Open 624 Fire and Ice - Fire Mafia Wins

[texcat]

SnarkySnowman, town Doctor, has been melted and incinerated.
Masquerade, Vanilla townie, has been iced.

Day 4, Vountcount 0

Not Voting (5):

Firebringer, Viva La Gloria, Something_Smart, Aristophanes, Shinobi

With 5 alive it takes 3 to lynch or to no lynch.

Deadline

: Monday, March 14, 2016 9:00 am (Texas time)

Countdown to deadline

: (expired on 2016-03-14 09:00:00)

[Aristophanes]

Well shit.

[Something_Smart]

Firebringer is Ice, Viva is Fire.
VOTE: Viva

[Firebringer]

I just want to lynch Something smart and call it a day.

[Aristophanes]

I just want to lynch Something smart and call it a day.

I'm not necessarily opposed.

Will review things and see where I end up.

[Something_Smart]

Fire is clearly between me and Viva.
We lynch Viva today. From my POV, he will flip scum. But from yours, if I were scum, I would definitely die tonight. I would of course take my best shot for the Ice (likely at Firebringer) but I would lose nonetheless.
My plan would lead to an auto loss for me if I were scum.

[Shinobi]

I am amazed that mafia didn't double stack.

[Shinobi]

I'll also try to do stuff tomorrow.

[Viva La Gloria]

Trying to get my bearings here because SS isn't reacting how I would expect him to if he's Fire.

Like he correctly pointed out, forcing a 1v1 here just doesn't end up well regardless of the ending. Snarky would also be a horrible kill because even though it frames me it leaves the game with a much wider ice pool than fire pool, and frankly framing me just doesn't serve his interests. You could argue that he wasn't thinking ahead; but his comments today prove that he is. Unless he thought he could trick Ice into misfiring but that seems incredibly unlikely.

I think that Fire is not someone who was on my major Fire list. Firebringer or Aristophanes most likely.

S_S, I am town. Your reactions today and yesterday have made me think that you probably are too. Work with me.

[Something_Smart]

I still think you/SW is more likely, but I could see Ari/SW (though Ari has felt town to me all game). Shinobi is absolutely not Fire and I seriously doubt that Firebringer is Fire.
A few questions:
What do you think of Ari's "Get a room!" in regards to SW and ika?
Do you think the Cobalting kill was an attempt to kill town or scum?

[Something_Smart]

Wait a minute.
Viva is reacting exactly how I would expect him to if he's Fire.
His only hope is to lynch out of the two of us and hope the Ice shoots me.

I would be much more comfortable lynching Viva today.

[Shinobi]

I still think Fire is mafia but I'm willing to take a second look at things considering I'm still alive.
Naturally I recommend that everyone do that, including the guy that voted before everyone even checked in.

I thought I'd have more time for this game today but I really don't. I'm making no promises wrt my activity but I'll do my best.

[Viva La Gloria]

Wait a minute.
Viva is reacting exactly how I would expect him to if he's Fire.
His only hope is to lynch out of the two of us and hope the Ice shoots me.

I would be much more comfortable lynching Viva today.

Viva is reacting like someone who doesn't think that you're fire scum based on your reaction.
I can't see you expecting to win this 1v1 and like you said, even winning this 1v1 would be unhelpful if you are fire because you'd just eat fire.
If you're town, 2/3 of Aristo/Shin/Firebringer are maf. Ice will likely see you as fire and shoot you and it's a town lose automatically after that.

Be useful.

[texcat]

Day 4, Vountcount 1

Viva La Gloria (1):

Something_Smart

Not Voting (4):

Firebringer, Viva La Gloria, Aristophanes, Shinobi

With 5 alive it takes 3 to lynch or to no lynch.

Deadline

: Monday, March 14, 2016 9:00 am (Texas time)

Countdown to deadline

: (expired on 2016-03-14 09:00:00)

[Something_Smart]

Your logic makes sense, however, it also makes sense for scum, and I'm running around in circles trying to find one clear motivation in your posts.
I'm still leaning scum on you because your interactions with SW are the sketchiest, but I want to see a case on who you think is Fire.

@Ari, Shinobi, Fire: Who are your top Fire and Ice candidates?

[Aristophanes]

Gimme another day or two to do something here..inclement weather in Southern Ontario has me called into work.

Yourself and Fire are the last two who I had some suspicion on, but that doesn't necessarily mean you're still top picks.

[Shinobi]

Your logic makes sense, however, it also makes sense for scum, and I'm running around in circles trying to find one clear motivation in your posts.
I'm still leaning scum on you because your interactions with SW are the sketchiest, but I want to see a case on who you think is Fire.

@Ari, Shinobi, Fire: Who are your top Fire and Ice candidates?

I haven't paid a lick of attention to any of the associative nonsense going on atm.
I think Fire is mafia but that's the most solid read I have atm.

[Shinobi]

Gimme another day or two to do something here..inclement weather in Southern Ontario has me called into work.

Yourself and Fire are the last two who I had some suspicion on, but that doesn't necessarily mean you're still top picks.

Also maybe this guy, for being the wishy-washiest and most forgetful player in the history of the universe.

[Aristophanes]

Gimme another day or two to do something here..inclement weather in Southern Ontario has me called into work.

Yourself and Fire are the last two who I had some suspicion on, but that doesn't necessarily mean you're still top picks.

Also maybe this guy, for being the wishy-washiest and most forgetful player in the history of the universe.

I know it isn't one, but I'm gonna take that as a compliment regardless!

[Shinobi]

>:|

[Firebringer]

I haven't paid a lick of attention to any of the associative nonsense going on atm.
I think Fire is mafia but that's the most solid read I have atm.

too bad your most solid read is wrong ;(

[Firebringer]

I should do a ISO of everyoen to figure this out.
Ill be back tomorrow with a least one player looked at.

[Something_Smart]

Yeah I'm going to have to do some rereading to see if the world where Viva is town makes any sense. I think Aristo is Fire in that world, so I'll see if that makes sense, too.

[Viva La Gloria]

Prod dodge. this game tomorrow.

[texcat]

Votecount remains the same; deadline remains the same; no one appears to be in prod range. But I'm still around if you happen to need me. : )