Mini 1769: Ice Cream Mafia - Game over!

[Slandaar]

TRUE... now that I think about it...

SCUM would want not so good players to be alive as LONG as possible

so they can trick them later when people are fewer... bad town players want policy lynches...

So mn is not scum...

UNVOTE: mn

my tummy still HURTS... will think more when it STOPS HURTING...

All seriousness - We are talking about policy lynching keyser here who, might not be the best (I don't know), but he doesn't come across as bad. I don't really think changing a read based on the idea scum wouldn't want to lynch keyser because he isn't a great player is very town-like shall we say.

[Phoenix Wright]

@massive What are your reads right now?

I've seen Keyser play and I like that he's goofing off a little - and that it doesn't seem to be stopping him from scumhunting. BBT and I are historically opposite alignment, so he's scum. I'll eventually get a read on TTH, once she really gets into the game. Half of the rest of the town appears to be playing a gimmick account.

How about you? What do you think of the three I specifically called out above?

I'm starting to not like Keysor's posts. He seemed to be making good points at first, but now he's just flipping a round and looking for any little thing to nitpick. Bluebloodedtoffee hasn't said much yet, and that's worrisome because people who Barry post are generally people taut you can't trust. The same goes for telltaleheart. TTH has the coolest name ever though.

[Phoenix Wright]

*flopping around

[TellTaleHeart]

No one even tried to guess who my scumread was? I must be really boring.

Anyway, it's KainTepes.

WHY DID THIS THREAD PROGRESS SO FAST??? I JUST WENT TO SLEEP AND CAME BACK AND EVERYONE TALKING, BUT THIS IS GOOD!!!!!

This is the first thing that set off some alarm bells for me. It's applauding ~something~ that's happened in the thread that's ostensibly good for town but nothing remarkable actually happened so that gives this post a canned and insincere feel.

This exchange with Keyser Soze also bothered me:

Spoiler:

Let us policy lynch and move on.

now he is SCUM

VOTE: mn

MY STOMACH HURTS...

Stop shaking dem titties.

Let us policy lynch and move on.

now he is SCUM

VOTE: mn

Do you think

Scum

actively push Day One policy lynches or does

Bad Town

?

TRUE... now that I think about it... SCUM would want not so good players to be alive as LONG as possible so they can trick them later when people are fewer... bad town players want policy lynches...

So mn is not scum...

UNVOTE: mn

my tummy still HURTS... will think more when it STOPS HURTING...

No time today.

Tomorrow.

WHY do you keep avoiding,,

VOTE: BLUE BLOOD COFFEE

(in your name you spelt COFFEE wrong!!!!!!)

Keyser's point isn't particularly salient here because of course scum can actively push a Day 1 policy lynch, but Kain rolled over and fell in line with Keyser's logic just like that. In keeping with this theme, Kain proceeds to co-opt Keyser's BBT vote. The tenuous reason that accompanied the apparent change of heart makes me think he's less interested in forming his own opinions and more interested in adapting ones that he thinks

look

town.

VOTE: KainTepes

[Slandaar]

(I also think Kain is scum)

I am thinking about your post Keyser, at work, will be back later. I am not impressed with it though.

[TellTaleHeart]

TRUE... now that I think about it...

SCUM would want not so good players to be alive as LONG as possible

so they can trick them later when people are fewer... bad town players want policy lynches...

So mn is not scum...

UNVOTE: mn

my tummy still HURTS... will think more when it STOPS HURTING...

All seriousness - We are talking about policy lynching keyser here who, might not be the best (I don't know), but he doesn't come across as bad. I don't really think changing a read based on the idea scum wouldn't want to lynch keyser because he isn't a great player is very town-like shall we say.

Spoiler:

[Keyser Söze]

I'm starting to not like Keysor's posts. He seemed to be making good points at first, but now he's just flipping a round and looking for any little thing to nitpick.

Me "flipping a round"?

I've been looking at your scum-hunting style for while now wondering if it was alignment indicative...

mn under focus.

You throw down a vote and scum-read. (post 36)

OceanWind under focus.

You jump in with a question. (post 64)

BlueBloodedToffee under focus.

You throw down suspicion (post 158, post 176)

I'm under focus.

You throw down suspicion (post 176).

What I'm saying is,

you're never the first person to engage anything/anyone.

You're the person who's late to every single party.


Show me YOU presenting an original thought or scum-case before accusing me of "flipping a round" people.
Thanks.

