In post 80, chilledtea wrote:process of elimination, and also because of what he has posted till now
WTF "process of elimination" how? Also, FS has made 2 posts since his opening post. Buddying and a leaning-Scum read on somebody who's been completely inactive, out of thin air. Can we lynch this slot please? It is
NOT
Town.
Also @tea, I understand how you can
independently
read both myself and itlepip as Town given our
independent
reactions to the Suzune "slip" issue, but how do you reconcile those reads and then conclude with the assertion that [Maestro, chilledtea, itlepip, Suzune] are all Town? If so, that also seems far too easy to me to be true, and I wouldn't trust it even if you did have much to back it up.
@itlepip: you still think Suzune slipped, correct? If so, who is her partner?
PEDIT: Why are you voting lovelygiant?
Do you guys realize how amazingly easy it is for lg to be scum, and lurk out an important phase of the game
while
also avoiding suspicion? THAT is why the vote is on him. A couple of more and maybe he will be here to defend himself.
As far as why not firestarter, he has posted 2 times. There isn't much to read there.
Process of elimination means I eliminate who I think are town and then consider the remaining as scum. Easy enough? These are initial reads, not something that I am 100% sure of anyways.
Anyone else notice that maestro just stopped talking. Perhaps I am expecting too much but he was super active demanding things of people and th minute everyone starts suggesting he could be scum, he disappears. Anyone else notice?
Nope. This game doesn't have PR's and ways to reveal others besides lynching. This game is about strategy and moreso focused on theory than game mechanics, which is a skill I'd like to improve as town. This game is different than the rest I've played so far, so I felt to make it known.
I've skimmed the story so far, can't say I'm pulled any specific way.
The Suz wagon was overhyped, in my eyes. While the possibility it was a scum slip exists, I've terribly misphrased/misread things before that made me look scummy and lead to my mislynch. It's extremely early in the day and lynching someone super early before they've made real reads or connections gives town less post-mortem evidence to work with.
I like Chilledtea so far. I'd be suspicious of me too, and picking to vote me for my silence over Easy Mislynch Candidate Suz is towny.
I'll go through and give more early reads soon. Liking this bunch of players so far, looking forward to a good game.
I'll also note that Maestro's tone is seeming less demanding than my past experience with him. More subtle. Not calling it towny or scummy but acknowledging the difference.
In post 118, lovelygiant wrote:I'll also note that Maestro's tone is seeming less demanding than my past experience with him. More subtle. Not calling it towny or scummy but acknowledging the difference.
You have how much experience with me? One game? Either way, yeah I'm more cautious here. Game can be over in 2 lynches if we fuck up, or in 1 if we don't. Ofc I'm more cautious here. Less demanding? I disagree.
In post 41, Suzune wrote:I kind of feel stupid about it to be honest~
Although this does seem a little "I've been caught" panicky. I'll accept that there's two reasonable sides to the Lynch Suz debate.
No, it doesn't. It soudns defeated. I've been in that place enough as Town to recognize it when I see it - there's no way she's Scum with the reaction she's used. She's not a great player - look at the lack of activity and overall...
fatalistic isn't quite the right word
resigned tone
she's displayed since the "slip" - but she's not Scum.
@Maestro - I still consider it an experience. It would be rude to exaggerate and call it a "trip."
We're still discussing it because I was late to the party and wanted to comment on it.
As it happens, I think it's likely that you're right, and that Suz is civ. If that's the case, we should be asking ourselves if the wagon hyped itself around civilians or if a mafioso did some fire stoking.
Why are you voting lovelygiant?
Either way, yeah I'm more cautious here. Game can be over in 2 lynches if we fuck up, or in 1 if we don't. Ofc I'm more cautious here. Less demanding? I disagree.
I'm at work.