Okay, here's where I'm at. We're in kind of an awkward position.
I'm pretty sure mollie is being truthful about her lyncher status; however, I highly doubt she is being truthful about beeboy. Having an IC AND a lyncher with an honest scum target would be ridiculous, so with this information, we have two choices going forward:
1. Lynch mollie - She'll most likely flip basic lyncher. One more anti town player gone, but one less lynch to put toward scum.
2. Don't lynch mollie - She'll either fade back or keep pushing beeboy. If beeboy is town, we lose a LYLO because scum would never NK beeboy and mollie would just auto vote him.
Either situation we need to lynch scum, whether sooner or later. The real question is whether we want mollie here potentially making noise or whether we just want to end her now.
Radiant seemed pretty opportunistic and was way to willing to originally hop on and lynch me.
3Dice is the is supposed to be ZZZX and my thoughts on him are the same as the above.
CatDog has felt way to fencey like he is trying to let Mollie come up with a convincing reason to lynch me so he can get free MyLo.
ah yes, beeboy style reads;
if this person flips town, then i'll townread them. - Nahdia
I think mollie has to go. I can't concentrate with her around. Shes always going to be making noise that honestly can't be ignored.
Even if she has a guilty I don't want to give her a win for how she has treated people. I can't scumhunt with her here, I can't do anything. All the discussion is about her place in the game and there is no way to figure out whether things people are saying are alignment indicative
One fine day with a woof and a purr
a baby was born and it caused a little stir
my name is the dog everyone likes me
I changed my mind CatDog is Kain tier scum for wanting to lynch someone for problems that are not directly related to the game.
Lynch Kain and CatDog and we win.
ah yes, beeboy style reads;
if this person flips town, then i'll townread them. - Nahdia
beeboy. This started because she had to die BEFORE she was being a jerk.
She has to die because her role is a distraction, probably untrue and causes a zone of no progress.
pedit: same FA. I think she might have pinged someone right, but her anti-townness is more of a concern than potential bboy scum. I think lynching him tomorrow makes the most sense. Esp. if mollie actually does have a guilty (which I doubt)
One fine day with a woof and a purr
a baby was born and it caused a little stir
my name is the dog everyone likes me
In post 308, Frozen Angel wrote:I srsly hope mollie is telling the truth about beeboy scum becuase I have a mild scum read on him without considering any part of mollies claim.
I was looking at mafiawiki to confirm that lyncher is normally given a target randomly, and I found this
"On Day 2, claim Cop with a guilty result on your target. By the time they figure out you're lying, you will have already won."
Beeboy what do you mean problems not directly related to the game? She's essentially stalled the game and made it impossible to get any where else until we handle this situation.
One fine day with a woof and a purr
a baby was born and it caused a little stir
my name is the dog everyone likes me
Look at your first few posts this game. It is all just you trying to find an excuse to lynch me instead of Mollie.
It is clear what your intentions where there.
ah yes, beeboy style reads;
if this person flips town, then i'll townread them. - Nahdia
In post 308, Frozen Angel wrote:I srsly hope mollie is telling the truth about beeboy scum becuase I have a mild scum read on him without considering any part of mollies claim.
I was looking at mafiawiki to confirm that lyncher is normally given a target randomly, and I found this
"On Day 2, claim Cop with a guilty result on your target. By the time they figure out you're lying, you will have already won."
Sound familiar?
I know who a lyncher operates. I won a game this way.
thats why guilty on beeboy means absolutely nothing. but why should she claim to be a lyncher and not doing that later as a guilty result?
In post 320, beeboy wrote:FA she said her role had a guilty result in her first post.
Well yeah, but the concept is the same. Claiming a cop on someone is a great strat for a lyncher, same as claiming your role tells you someone is scum.