Open 636 - Nightless Vengeful Mayhem - Game Over

[grapes]

Votecount 1-8

(3) Not_Mafia

-- (Flubbernugget, duppin, Blue Yoshi)
(2) Severa -- (pistachi0n, Severa)
(2) heuristically_alone -- (acryon, Postie)
(1) Postie -- (Not_Mafia)
(1) Blue Yoshi -- (Bellaphant)
(1) pistachi0n -- (Aristophanes)
(1) duppin -- (heuristically_alone)

Not Voting -- (SnarkySnowman)

12 alive, 7 to lynch

Time left:

(expired on 2016-05-14 15:10:02)

[heuristically_alone]

I'm still scum reading Severa because I think she might be mafia saying lynch her so she can use venge kill, hoping that becasue of that we don't kill her. WIFOM. It's not a very confident read, but still one of the best I got. That's why I say if we follow your plan I could see her being the second scummiest we decide to lynch.

[heuristically_alone]

And I feel like you keep asking me the same questions over and over again. What's up with that? Hoping I'll slip?

[Aristophanes]

Yeah, that. I think my issue with your plan is the second scummiest player wont be in the 'loop' so their reads might be kinda shit? Wheras if a bunch of us agreed on a 'probably town with good scum-reads' player, we might be safer?


''

Bella, why are you trying to lynch town?
That's scummy
I don't like when you are scummy!

[Aristophanes]

VOTE: Pista
Harping on this is distracting and useless.
Nice busiwork though.

It's the most interesting thing going on and the only major event so far.

it seems this is really based on the fact that I only had 3 posts about Severa, as opposed to 34.

That you only addressed her despite other people commenting on it and doing things around it is moreso what bugs me.
Start engaging others and I may reconsider.

Again, it was the only notable thing to have happened at the time, I could have ignored it and lurked another day.

See, now when I engage other people, you'll say "oh, she's doing what I told her to do not to get scumread, she's obviously scum"

Not the angle I intended to pursue at all actually. Interest ok ng that you would assume so.

Do you have a read on me or anyone else yet?

Also, it was the only notable thing in the first...what, 200 posts? That is ridiculous and you know it!

Also also, didn't realised the "she" at the bottom and have probably used improper pronouns. My apologies!

[pistachi0n]

That's why we tell them who to venge. I guess we have to trust they'll actually do it though.

That's a really stupid idea. Why would somebody go through with it? If we lynch town, and they disagree with who the consensus thinks is scum (and chances are they do if they got lynched in the first place), they'll venge whoever they damn well please.

[Aristophanes]

Not 200. First 150 posts. Still, the point stands.

[Aristophanes]

That's why we tell them who to venge. I guess we have to trust they'll actually do it though.

That's a really stupid idea. Why would somebody go through with it? If we lynch town, and they disagree with who the consensus thinks is scum (and chances are they do if they got lynched in the first place), they'll venge whoever they damn well please.

What if we ask really sweetly?

(I support the plan, obvee)

[Blue Yoshi]

quick thoughts before I go to bed (been a long day)
stop giving a shit about severa, nothing's going to change in that regard and they aren't going to do shit for half the game whether they're town or scum
N_M is seriously just trying to get a word in wherever possible, even though it's rarely relevant
pistachi0n has a low post count which could be wifom in regards to alignment, and few substantive posts, leaning scum at least until I see more
Postie seems consistently misinformed, meaning they probably either aren't familiar with the setup or just the game (which could be town or complex wifom, haven't decided)
aristo's high post count is unimpressive, but I can't really read them yet
I'm apparently confusing aristo and heur in my reasoning because to me they're both playing very filler-y, so probably same read
seriously fuck severa

not getting to anything else tonight, too tired
sorry for all the fence sitting and lack of proofreading.

[Aristophanes]

I'm fillery?
And he re I tight I was doing helpful things

[SnarkySnowman]

Starting to have second thoughts on Aristo - scumlean.

Blue Yoshi pings pretty hard town atm.

[Not_Mafia]

Don't worry Aris, he's scum

[pistachi0n]

VOTE: Pista
Harping on this is distracting and useless.
Nice busiwork though.

It's the most interesting thing going on and the only major event so far.

it seems this is really based on the fact that I only had 3 posts about Severa, as opposed to 34.

That you only addressed her despite other people commenting on it and doing things around it is moreso what bugs me.
Start engaging others and I may reconsider.

