Open 629: C9++ (Game over!)

Nahdia · Post Post #75 (ISO) » Sun Mar 06, 2016 4:12 pm

In post 71, TheSoldier wrote:@Nahdia, 43 and 44: That's what I thought. I can see why you think so, but I disagree. He reads as someone impatient to play the game and get through RVS to me. Also, what makes Masq's posts about wanting things to happen more tryhard than Creature's (see: all of his posts before today)?

Hard to say, something about Masq's post in particular pinged me and I decided to vote it. Creature's posts did not. Incidentally I've liked some of Masq's more recent posts but there's no one else that has made me twitch so I'm comfortable keeping my vote. I'm very much a passive/reactive player at this stage.

Klingoncelt · Post Post #76 (ISO) » Sun Mar 06, 2016 5:13 pm

In post 68, Ranger wrote:

{GoodNightMsGreen}
{Nahdia, TheSoldier}
{acryon, Willowmeadow}
{Reubus Swagrid}
{Kop, zefiend}
{KainTepes, Masquerade}
{Klingoncelt}
{Creature}

Your reads list is off.

Care to explain why?

KainTepes · Post Post #77 (ISO) » Mon Mar 07, 2016 12:40 am

hello, sorry i have been depressed lately,, will try to post more but if i cannot then i will replace out............

GoodNightMsGreen · Post Post #78 (ISO) » Mon Mar 07, 2016 2:41 am

In post 66, Masquerade wrote:Not wtoc, wotc.
Word of the crowd.

1. It's actually "Wisdom of the Crowds".
2. It's probably a bit late for that now.

In post 71, TheSoldier wrote:@GoodNight: Early thoughts on people other than Kain?

I'm in the process of trying to establish some. This head just got out of a really gnarly game, so give it a bit.

Thoughts I do have:
-Ranger I want to think is Town, the teasing really reminds me of something I do as both alignments in Newbie games but it's a lot more open than that and feels right.
-Masquerade is giving me some vaguely newbTownish vibes.
-I feel like I should have a read on Creature but I don't.
-You're asking the right questions and look pretty Town but I have this weird feeling something's wrong with your tone. I definitely need to go back and remind myself what you sounded like last time we played though.
-Kop feels a little underwhelming but we'll see where that goes.

~gm

Kop · Post Post #79 (ISO) » Mon Mar 07, 2016 3:06 am

In post 78, GoodNightMsGreen wrote:
In post 66, Masquerade wrote:Not wtoc, wotc.
Word of the crowd.

1. It's actually "Wisdom of the Crowds".
2. It's probably a bit late for that now.

In post 71, TheSoldier wrote:@GoodNight: Early thoughts on people other than Kain?

I'm in the process of trying to establish some. This head just got out of a really gnarly game, so give it a bit.

Thoughts I do have:
-Ranger I want to think is Town, the teasing really reminds me of something I do as both alignments in Newbie games but it's a lot more open than that and feels right.
-Masquerade is giving me some vaguely newbTownish vibes.
-I feel like I should have a read on Creature but I don't.

-You're asking the right questions and look pretty Town but I have this weird feeling something's wrong with your tone. I definitely need to go back and remind myself what you sounded like last time we played though.

-Kop feels a little underwhelming but we'll see where that goes.

~gm

When was the last time you played with him?

Kop · Post Post #80 (ISO) » Mon Mar 07, 2016 3:13 am

In post 70, Creature wrote:VOTE: Willowmeadow

What's the reason for this vote?

Creature · Post Post #81 (ISO) » Mon Mar 07, 2016 4:08 am

In post 71, TheSoldier wrote:@Creature: Why do you think you're being voted? (This is a real question, less strange than it seems at first glance)

Wasn't I voted? Unless you mean lynched.

I didn't think I was being lynched, I was curious about Ranger's reads.

Creature · Post Post #82 (ISO) » Mon Mar 07, 2016 4:08 am

In post 80, Kop wrote:
In post 70, Creature wrote:VOTE: Willowmeadow

What's the reason for this vote?

RVS

Creature · Post Post #83 (ISO) » Mon Mar 07, 2016 4:10 am

Just to make it clear, I am not scum reading Ranger yet.

Willowmeadow · Post Post #84 (ISO) » Mon Mar 07, 2016 4:16 am

No questions for me?

Ah, I'll see if I can comment on anything else in a couple of hours, then, when I'll have a tiny bit more time.

