Mini 1785: Game Over!

[RadiantCowbells]

1295 is so bad but like
I don't want to lynch that claim D1.

If she's town she'll get NKed eventually, if she's scum she'll PoE herself.

[nnn_thekushmountains]

I agree with RC the smart play is to lynch somebody else. IAI anyone?

[nnn_thekushmountains]

UNVOTE:
VOTE: IAMINNOCENT

[JarJarDrinks]

Claim sounds fake. I'll let her catchup and posts stuffs but I say we hang her regardless.

why

Why do I think it sounds fake? First off, mafia is more likely to claim PR IMO. I find it convenient that she's not just a VT.

Also I don't like how she was all "dissect the wagon" as if to imply that her claiming means we auto-move our votes.

[RadiantCowbells]

fuck it.

what are your reads Postie?

[nnn_thekushmountains]

I mean I agree with you guys that I think she's probably scum, but still it's optimal play to wait to lynch her.

[MURDERCAT]

Why do I think it sounds fake? First off, mafia is more likely to claim PR IMO. I find it convenient that she's not just a VT.

This is silly reasoning that will have us end up with all our PRs lynched.

I'll agree that I'm still suspicious but we can't lynch Postie today.

[JarJarDrinks]

hey RC, notice how Garmr totally disappeared once the postie wagon started.

[JarJarDrinks]

Why do I think it sounds fake? First off, mafia is more likely to claim PR IMO. I find it convenient that she's not just a VT.

This is silly reasoning that will have us end up with all our PRs lynched.

I'll agree that I'm still suspicious but we can't lynch Postie today.

So what you're saying is you've given up on lynching scum today? Cause all scum has to do is claim PR and we don't lynch em right?

[JarJarDrinks]

I mean I agree with you guys that I think she's probably scum, but still it's optimal play to wait to lynch her.

First half of ur sentence disagrees w/ the second.

[RadiantCowbells]

You're missing the point.
If Postie is scum with a GS claim she'll get PoEd out eventually.
If she's town, she'll get NKed.

There's no rush to lynch her without a CC, and for the record: town shouldn't necessarily CC.

[MURDERCAT]

There's a line. It's only day 1.

[RadiantCowbells]

JJD I feel like you're CCing and I feel like it's fucking obvious.

If you specifically CC you should do it outright and we can lynch her.

If anyone else CCs they should keep their mouth shut until a few days in then counterclaim her the day before LyLo.

[JarJarDrinks]

not CCing

[JarJarDrinks]

It's purely a read based on the post where she claimed.

[RadiantCowbells]

I'm not disagreeing but I'm not lynching uncced gunsmith on day one.
like ugh.

[Mr Meeseeks]

I've been asleep.

postie

what on earth have you been doing sleeping between 3 pm and 8 pm in the afternoon/evening

[Mr Meeseeks]

i know thats a weird thing to focus on but it seems bizarre

idk why i asked but OH WELL TOO LATE

part of me would rather just lynch this than waste time all piling onto another person

but another part of me knows that we do have enough time to all pile onto another person

kush, anyone? :3

[JarJarDrinks]

I've been asleep.

postie

what on earth have you been doing sleeping between 3 pm and 8 pm in the afternoon/evening

And like, how much time does she need to catch up on the 3 pages she missed?

Now give me some time to catch up properly please and dissect the wagon on me please.

I feel like the other scummies were all like "Dude claim". And she just showed up to drop a claim and then peaced out.

[MURDERCAT]

JJD I wonder if you want to lynch so bad because you know you could be next.

[Postie]

The only thing I think is suspicious is the fact she said was explicitly holding out a read on you. Though I thought that would be a weird thing to do for her scum version of play.

The reason for that was that I was scumreading RC very slightly, and if I said that I was scumreading him, he would start looking at why that was and be able to adjust his play. That would make it harder for me to read him.
I can go into this now though because I've mostly made up my mind and think he's town. I don't think scum!RC would act the way he did when he was drunk. Like, I know he was drunk, but he was being all nice and willing to sheep me on my reads, and I'd really expect scum!RC only to be nice to me if he was trying to manipulate me to do something.
I also don't see scum!RC trying to push a last minute wagon on me. I'd expect him to build up to that kind of thing and not just come out with it from nowhere.

RC's case on me is really exaggerated though and half the points don't even make sense; I'm going to chalk what he's doing up to paranoia for now. I'll be nightkilled tonight though so changing his mind isn't a priority for me at the moment.

[Postie]

Postie's reasoning for voting Calv is bad, and the way she acted flabbergasted when I was questioning her on it pinged. Do you think the way she replied felt genuine?

Bad logic is not a scumtell

Getting annoyed at you for misrepping is not a scumtell

OK just ISO'd Postie and she's kinda scummier than I thought. I might compromise on her.

??????????????

I'm potentially willing to compromise on Postie.

??????????????

im fine with hammering postie, shes bugged me in the short time shes here so im not gonna be upset by her loss (sorry post youre nice but seriously)

??????????????

Claim sounds fake. I'll let her catchup and posts stuffs but I say we hang her regardless.

You are terrible go home.

Also I don't like how she was all "dissect the wagon" as if to imply that her claiming means we auto-move our votes.

I wanted a chance to do stuff without being lynched you wayward minion.

[Mr Meeseeks]

im fine with hammering postie, shes bugged me in the short time shes here so im not gonna be upset by her loss (sorry post youre nice but seriously)

??????????????

lolwut

[Postie]

I really hate how people have wagoned me without even really giving reasons. The "compromise" votes are especially bad because it feels like they're trying to give reasons so their jump looks less bad but don't really have any.

[Fire Assassin]

VOTE: JarJarDrinks