Again, it was the only notable thing to have happened at the time, I could have ignored it and lurked another day.

See, now when I engage other people, you'll say "oh, she's doing what I told her to do not to get scumread, she's obviously scum"

Not the angle I intended to pursue at all actually. Interest ok ng that you would assume so.

Do you have a read on me or anyone else yet?

Also, it was the only notable thing in the first...what, 200 posts? That is ridiculous and you know it!

Also also, didn't realised the "she" at the bottom and have probably used improper pronouns. My apologies!

It's just a pet peeve of mine when people say "do this thing and maybe I'll stop scumreading you." Even when I'm not the target.

Town on you, weak town on postie. Blue Yoshi seems forced.

And it's fine, if I had a dollar for every time someone used the incorrect pronouns on this site, I'd be a rich woman.

[pistachi0n]

Also re: the first 200 posts, Severa did her thing on page 2.

[heuristically_alone]

Don't worry Aris, he's scum

To clarify, Snarky is scum?

[heuristically_alone]

^ ^ ^
or Blue Yoshi?

[Not_Mafia]

Blue Yoshi

[Severa]

pdodge.

[duppin]

Right now I've decided on Duppin and Postie as my biggest scum reads. When I saw duppin ask that someone ask him something, I wanted to ask the same question. Town are generally more likely to give a simple no answer while scum tend to deflect the question in some way or not answer. I've just been having bad feelings about Postie, similar to those Postie has for me, but not in an omgus sense.

Um... what? Sorry but this makes no sense at all. Why do you think town are more likely to give a simple no answer and what exactly do you base this on? Because I don't agree with you at all. This is actually not me trying to defend myself, but I'd really like to know why you believe this to be the case.

[acryon]

That's a really stupid idea. Why would somebody go through with it? If we lynch town, and they disagree with who the consensus thinks is scum (and chances are they do if they got lynched in the first place), they'll venge whoever they damn well please.

Agree here. I actually don't think we should be considering the Vengeful part in our lynch at all. Like someone else said, we are lynching someone whose reads we likely don't agree with. If we agree with someone's reads, we probably shouldn't be lynching them. We lynch the scummiest person.

stop giving a shit about severa, nothing's going to change in that regard and they aren't going to do shit for half the game whether they're town or scum
N_M is seriously just trying to get a word in wherever possible, even though it's rarely relevant
pistachi0n has a low post count which could be wifom in regards to alignment, and few substantive posts, leaning scum at least until I see more
Postie seems consistently misinformed, meaning they probably either aren't familiar with the setup or just the game (which could be town or complex wifom, haven't decided)
aristo's high post count is unimpressive, but I can't really read them yet

So what is your real issue with pistachion? Do you think he is lurking or do you really just have an issue with his post count, because that seems terrible.

If you had to pick re: Postie, does it feel more like misunderstanding or posturing?

Starting to have second thoughts on Aristo - scumlean.

Blue Yoshi pings pretty hard town atm.

Interesting that people are so split on Blue Yoshi. What posts ping town to you of his?

What happens if we Lynch a town read today? Especially if we agree with their reads...

This feels really town.

Oh! And if we get lucky and hit the Day Goon, they won't even have the opportunity to use their shots!

This feels fairly fake.

@N_M: I'd be really interested in a full reads-list from you. You seem to be hinting that you have reads, but you're not really speaking up.

[Bellaphant]

Acron, can I get a readslist from you too? I could lynch way too many people...

[acryon]

Acron, can I get a readslist from you too? I could lynch way too many people...

To be honest I'm not one for readslists, but I'll humor you. This can be a ranking from most likely town to most likely scum.

Town

acryon
Bellaphant
Flubbernugget
Severa
Aristophanes
SnarkySnowman
pistachi0n
heuristically_alone
Blue Yoshi
Postie
Not_Mafia
duppin

Scum

Suppose I should also move my vote.

VOTE: duppin

[Not_Mafia]

Town

Bellaphant
acryon
Aristophanes
heuristically_alone
Severa
Flubbernugget
duppin
SnarkySnowman
pistachi0n
Blue Yoshi
Postie
Not_Mafia

Scum

[acryon]

Town

Bellaphant
acryon
Aristophanes
heuristically_alone
Severa
Flubbernugget
duppin
SnarkySnowman
pistachi0n
Blue Yoshi
Postie

Not_Mafia

Scum

Actually move Postie below you on my list.

[Not_Mafia]

I cannot tell a lie