Open 635 - JK9++ (Game Over)

[Titus]

VOTE: Thor

You're asking if I claimed something impossible all the while not confirming or revoking WH's claim. You claim to have read the setup briefly but that's not true as backup isn't possible. Asking me if I claim backup strongly implies you claimed doctor so why not outright affirm or disclaim it?

@Dave, I will deal with you in a moment.

[Titus]

There were only TWO acceptable answers to my questioning for Thor. One for Dave. Neither hit it.

[davesaz]

I'm pretty sure RC was right all along BTW. Titus and Postie acted together. No way Postie could know what Titus was doing unless they planned it.

[davesaz]

And no, scum reads don't get the luxury of telling me to shut up. IGDAF what you thought you were trying to do - the lie is not justified.
Whether scum or policy, my vote parks.

[Titus]

I'm pretty sure RC was right all along BTW. Titus and Postie acted together. No way Postie could know what Titus was doing unless they planned it.

ROTFL

That's even worse.

How much of my ISO have you read? Let's be blunt here.

[davesaz]

I haven't done the odds, but there is no guarantee that your earlier posts were true either.

[davesaz]

As I'm fond of reminding people, what alignment has to be skeptical?

[Titus]

Town, which shows you aren't.

[davesaz]

Once again, eh? Name someone else in the game who doesn't take your claim as gospel?
There is no guarantee the game even has a doc.

[Titus]

And you just ruined my test. There's zero chance Thor will claim doctor now. None.

Thor claiming doctor would scu firm him, which benefits the entire game. You're right that WH never claimed Doctor. I wanted Thor to confirm or dispel that himself. Why?

Look the only acceptable answers from Thor were either, calling me out for rolefishing or stating my claim was bullshit. His refusal to revoke the claim is scummy as fuck.

Meanwhile, you're here coaching Thor telling him that a doctor claim is a scumclaim.

After all, who makes up a CC to themselves under no pressure? It was a reaction test that ONLY I could do and you both failed miserably.

[Thor665]

You're asking if I claimed something impossible all the while not confirming or revoking WH's claim.

You are correct, I brought up a non-existent role in this game, and also didn't claim while not at L-1.
I'm not sure why that's scummy on either point.

You claim to have read the setup briefly but that's not true as backup isn't possible. Asking me if I claim backup strongly implies you claimed doctor so why not outright affirm or disclaim it?

Because it was a joke based off the question I had asked you about how we were connected. Like, here's the conversation flow;

Titus: there case connecting us is strong!
Thor: How are we connected?
Titus: You claimed Doc!
Thor: Did you claim backup?
Titus: LOL Thor is scum!

That's where I'm at, where are you?
Because I thought it was pretty clearly a joke - and even if we want to go with the theory that I was dead serious...what was my scum plan there exactly? To get you to fake affirm that you're a backup?

This makes no sense at all.

[Thor665]

And you just ruined my test. There's zero chance Thor will claim doctor now. None.

Thor claiming doctor would scu firm him, which benefits the entire game. You're right that WH never claimed Doctor. I wanted Thor to confirm or dispel that himself. Why?

And why would you think I would do that?

[Titus]

And you just ruined my test. There's zero chance Thor will claim doctor now. None.

Thor claiming doctor would scu firm him, which benefits the entire game. You're right that WH never claimed Doctor. I wanted Thor to confirm or dispel that himself. Why?

And why would you think I would do that?

People when confronted with bullshit about them call it out. You wanted an exit hatch.

[Titus]

You're asking if I claimed something impossible all the while not confirming or revoking WH's claim.

You are correct, I brought up a non-existent role in this game, and also didn't claim while not at L-1.
I'm not sure why that's scummy on either point.

You claim to have read the setup briefly but that's not true as backup isn't possible. Asking me if I claim backup strongly implies you claimed doctor so why not outright affirm or disclaim it?

Because it was a joke based off the question I had asked you about how we were connected. Like, here's the conversation flow;

Titus: there case connecting us is strong!
Thor: How are we connected?
Titus: You claimed Doc!
Thor: Did you claim backup?
Titus: LOL Thor is scum!

That's where I'm at, where are you?
Because I thought it was pretty clearly a joke - and even if we want to go with the theory that I was dead serious...what was my scum plan there exactly? To get you to fake affirm that you're a backup?

This makes no sense at all.

The it was a joke defense. My favorite.

[davesaz]

@Thor, your slot claimed Doctor. :-p

@Thor, your slot claimed Doctor. :-p

Did you claim backup? Because otherwise whatever my slot claimed I don't see the connection.

@Thor, your slot claimed Doctor. :-p

Huh?

Thor reacted first.

[Titus]

@Thor, your slot claimed Doctor. :-p

@Thor, your slot claimed Doctor. :-p

Did you claim backup? Because otherwise whatever my slot claimed I don't see the connection.

@Thor, your slot claimed Doctor. :-p

Huh?

Thor reacted first.

He didn't confirm or deny. That's why his reaction didn't work.

What did you think I was doing?

[Thor665]

The it was a joke defense. My favorite.

Are you saying my reaction didn't come across that way?
What did you think my reaction came across as?

Because your issue still isn't making sense.

[Thor665]

Honestly, if you're town, I'm insulted at the level of play you're implying in me as theory scum, frankly.

[Titus]

The it was a joke defense. My favorite.

Are you saying my reaction didn't come across that way?
What did you think my reaction came across as?

Because your issue still isn't making sense.

Wow. Going for the i'm dumb.

Seriously, when I asked you how much of the setup you read and you replied that you skimmed it, that clearly indicated not a joke.

People call out bullshit wen faced with it. You didn't. Youhemmed and hawwed.

[davesaz]

We have a smidge under 5 days. I'd prefer to not let it go much under 3 without some movement.
How bout some non-derp reads on other people.

[SirCakez]

Mainly the complete lack of address by Titus towards the Rhaegar wagon while SMGO joined it.

Going just off mod VC - the wagon peaked at three votes with a whole ton of people not seeming to get excited by it.
Why was it such an event that Titus needed to comment on it, and not doing so made him scum, while SMGO sheeping along on a null read wagon is obv. town.
I don't get it.

It was clearly the main topic at the time, and that's not the only thing making her scum.
Same for that not being the only thing making SMGO obv town.

No because I don't have a completed game with him

So why do you think he would scumhunt better than he has?

I have no idea how he scumhunts as town, but if this is town it's seriously weak.

The Titus vs SMGO, CNM wagon, basically everything Spiffeh posted, etc

Why is Spiffeh's posting so exciting?

Because it's an entire player slot?

[Thor665]

Wow. Going for the i'm dumb.

Going with the "not addressing how my response didn't look like a joke".

Seriously, when I asked you how much of the setup you read and you replied that you skimmed it, that clearly indicated not a joke.

What does that have to do with the joke? I did just skim the setup.

People call out bullSmurf wen faced with it. You didn't. Youhemmed and hawwed.

I actually didn't - I directly asked how your response had anything to do with my question.

[davesaz]

So were you looking to see what Titus meant individually, or just the general how you're "connected"?

[davesaz]

BTW, hunting for lurkers or people being "bad" in this game is not going to work.

[Ranger]

Okay, excitement, why am I in the hot seat?

Because people are idiots and/or scum.

Thor, if you want to convince me you're town, the best way to do that is to read the game and give me your reads. Trying to defend your predecessor's actions isn't going to get you very far.

Pretty sure this is scum btw.