Mini 1785: Game Over!

[Maxous]

hmm reaction makes me feel slightly better about my choice.

nothing unfakeable but still

[Postie]

I beleive this is correct:

Ircher (5): Postie, JarJarDrinks, Mr Meeseeks, MURDERCAT, Maxous
Postie (4): Expedience, Dwlee99, Ircher, acryon
Mr Meeseeks (1): RadiantCowbells

Not Voting (1): I Am Innocent

Oh. Did someone unvote? He was at 4 votes a few pages ago and then MURDERCAT and Maxous voted.

[Postie]

unvote ircher for now

Postie who else is scum?

Oops there it is.

[JarJarDrinks]

u did respond to that 2 posts later Postie.


RRRgggghhhh....

[JarJarDrinks]

Still not reading too much into it since it's completely unnecessary for scum postie to even say anything @ this point. IAI is pretty likely to vote Ircher when he gets back so a scum-postie already basically won the counter-battle.

[Postie]

u did respond to that 2 posts later Postie.


RRRgggghhhh....

What?

[Postie]

Just off the top of my head right now, my strongest townreads are Mr Meeseeks and I Am Innocent and if you lynch them at any point I'll be super mad.

Switch IAI with kush. I still think IAI is town but I'm no longer super confident about that.

I liked what kush said about Lapsa in 435. The stubborness in 436, particularly the "I don't want to let you think that you can order me to do things", feels pretty town to me.
Not sure how to explain why but the stuff about meta in 477 feels

extremely

town.
I'm not gonna go further into his ISO because I don't feel I need to.

I guarantee you kush is town, and you should be scumhunting off his wagon. I think one or more of the scum were definitely pushing it at some point.

[MURDERCAT]

Is this a joke...

[MURDERCAT]

Yeah I'm pretty sure Kush is town too, he's been flipped.

[MURDERCAT]

UNVOTE:

[Postie]

OH.
I AM DUMB.
PLEASE IGNORE ME.

[MURDERCAT]

What's your read on Garmr?

[MURDERCAT]

Ok I'm going to assume you were just reading from the beginning and made a mistake.

reVOTE: Ircher

[JarJarDrinks]

What's your read on Garmr?

[Postie]

;__________;

I really need to pay closer attention to the game.

[Postie]

Ok I'm going to assume you were just reading from the beginning and made a mistake.

reVOTE: Ircher

Yeah, basically. I was looking at the playerlist on the first page to jog my memory about which players I was townreading, saw kush and was like "hey I'll ISO this guy, he seemed town".

[Postie]

The stuff about scumhunting of kush's wagon still applies though.

[Mr Meeseeks]

yeah, that's enough to make me err on the side of postie!town

can we get a hammer on irchy-boy? i believe its called for at this point

ta

id love to contribute more rn but its late (9:30 PM) and i have other games to post in, while in this game ive pretty much made up my mind and have little to add beyond what i have already said

[Dwlee99]

i am here but would rather not hammer who i think is town

[Ircher]

Whats the case again? Anyone who metas me fyi SHOULD figure that most of the "scummy" stuff I've done is actually null for me.

Oh, and statistically, I am town 100% of the time. That's given 10 games though.

[Ircher]

No one hammer; I want to do something before I die.

[Ircher]

Spoiler: Mini 1785 - Postie ISO

1. 1295 is where Postie claimed gunsmith. From what I read, that was about 3 hrs before deadline.

2. 1321 - "Bad logic is not a scumtell" -

Is this not what I'm getting scumread for? For Postie, her perspective only allows one possible outcome. Same for me. But, if this wagon is cuz of my earlier sheep of RC on poor/not thought out logic, then this wagon on me has no basis.

3. 1368 then much later, 1583 -

It seems to me that Postie just stayed around while her wagon was going, and when the wagon died, lurked again.

4. 1634 - Claims to check RC and was RB'd or jailed.

5. 1893 - Insists there was a vig and insists she was jailkept. -

Who claimed vig, if anyone? Did you indeed shoot Kush? If so, why didn't you claim immediately (unless my memory is wrong). I still think that scum gunsmith Postie makes more sense than Town Gunsmith Postie who was targeted by scum to be killed and stopped and a vig shot Kush. Indeed, the JOAT claim from Dwlee seems to me the most believable claim, and he didn't target Postie. Gunsmith+Joat+Vig+Backup Cop versus Mafia Gunsmith is heavily scumsided. I am thinking town has a more useful role than vig. I'm also starting to think the backup cop claim makes no sense from a balancing standpoint.

The way Postie is going about things reads as contrived and convenient to me.

[MURDERCAT]

IAI claimed vig shot

[MURDERCAT]

I think it's reasonable to think IAI scum shot Kush for being right and claimed vig though.

[MURDERCAT]

Or at least reasonable to consider.