Masquerade · Post Post #85 (ISO) » Mon Mar 07, 2016 4:36 am

@TheSoldier: Oops mixed you up with another player, just names though. It happens sometimes for me. My brain isn't what it used to. No reads from Ranger stand out to me at the moment, I mean I have a rough idea of why Ranger classified the players the way she did. Once I see an anomaly or something that I don't agree with I'll go after her. But to be honest I just want to avoid asking her anything early-game because I'm probably not going to get a direct answer yet and that will frustrate me. So I decided to observe Ranger and push her to post her lists frequently if needed. (And knowing what order they are in helps and that was my biggest issue really, players that don't know her yet won't know what she's doing)

@Nahdia: Ok, now I'm done (amusing myself by reading other people talk about me). Why did you think my early posts were tryhard?

@GNMG: What exactly strikes you as newbie from me?

@Klingon: What's off about Ranger's readslist according to you?

Hey Willow, can I call you Willow? Do you have any reads so far you'd like to share?

Kop · Post Post #86 (ISO) » Mon Mar 07, 2016 5:14 am

In post 81, Creature wrote:
In post 71, TheSoldier wrote:@Creature: Why do you think you're being voted? (This is a real question, less strange than it seems at first glance)

Wasn't I voted? Unless you mean lynched.

I didn't think I was being lynched, I was curious about Ranger's reads.

Sorry if I'm butting in.

But the whole context of that quote you quoted doesn't mean lynched, the question is, why do you think you're being voted? If the question was aimed at being lynched, there are only a few people voting for you, and haven't designated you as lynch priority so it's far from meaning lynched.

Creature · Post Post #87 (ISO) » Mon Mar 07, 2016 5:16 am

In post 86, Kop wrote:
In post 81, Creature wrote:
In post 71, TheSoldier wrote:@Creature: Why do you think you're being voted? (This is a real question, less strange than it seems at first glance)

Wasn't I voted? Unless you mean lynched.

I didn't think I was being lynched, I was curious about Ranger's reads.

Sorry if I'm butting in.

But the whole context of that quote you quoted doesn't mean lynched, the question is, why do you think you're being voted? If the question was aimed at being lynched, there are only a few people voting for you, and haven't designated you as lynch priority so it's far from meaning lynched.

I am being voted for being at the bottom of Ranger's readlist, this is why I asked him why he's scum reading me the most.

Kop · Post Post #88 (ISO) » Mon Mar 07, 2016 5:26 am

In post 87, Creature wrote:
In post 86, Kop wrote:
In post 81, Creature wrote:
In post 71, TheSoldier wrote:@Creature: Why do you think you're being voted? (This is a real question, less strange than it seems at first glance)

Wasn't I voted? Unless you mean lynched.

I didn't think I was being lynched, I was curious about Ranger's reads.

Sorry if I'm butting in.

But the whole context of that quote you quoted doesn't mean lynched, the question is, why do you think you're being voted? If the question was aimed at being lynched, there are only a few people voting for you, and haven't designated you as lynch priority so it's far from meaning lynched.

I am being voted for being at the bottom of Ranger's readlist, this is why I asked him why he's scum reading me the most.

I understand that, but the question you asked to Soldier, didn't mention anything about a lynch, it was why do you think your being voted, not being lynched.

Or possibly I've misread it somewhere in the line.

GoodNightMsGreen · Post Post #89 (ISO) » Mon Mar 07, 2016 5:28 am

In post 79, Kop wrote:When was the last time you played with him?

It was about a year ago. But tone doesn't change much.

In post 85, Masquerade wrote:@GNMG: What exactly strikes you as newbie from me?

Your perspective on the game.
It's not meant poorly; we were all new once, and Newbs can be and are just as good as anyone else.

acryon · Post Post #90 (ISO) » Mon Mar 07, 2016 5:38 am

In post 84, Willowmeadow wrote:No questions for me?

Ah, I'll see if I can comment on anything else in a couple of hours, then, when I'll have a tiny bit more time.

Any posts pinging you thusfar?

Creature · Post Post #91 (ISO) » Mon Mar 07, 2016 5:43 am

In post 88, Kop wrote:
In post 87, Creature wrote:
In post 86, Kop wrote:
In post 81, Creature wrote:
In post 71, TheSoldier wrote:@Creature: Why do you think you're being voted? (This is a real question, less strange than it seems at first glance)

Wasn't I voted? Unless you mean lynched.

I didn't think I was being lynched, I was curious about Ranger's reads.

Sorry if I'm butting in.

But the whole context of that quote you quoted doesn't mean lynched, the question is, why do you think you're being voted? If the question was aimed at being lynched, there are only a few people voting for you, and haven't designated you as lynch priority so it's far from meaning lynched.

I am being voted for being at the bottom of Ranger's readlist, this is why I asked him why he's scum reading me the most.

