In post 308, Aristophanes wrote: In post 304, Heat wrote: In post 301, Aristophanes wrote: In post 296, Heat wrote:I do not like how BlueTrin came out of 10/11 pages with only null reads, with the most being leans. That doesn't sit well with me at all
I think he explained why pretty well, though I will maybe possibly eventually look at other D1s of his to see if he's always wishy washy like this.
But even with the amount of explanation he did, I'd expect something a bit more solid.
There were a lot of null with modifiers.
I took them as "light town" and "light scum" reads, which I make all the time in readslists.
Blue, can you confirm or deny that this is a proper marker of the strength of your differing null reads?
This is correct, I didn't realise that you would prefer light town or light scum rather than null/town or null/scum. If this is causing confusion, I can just use "light town" and "light scum". I am far from being 100% sure at the moment and this is my way to say it. In the end, I understand that you have to go with your strongest read even if you are not 100% sure.
My strongest scum reads were Xtorm and Lilith. For Lilith I had made already a post about why (
199), it was the case. For Xtorm, it is that not only he posts very few but he joins wagons a bit late like if wanted to tip the votes once there was a few votes:
201
281
But for Xtorm, I like his questioning of Jackal in
235
8:20AM I need to go to work here, I will probably finish after the dead line but I will try to log on my phone at some point during the day.
PEDIT, it is my way to say that I am not 100% sure,I already explained my choices and put my vote.