Mini 1785: Game Over!

[Mr Meeseeks]

So like. Didnt Cavalry almost get lynched?

Why wouldn't she have claimed that postie was lying?

ehh, in her situation i wouldnt have either, as the possibility of her being lynched was immensely higher than postie if she did cc, if you ask me

[Mr Meeseeks]

if postie is scum, how did she fakeclaim gunsmith in a setup that actually had a gunsmith in it?????

also this

yeah but the other point has merit too

because it seems bizarre to me that scum!ircher would, by pure chance, manage to get a "result" on the one player he could claim hed got a setup-fake guilty on

[JarJarDrinks]

I'm in favor of a massclaim

[Ircher]

If Postie is a Mafia Gunsmith, then it makes sense.

The only funny thing is that Postie & I apparently targeted the same person but got different results. Postie got no result but I got a guilty (has a gun)

If there is a vig, I definitely think there is a JK.

[JarJarDrinks]

if postie is scum, how did she fakeclaim gunsmith in a setup that actually had a gunsmith in it?????

also this

yeah but the other point has merit too

because it seems bizarre to me that scum!ircher would, by pure chance, manage to get a "result" on the one player he could claim hed got a setup-fake guilty on

That point has merit....IF you believe RC. RC/Ircher scumteam makes the most sense. Cause then we dont have to believe that there was some kind of crazy coincidence.

[Mr Meeseeks]

i know

which is why im seriously considering the rc/ircher scum pair despite suggesting it as a joke

let me add it all up

[Ircher]

The only thing I can say for certain is that Postie is mafia since I am just a plain gunsmith with no modifiers. Two town gunsmiths is practically zero.

If you lynch me today, you must definitely lynch Postie tomorrow and deal with RC the day after.

Otherwise, we lynch Postie today and deal with RC tomorrow as Postie's flip should confirm my role.

[Ircher]

Also, if this was scum Ircher with scum RC, why would I 1) Investigate RC and 2) Force my partner to have to come up with a fakeclaim?

[Mr Meeseeks]

so in theory

ircher gets lynched and flips scum, rc looks super duper town
rc gets lynched and flips scum, ircher looks super duper town
in a really ideal world, postie ends up being lynched and while ircher follows, thats an investigative lynched as well as rc looking super duper town
and, in the end, they can "realise" that backup cops get fake guilties as a good get-out-of-this situation if circumstances result in the best play being them both nullreading each other

...

something about that seems

too

convenient

blargh

[Mr Meeseeks]

and it also explains the all-too-convenient thing where ircher ~somehow~ had the dumb luck, as a fakeclaiming scum, to get a guilty on the one player who he would actually get a fake guilty on

sdhfsdifudsfihuhidf

[Expedience]

Scum probably do have a role such as doctor which allowed them to conclude that there was a gunsmith in the setup.

I really don't think Ircher is lying.

[Mr Meeseeks]

if postie is scum, how did she fakeclaim gunsmith in a setup that actually had a gunsmith in it?????

also this

yeah but the other point has merit too

because it seems bizarre to me that scum!ircher would, by pure chance, manage to get a "result" on the one player he could claim hed got a setup-fake guilty on

That point has merit....IF you believe RC. RC/Ircher scumteam makes the most sense. Cause then we dont have to believe that there was some kind of crazy coincidence.

yeah thats the point i was making

the only world in which both of those fit together is an rc/ircher scumteam

[RadiantCowbells]

If you think we're scum together you're lynching him first.
I'm considering whether scum had a doc and someone on the scumteam pieced together doc = probably gunsmith setup.
For the fucking record, I had claimed that role before I was checked.

the only world in which both of those fit together is an rc/ircher scumteam

k.

[RadiantCowbells]

If there's a vig or SK I'd like them to claim.

[RadiantCowbells]

Correction.
If there's a vig or SK who targeted Kush, I'd like them to claim.
Assuming Postie was indeed jailkept that sort of confirms her as town because I can't see why Scum!Postie makes the nightkill last night.

Which makes Ircher probably scum gunsmith? or MAYBE role cop who came up with a really smooth play.

[Ircher]

Hello, do you guys not understand??? It is 100% plausible that RC and I are the same team. It is 100% implausible that Postie and I are the same alignment. My flip does not affect RC's alignment and vice-versa.

[RadiantCowbells]

Unless there's some other explanation for the missing kill.

[Ircher]

I replaced in to a bad position it seems. We're either lynching myself or Postie, as lynching RC will tell us nothing right now, since Postie could be scum Gunsmith.

[Mr Meeseeks]

If you think we're scum together you're lynching him first.

why do you think im currently not voting? im weighing out the possibilities because this is weird as hell

For the fucking record, I had claimed that role before I was checked.

yeah but youre radiantcowbells, im not going to rule something out because its improbable

[JarJarDrinks]

Scum probably do have a role such as doctor which allowed them to conclude that there was a gunsmith in the setup.

I really don't think Ircher is lying.

Huh? What would lead you to this conclusion?

[RadiantCowbells]

Actually what makes the most sense is that this is basically a carbon fucking copy of my 1777.
What if it's 2/1/10, mafia killed Kush, Serial Killer targeted scum!Postie but was prevented by jailkeep?

yeah but youre radiantcowbells, im not going to rule something out because its improbable

Your face is improbably ugly.

[RadiantCowbells]

WAIT A SECOND.
If Mafia thinks that there's an SK: that explains why Postie would claim as Gunsmith. Non-threatening to serial killers.
Especially if they also have a doc.

[Mr Meeseeks]

possibilities laid out

best lynch is ircher today. he flips town, weve found scum in postie. he flips scum, weve lynched scum, and after that we give rc a lookover

VOTE: ircher

roll up roll up for the magical mystery tour

[JarJarDrinks]

Like Expe, why wouldn't you assume that Ircher was the liar, considering:

. Mr Meeseeks: town
2. acryon: scum
3. RadiantCowbells: idk

4. Calvary: scum

5. MURDERCAT: idk
6. Fire Assassin: idk

7. Postie: town

8. Lapsa: town
9. I Am Innocent: idk
10. Garmr: town
12. JarJarDrinks: town
13. nnn_thekushmountains: town

Why would the counter make u flip ur read?

[Mr Meeseeks]

Your face is improbably ugly.