I understand that, but the question you asked to Soldier, didn't mention anything about a lynch, it was why do you think your being voted, not being lynched.

Or possibly I've misread it somewhere in the line.

I understood he was asking me why I think I am going to be voted. I didn't understand correctly at first.

ɀefiend · Post Post #92 (ISO) » Mon Mar 07, 2016 8:54 am

VOTE: Kop

Posts read as fluff and pointless questions. And I'll echo this since it was ignored:

In post 71, TheSoldier wrote:@Kop: You've been passive so far. Why no attempts to engage?

Masquerade · Post Post #93 (ISO) » Mon Mar 07, 2016 10:00 am

In post 89, GoodNightMsGreen wrote:

In post 85, Masquerade wrote:@GNMG: What exactly strikes you as newbie from me?

Your perspective on the game.
It's not meant poorly; we were all new once, and Newbs can be and are just as good as anyone else.

I'm not new, but I don't consider myself a superawesome mafiaplayer either. So I'm curious what perspective you mean, I want to get better so I can actually be a superawesome mafiaplayer.

Acryon, talk to me more about your vote on Ranger.

acryon · Post Post #94 (ISO) » Mon Mar 07, 2016 10:22 am

In post 93, Masquerade wrote:
In post 89, GoodNightMsGreen wrote:

In post 85, Masquerade wrote:@GNMG: What exactly strikes you as newbie from me?

Your perspective on the game.
It's not meant poorly; we were all new once, and Newbs can be and are just as good as anyone else.

I'm not new, but I don't consider myself a superawesome mafiaplayer either. So I'm curious what perspective you mean, I want to get better so I can actually be a superawesome mafiaplayer.

Acryon, talk to me more about your vote on Ranger.

I didn't like the immediate readslist. Feels like faux-content, so seemed like a fine place to park a vote for the moment. Was hoping he would engage me on it, but that's ok.

GoodNightMsGreen · Post Post #95 (ISO) » Mon Mar 07, 2016 10:56 am

In post 93, Masquerade wrote:
In post 89, GoodNightMsGreen wrote:

In post 85, Masquerade wrote:@GNMG: What exactly strikes you as newbie from me?

Your perspective on the game.
It's not meant poorly; we were all new once, and Newbs can be and are just as good as anyone else.

I'm not new, but I don't consider myself a superawesome mafiaplayer either. So I'm curious what perspective you mean, I want to get better so I can actually be a superawesome mafiaplayer.

Just most of the things that Nahdia (I think?) was reading as tryharding.
You've been looking at the game like the shine hasn't worn off.

Willowmeadow · Post Post #96 (ISO) » Mon Mar 07, 2016 11:27 am

acryon wrote:Any posts pinging you thusfar?

In post 85, Masquerade wrote:Hey Willow, can I call you Willow? Do you have any reads so far you'd like to share?

Yeah you can call me that.

I can't tell if Nahdia was serious in the start, but they're definitely someone who I won't forget to keep an eye on. Gut says there's something off about Creature but for now I can't put my finger on it.

I like what Ranger has been doing. Pretty original RVS strategy.

Don't know what zefiend is seeing as fluff in Kop. I'm not going to comment anything else on this

yet

. I hope there's going to be more friction between them.

But in the end, KainTepes is the reason I'm afraid this day is going to end in a policy lynch. I hope he's replacing out before that, though.

TheSoldier · Post Post #97 (ISO) » Mon Mar 07, 2016 11:31 am

Thanks for your thoughts GM.

Now that I read my question to Creature again I can see how it's confusing, so let me rephrase it.

What do you think the reasons are that people are voting you?

No problem with the name Masq, was just something I chuckled at.

I'm sorry to hear that Kain; take as much time as you need. This is just a game, after all.

acryon · Post Post #98 (ISO) » Mon Mar 07, 2016 11:34 am

In post 96, Willowmeadow wrote:
acryon wrote:Any posts pinging you thusfar?

In post 85, Masquerade wrote:Hey Willow, can I call you Willow? Do you have any reads so far you'd like to share?
I like what Ranger has been doing. Pretty original RVS strategy.

I'm not sure Ranger's is just an RVS strategy. Only game I've played with him he came in late-game doing that.

TheSoldier · Post Post #99 (ISO) » Mon Mar 07, 2016 11:52 am

I'm townreading Masquerade btw. They seem really earnest and they're looking for reasons behind actions. I've posted 'tryhard' stuff as town before, so I identify with that too.

I want to townread the GM hydra and Ranger too but I know I shouldn't yet. Please go town it up for me.

I'd like Kop to answer my question from earlier, zefiend quoted it.

P.S. Ranger is a she