Get done done done done at work
Come over
We just need to slow the motion
Don't give that away to no one
Deadline is in (expired on 2016-05-06 16:00:00)
heuristically_alone wrote:If Ira were mafia, it would actually be an interesting move to fake claim a town role just to get me out. Ira knew that it might be him if not me hence the fake claim to really ensure they get rid of the town PR and thus having to sacrifice himself to the town lynch on next day after having mislynched a PR.
In post 560, Robert2424 wrote:Just FYI, I'm catching up, I notice heuristically_alone is l-1. I'm not normally for Day 1 lynching even though I do suspect him. So I'm going to be rereading as he is so close as I read the last page and going beck to my last post to the last page again.
In post 415, Jake from State Farm wrote:In post 413, toolenduso wrote:Also this seems like a contradiction to me:
In post 134, Robert2424 wrote:I must prepare myself for Jake. For he may try to take revenge upon me from a previous game.
In post 191, Robert2424 wrote:Thank you, and I imagine you wouldn't. I beat you being mafia with AJ. it was awhile back.Jake from State Farm wrote:I dont even remember playing with you
You thought he would try to take revenge based on a previous game, but you're not surprised he doesn't remember that game?
and let's not forget about the fact that if he were town WHY would he be worried about me this game. If anyone can answer that question with rationale that actually makes sense (robert you can try also if you want) i'd love to hear it.
if robert is town, he should be relieved to be on the same side as me if he thinks I am a good player (thank you for the kind words btw)
In post 426, toolenduso wrote:In post 422, heuristically_alone wrote:@Robert I already explained my reasoning for why I added you to my scum board, and if you were paying attention you would see that it has nothing to do with what you think of me, but of how you answered my question when I asked if you were mafia.
Also, didn't you ask Zach if he was mafia, and not Robert?
In post 428, Jake from State Farm wrote:In post 426, toolenduso wrote:In post 422, heuristically_alone wrote:@Robert I already explained my reasoning for why I added you to my scum board, and if you were paying attention you would see that it has nothing to do with what you think of me, but of how you answered my question when I asked if you were mafia.
Also, didn't you ask Zach if he was mafia, and not Robert?
In post 447, xyzzy wrote:now that the topic has moved away from Jake's vote on Zachstralkita, I feel like Jake has been a far more useful player (even in just like the last page and a half). I'm still not a fan of the choices made by him surrounding that vote, but I'm feeling better now.
in response to Jake's 409: I think the relevance of that depends entirely on whether Robert could've had any good reason to strongly believe that you're town at that point; if Robert died and turned out to be scum, that would be a strong indicator in your favor, but I don't think there's any reason to believe that it was anything more than "I believe you're a skilled player, I'm going to keep my eye on you on the assumption that you would do well as scum."
I'm going to reread h_a; I've felt just slightly worse than neutral about him, but given that he's at L-1, I'd like to reassess.
In post 459, Bins wrote:I like Dunn's last few posts, I don't think what H_A did was a scum slip but I don't think it's that incriminating that Zach thought it was one. boy who cried scum slip... Idk if that's super scummy.
Robert is more MIA than me so like fuck that. He's sort of high on my list rn I just wish I had something to go off of.
Tyler is probably town
I really like Tool's posts / general observations
Floof is like eh
Jake is pretty town too but I'm less confident
I think xyzzyz has reached a point where he's putting so much effort I'd be impressed if he was scum. I feel the ability to ask questions and pull so much from everyone's posting is quite town. I usually get weary of A LOT of effort. I need to look more in depth in his posts to get more feels
h_a and Jaack and I can't remember who else I'm missing are really hard to comment on rn. I generally don't get a bad feel from h_a and Jaack is like eh but like eh. I need to ISO both of them
Idk who I'm missing
Ira is making me so unsure of him at this point ugh. I really have to draw this out
These are my general feels to that read through please dkm
In post 492, iraonavp wrote:I'm a bodyguard, so heuristically_alone is almost surely lying.
VOTE: heuristically_alone
I'm not normally for Day 1 lynches. From my personal experience, my Day 1 reads are ussally wrong 90% of the time. Being said there are very few times my scum list looks simular from day 1 to day 2. Plus, I feel my win more when we don't. But I understand people like day 1 lynches. Some like the statistics better, and maybe dose help you in the long run. I personally don't like it, but I'm not 100% opposed to a D1 lynch. There have been times is was Absolutely great.In post 561, xyzzy wrote:it's been 2 days since I last got the chance to post and/or closely read the thread, gonna do that now. my initial impression is that I'm really not feeling good about h_a with the most recent happenings, but I'll hopefully have a more nuanced opinion once I read some more???
pedit: Robert why are you not for day 1 lynching? not lynching someone day 1 (especially with an odd number of players) is a fundamentally bad idea in basically any normal game.
In post 563, Robert2424 wrote:
H_A, and Iraon was both on my scum list, but this development tends to make me believe they are both more townie. That probably sounds really strange, but hey, Zuffy decided to make me a weak townie so there it is. I thought my role was weird, but it makes more sense with those roles in the game. I'm in 80% sure both are town now and think the wagon should be dissolved. I could be wrong, and one or both are lying, but its unlikely.
In post 563, Robert2424 wrote: but hey, Zuffy decided to make me a weak townie so there it is. I thought my role was weird, but it makes more sense with those roles in the game. I'm in 80% sure both are town now and think the wagon should be dissolved. I could be wrong, and one or both are lying, but its unlikely.
In post 547, Tyler the Creator wrote:ira how do you feel about xyzzy's read progression on you?
In post 552, heuristically_alone wrote:IfIra were mafia, it would actually be an interesting move to fake claim a town role just to get me out. Ira knew that it might be him if not me hence the fake claim to really ensure they get rid of the town PR and thus having to sacrifice himself to the town lynch on next day after having mislynched a PR.
In post 566, xyzzy wrote:
519 (Dunnstral) - I don't think daytalk would be enough to compensate for both claims being real.
531 (Zachstralkita) - I don't believe this at all.
In post 474, heuristically_alone wrote:I am the doc this game.
In post 476, heuristically_alone wrote:I a newbie in the sense of playing online in forum, and so far in every game I've participated in I have been one of the first to get lynched.
In post 486, Floof wrote:Why are we all unvoting H_A?
In post 492, iraonavp wrote:I'm a bodyguard, so heuristically_alone is almost surely lying.
VOTE: heuristically_alone
xyzzy wrote:
446 (Zachstralkita) - I still very strongly feel like you're scum and you're trying to just distract the town, but at least it's entertaining