[Keyser Söze]

All seriousness - We are talking about policy lynching keyser here who, might not be the best (I don't know), but he doesn't come across as bad.

I don't really think changing a read based on the idea scum wouldn't want to lynch keyser because he isn't a great player is very town-like shall we say

.

Kain rolled over and fell in line with Keyser's logic just like that. In keeping with this theme, Kain proceeds to co-opt Keyser's BBT vote. The tenuous reason that accompanied the apparent change of heart makes me think he's

less interested in forming his own opinions and more interested in adapting ones that he thinks

look

town

.

Excellent points here. The KainTepes scum-narrative is very clear:
VOTE: KainTepes

[Phoenix Wright]

All seriousness - We are talking about policy lynching keyser here who, might not be the best (I don't know), but he doesn't come across as bad.

I don't really think changing a read based on the idea scum wouldn't want to lynch keyser because he isn't a great player is very town-like shall we say

.

Kain rolled over and fell in line with Keyser's logic just like that. In keeping with this theme, Kain proceeds to co-opt Keyser's BBT vote. The tenuous reason that accompanied the apparent change of heart makes me think he's

less interested in forming his own opinions and more interested in adapting ones that he thinks

look

town

.

Excellent points here. The KainTepes scum-narrative is very clear:
VOTE: KainTepes

Acuses me of sheeping others. Turns around and sheeps others in his next post. Seems legit.

[Keyser Söze]

Acuses me of sheeping others.

Turns around and sheeps others in his next post.

Seems legit.

Do you agree or disagree with their points? This isn't about me.

Plus, you haven't been sheeping, you've been scavenging on scraps - but I don't think that behaviour is alignment indicative.

[mn]

I Am scumhunting.

Then I must apologise sincerely

.

I thought you were earnestly trying to policy lynch me. If you scum-read me than continue your push.

They Just admitted To being Scum. Time To Lynch.

[Keyser Söze]

They Just admitted To being Scum. Time To Lynch.

It Was Not An Admission Of Alignment. I Said Pursue Your Scumreads. Scum Hunt. But Please, Do Not, For The Love Of God, Push A Policy Lynch On Day One. The End.

[mn]

You used Commas wrong. The Lynch on You is a Go still.

[Keyser Söze]

They

Moreover, Who, Are "They"?

[Phoenix Wright]

Acuses me of sheeping others.

Turns around and sheeps others in his next post.

Seems legit.

Do you agree or disagree with their points? This isn't about me.

Plus, you haven't been sheeping, you've been scavenging on scraps - but I don't think that behaviour is alignment indicative.

I'm in another ongoing game with Kain and he has the same playstyle in both of these games. Based on what I've seen from him so far, he's just really reactionary and goes along with what everyone else says. It doesn't necessarily mean that he's scum, but I don't think we should throw tang possibility away either. I don't have a problem with you voting him, I just think it's hypocritical for you to say I was just picking up scraps when you did the exact same thing. If you really think that I'm scavenging for scraps it's because nothing has really happened in this game yet.

[Keyser Söze]

Try not to discuss other ongoing games mate (only completed games). It's a site rule thing.

[Phoenix Wright]

Okay, sorry.

[popsofctown]

mn, who is the second most scummy player in the game?

[Aquanim]

I always have a slow start. I get scumread a lot for it early in the game. It's getting boring.

The only game of yours I can see that is finished is Blitz 22, in which you posted once in the first third of day 1, and got scumread for that. Are you saying you think this is the same as that?

Oh.

UNVOTE:

But why suggest a PL so early in the phase?

Also, why did you unvote here?

[Aquanim]

I'd be happier with the sheeping part of the KainTepes case if there were more data points, but this:

TRUE... now that I think about it...

SCUM would want not so good players to be alive as LONG as possible

so they can trick them later when people are fewer... bad town players want policy lynches...

So mn is not scum...

UNVOTE: mn

my tummy still HURTS... will think more when it STOPS HURTING...

All seriousness - We are talking about policy lynching keyser here who, might not be the best (I don't know), but he doesn't come across as bad. I don't really think changing a read based on the idea scum wouldn't want to lynch keyser because he isn't a great player is very town-like shall we say.

does feel like he's more comfortable debating policy lynches in general rather than the specifics of this game.

[Golden Robster]

Telltale is scum.

Discuss

[TellTaleHeart]

You have my attention.

[Phoenix Wright]

You have my attention.

Were you just lurking this entire time?

[TellTaleHeart]

No, I happen to be on because I just ended the game I was modding.

[SirCakez]

Hi