

Well, who else is scummy looking?

Hey Shaka, what do you think of Gorgon? Could I get a paragraph?

[somestrangeflea]

However, seems kinda odd for a scum to claim a useless role(on day1) so i'm going to

unvote: AlyG

for now. You're not off the hook by any means though.

I would say it is the kind of claim that won't get contradicted, which is the only kind he COULD make on day 1 if he was scum.

Just to clarify this (cicero bork'd his tags), White said the above, not me...

[shaka!!]

Besides for Pwayne (and myself) I find Gorgon to be the most pro town player. I like his contribution to the game so far, his posts are long but they are well thought out, I don't think of them as a wall of words.
His voting habbit seems to be in the best interest of the town.

As for the rest of the game, I think you are putting to much attention on in the inactive player, and should focus on the people who are here to respond to our questions. We've pressure AlyG and got a repsonse, lets move on. I think the mafia are hiding with us trying to pressure the inactive players.

I still think Borchmore/BM/Dudewhoreplacedhim is scum. All three of the players has played (imo) badly. I can elaborate if you want, but I won't now cause I am at work.

Something I've just picked up, really White, why did you want AlyG to claim? I'm thinking that maybe you were hoping to go a nk target?

Also, if AlyG really is a back up, that means we have power roles amongst us.

Forgive my spelling, I'm at work and we don't have firefox (spell checker d:)

[shaka!!]

EBWOP
I'm thinking that maybe you were hoping to get a nk target?

[White]

An understandable thought. It seem like my love for claims is really just a bad idea all together. It's a shame really.

[shaka!!]

So you have no reason for suggesting to him to claim then?

[shaka!!]

Offtopic:

Theres no shame in love.

[White]

I love claims and I think (and still do) that it helps deal with suspicions. Had he claimed cop or rb or something more useful then we could actively use that to inhibit scum and if successful we could out scum. So it wasn't baseless but it was coupled with a love for claims. I also thought that it would either clear him for the most part of suspicion or tip us off that he's a fake.

[shaka!!]

I highly doubt AlyG is so interested in this game as to fake claim backup.

though this is true as well.

I have to remain absolutely suspicious of this claim though.

I disagree, it takes two seconds to realize what is and isn't a safe claim. It requires no interest to think of that, also note that AlyG doesn't wish to be replaced.

[White]

...yet.

I feel at this rate it's inevitable unless AlyG really starts showing an interest.

[Kakeng]

Besides for Pwayne (and myself) I find Gorgon to be the most pro town player. I like his contribution to the game so far, his posts are long but they are well thought out, I don't think of them as a wall of words.
His voting habbit seems to be in the best interest of the town.

As for the rest of the game, I think you are putting to much attention on in the inactive player, and should focus on the people who are here to respond to our questions. We've pressure AlyG and got a repsonse, lets move on. I think the mafia are hiding with us trying to pressure the inactive players.

I still think Borchmore/BM/Dudewhoreplacedhim is scum. All three of the players has played (imo) badly. I can elaborate if you want, but I won't now cause I am at work.

Something I've just picked up, really White, why did you want AlyG to claim? I'm thinking that maybe you were hoping to go a nk target?

Also, if AlyG really is a back up, that means we have power roles amongst us.

Forgive my spelling, I'm at work and we don't have firefox (spell checker d:)

I may have misinterpreted you wrong, but you think they are scum as they are playing badly?

[AlyG]

I'm a back-up up fort anu pro-town role.

[shaka!!]

I still think Borchmore/BM/Dudewhoreplacedhim is scum. All three of the players has played (imo) badly. I can elaborate if you want, but I won't now cause I am at work.

I may have misinterpreted you wrong, but you think they are scum as they are playing badly?[/quote]

Well if someone isn't playing a good pro town game they are going to be seen as scum.

Sorry again, rush posting from work, I didn't mean bad play in general. I meant bad town play.

[Gorgon]

I'm a back-up up fort anu pro-town role.

Fort? Wow, that must be a great role.

Nah, I get you. You're a backup for any pro-town role.

I'm inclined to believe this. White has a good point when he says that AlyG is unlikely to make something like this up, given his lack of interest in the game ... although this could be a ruse, of course. I tend to think not, though.

Anyway, AlyG, do you have some thoughts on the game so far? You're not just going to sit there uselessly throughout the game, are you?

[White]

I hope not.

Guys, i'm going to be V/LA until Monday as the expected latest. Sorry.