Mini 1761: Red Neighborhood - Day 2

[Aristophanes]

I should reread some stuff here.

I think I was called out for having stagnant reads at some point here?

I don't think they are stagnant. I think they are D1 confidence and I have yet to be proven wrong on them. So I stand by them for now.
Whatever though.

[Persivul]

On the other hand, SRMP hasn't really taken any hard stances and seems null to me.

I intended to read the entire game before making any comments but I couldn't pass this by. Not taking hard stances isn't null, it's scummy.

[Persivul]

VOTE: JohnnyFarrar

Seems to me like he's realised he can no longer fluff his way through the game and has gone quiet.

I've been thinking that for some time now.

[Dwlee99]

Haahahahaahahhahahaa
LMAO

[Persivul]

Public Service Announcement:

Someone has recently asked me if crumbing counts as breaking the rules. This has never been the case (since people crumb roles in every game, and often unintentionally). However, I will explain it once and for all this game.

Crumbs are not cryptic messages. Crumbing is dropping hints about your role in the things you say. Not in the actual syntax of it.

e.g.

This is

crumbing

: "I'm 100% positive that ___ is mafia. One another note, I'll likely die tonight."

This is a

cryptic message

: "I wish that you All would stop Messing around. After how far we've Come, we could lose the game, On top of having lynched a Power role."

The capital letters spell out I AM A COP. That's a cryptic message.



tl;dr cryptic messages are "puzzles", more or less. Crumbing is merely letting people make implications.

You can say what you want in your game but IMO what you call a cryptic message is a crumb (and wiki agrees IIRC) and what you call a crumb is a soft claim.

[JohnnyFarrar]

Boy

[Persivul]

my role pm says otherwise

Literally my least favourite argument.

Agreed.

[Dwlee99]

Persivul why are you going back completely on your no response until done reading?

[Persivul]

Individual notes, order of least posts to most.

Number one: didn't like the start - 60 and 193 seemed like scum asking question to appear to be engaged, but 260, 290 and following are a lot better.

Hasta: seems like newbtown. 65 reads as genuine curiosity about the setup, which I also have and was a little surprised no one else got into it. I agree with 299. 324 reads OK in context of the entire ISO. Don't like that he's sitting on his initial vote.

Ricastle: town lean based on meta tells that I don't want to go into.

More tomorrow.

[Some Random Mafia Player]

I should reread some stuff here.

I think I was called out for having stagnant reads at some point here?

I don't think they are stagnant. I think they are D1 confidence and I have yet to be proven wrong on them. So I stand by them for now.
Whatever though.

You havent been proven right either...

And everyone wants me dead ;-;

[Dwlee99]

I should reread some stuff here.

I think I was called out for having stagnant reads at some point here?

I don't think they are stagnant. I think they are D1 confidence and I have yet to be proven wrong on them. So I stand by them for now.
Whatever though.

You havent been proven right either...

And everyone wants me dead ;-;

Is this scum caught for the wrong reason? ^^^

[Persivul]

@Garmr: do you have reads on insanity & lowell?

[JohnnyFarrar]

More tomorrow.

[Persivul]

Sorry Johnny, but I have images turned off.

Why are you responding to me without saying anything?

[Garmr]

@Garmr: do you have reads on insanity & lowell?

Town for insanity and keeping track of lowell trying to find something will nudge him out of null.

[Number_0ne]

With the deadline approaching soonish, we should start to work on picking a lynch. So far we're just sitting around with a couple of votes tossed around on various people, and this isn't the way to catch scum.

I still want Hasta lynched, but I guess a SRMP lynch is alright.

VOTE: SMRP

[Garmr]

I'll lay down my vote on smrp if my ari wagon doesn't pick up.

[Lowell]

I reread ari's iso based on your push. I have to say I'm a little bit starting to buy it. I gave johnny and ari a pass for similar reasons on the first couple pages. In ari's case he does seem to just be cruising. Still not a scumread, but point taken, I'll move him into my neutral camp.

[Lowell]

also putting up V/LA tag, as I may be without internet for the next couple of days.

[Some Random Mafia Player]

Suppose im better than NL.

im no PR, so nothing shocking to change your minds.

[Garmr]

VOTE: smrp

[JohnnyFarrar]

did anyone ask for a claim? why dis happen? we're days out aren't we?

[Dwlee99]

Wait was that a hammer?
They did claim, vanilla, though.

[Dwlee99]

That's 5 votes, we need 7. What'chu talkin about.

[Ricastle]

Suppose im better than NL.

im no PR, so nothing shocking to change your minds.

From my experience going ahead against this has led to a mislynch more often than not.

did anyone ask for a claim? why dis happen? we're days out aren't we?

I'd much rather lynch this, on the other hand.

VOTE: JohnnyFarrar