Open 624 Fire and Ice - Fire Mafia Wins

[SnarkySnowman]

~Most Ice~
Masq
Shinobi
Firebringer
VLG
Aristo
Something Smart
~Least Ice~

Was what I meant - my b.

VLG is still definitely scum though.

[Viva La Gloria]

~Most Ice~
Masq
Shinobi
Firebringer
VLG
Aristo
Something Smart
~Least Ice~

Was what I meant - my b.

VLG is still definitely scum though.

Not a chance. Bye dude.

[Viva La Gloria]

Oh, and that 'new' most-least ice list is basically {3 people who didn't vote SO}{3 people who did, with me as most scummy of them}

So extremely fabricated.

[SnarkySnowman]

Salty that I caught you for maybe not the right reason?

[SnarkySnowman]

You're 110% scum though.

[Viva La Gloria]

Your reads are fake as shit, your push on me is awful, you had to retract your entire readslist when I called you out on it, and there's no visible thought process that leads to your asinine conclusions.

If you're not scum then you're a fairly awful player.

[SnarkySnowman]

Well, maybe wait and see what others say. Tell me why you're not scum, other than because I'm "a fairly awful player".

[SnarkySnowman]

Your frustration looks fake as shit imo

[Firebringer]

Oh, and that 'new' most-least ice list is basically {3 people who didn't vote SO}{3 people who did, with me as most scummy of them}

So extremely fabricated.

Don't agree with this.

[Firebringer]

~Most Ice~
Masq
Shinobi
Firebringer
VLG
Aristo
Something Smart
~Least Ice~

Was what I meant - my b.

VLG is still definitely scum though.

I don't think Shinobi is likely ice imo.
Masq possibly but not sure.

[Viva La Gloria]

Well, maybe wait and see what others say. Tell me why you're not scum, other than because I'm "a fairly awful player".

I'm not getting lynched. You might though!
You've given no reasons to scumread me and the people who are actually scumhunting are fairly universally townreading me.
No one thinks that I'm likely to be Ice in particular, and thinking that I'm more likely to be Ice than, say, Aristo makes absolutely no sense.
I don't even have a case to answer to try to get us on the same page because you frankly haven't made a case. You just declared me scum with no reasoning.
Like I'm pretty fine lynching you at this point. If you're town then you me an asston of explanation.

[Firebringer]

You're 110% scum though.

Definitely don't agree with this.

[Viva La Gloria]

Oh, and that 'new' most-least ice list is basically {3 people who didn't vote SO}{3 people who did, with me as most scummy of them}

So extremely fabricated.

Don't agree with this.

Why do you believe that any more thought when into Snarky's reads than he's posted?
His reads don't jive whatsoever and the Ice list is indeed the 3 people who didn't vote -> 3 who did.
Do you think having me as most likely of the SO voters to be scum makes any sense whatsoever?
I don't think I make a ton of sense as Fire either but given that it's not as smoking gun obvious I'm not even going to address that.

[Firebringer]

Why do you believe that any more thought when into Snarky's reads than he's posted?
His reads don't jive whatsoever and the Ice list is indeed the 3 people who didn't vote -> 3 who did.
Do you think having me as most likely of the SO voters to be scum makes any sense whatsoever?
I don't think I make a ton of sense as Fire either but given that it's not as smoking gun obvious I'm not even going to address that.

It makes sense in a way, but I don't think its wrong to think in those terms.
I don't know If I myself am making sense right now, I have null on snarky, and most games I have been in with him I have read him as such and lynched him because he was null and I think he was town.

Anyways, I would prefer Masq lynch over anyone else today.
I don't trust her

[texcat]

Day 3, Votecount 5

Firebringer(2):

Something_Smart, Aristophanes

SnarkySnowman (1):

Viva La Gloria

Aristophanes(1):

Shinobi

Viva La Gloria(1):

SnarkySnowman

Not Voting (2):

Firebringer, Masquerade

With 7 alive it takes 4 to lynch or to no lynch.

Deadline

: Friday, February 26, 2016 9:00 am (Texas time)

Countdown to deadline

: (expired on 2016-02-26 09:00:00)

[Something_Smart]

Snarky, that is horrible. Your reasons don't follow logically from the thread, and your reads don't follow logically from your reasons. Your vote on Viva indicates that you have not read for content, only for associations, and they only tell part of the story.
Then, when Viva is incredulous, you change it to make him feel better.
It doesn't look like you can make good cases... why don't you sheep somebody else's (like mine). Go back and read Fire and SO and tell me how they could possibly not be buddies.

[Aristophanes]

Oh wow, Snarky, wtf was that post man!?

None of the sections support each other, the reads are random, and it lacks any actual analysis (or at least any visible points of analysis).
Someone accused me of IIOA before? No. Thus is IIOA!

But is it scum?

[Shinobi]

lol @ Snarky post.

[Shinobi]

This is not a terrible post.

Tell me why you think that.

I thought I'd have something in-depth to say wrt this but I don't.
I agree with his assessments of Aero/droog and thought that his recap of Fire's posts was accurate.

Not entirely sure what you're looking for, tbh.

[Shinobi]

I remember writing a bit on Aero myself, actually.
I can't remember why I dropped it.

[Viva La Gloria]

Snarky, that is horrible. Your reasons don't follow logically from the thread, and your reads don't follow logically from your reasons. Your vote on Viva indicates that you have not read for content, only for associations, and they only tell part of the story.
Then, when Viva is incredulous, you change it to make him feel better.
It doesn't look like you can make good cases... why don't you sheep somebody else's (like mine). Go back and read Fire and SO and tell me how they could possibly not be buddies.

This sort of assumes that he's town.

Why?

[SnarkySnowman]

I'm very confident in my picks for fire mafia. Not so sure about the ice one.

[Viva La Gloria]

That basically reads to me as 'I'm only scumhunting one faction!'

I wonder if scum would actually be so blunt about it.

[Something_Smart]

Snarky, that is horrible. Your reasons don't follow logically from the thread, and your reads don't follow logically from your reasons. Your vote on Viva indicates that you have not read for content, only for associations, and they only tell part of the story.
Then, when Viva is incredulous, you change it to make him feel better.
It doesn't look like you can make good cases... why don't you sheep somebody else's (like mine). Go back and read Fire and SO and tell me how they could possibly not be buddies.

This sort of assumes that he's town.

Why?

I'm assuming that he would try to act like he's town. It doesn't particularly feel like a scumcase, just a bad one.

[SnarkySnowman]

As in, i have a much better idea of who Silverwolf's partner could be and not so good an idea of who SO's partner could be. More gutreads for the latter, and more certainty for the former.

I'm still pretty certain you're fire VLG.