Mass Effect Mafia - [Game Over]

[Cake Effect]

It would appear that Nahdia is the only one with a brain.
It would also appear that Cake belongs to a party who's win condition does not involve the survival of humans.

Further analysis to follow once I've had the time to look through the thread in more detail.

Vote: Cake Effect

The hell?
First you say "What if we kill off the humans?" Once the Asari and Turians clearly don't care for you, you go and say we're all stupid idiots.
You're explaining right now if you have a read.

[Painbringer]

SethYazura has requested replament. Searching.

[Nahdia]

I was not kidding. Bait is town through and through and the people who are pushing super hard on him as having scumclaimed are probably scum trying to get an easy mislynch off.

[FA_Q2]

I was not kidding. Bait is town through and through and the people who are pushing super hard on him as having scumclaimed are probably scum trying to get an easy mislynch off.

Tell me what valid conclusions you can draw from an outright scumclaim like that.

[FA_Q2]

who avoided that?

~Elsa

bait has scumclaimed and only has seven votes.
ranger doesn't want to vote bait because she doesn't want a quicklynch even though he was only at, like, L-8 at the time.

for the people who said bait scumclaiming was insane; i sort-of disagree. humans don't have majority so bait is pitching to the neutrals to be pro-scum. we have to hope the neutrals see the light, but most of all we have to vote bait.
-MM4

I am completly agreed with this , but scum hunting shouldn't stop. we have plenty of time to push him.

whats your read on beeboy?

~Elsa

Beeboy doesn't really need to be read because the Asari can target him for us.
Bait and Ranger are the two solid scumreads.

seven left.

I don't really get the case on ranger. Every game I play with him he seems to be universally scum read out the gate without a real reason. Tell me what I am missing.

[Nahdia]

Tell me what valid conclusions you can draw from an outright scumclaim like that.

the people who are pushing super hard on him as having scumclaimed are probably scum trying to get an easy mislynch off.

[Nahdia]

Bait didn't even scumclaim. They asked people thought of an idea, making no assertions about their own alignment.

[FA_Q2]

I'm 14. lol

This is immaterial. You have avoided posting actual content. Do you have something worth posting?

[FA_Q2]

Tell me what valid conclusions you can draw from an outright scumclaim like that.

the people who are pushing super hard on him as having scumclaimed are probably scum trying to get an easy mislynch off.

Pushing super hard?
Not a lot of pushing as the statement speaks for itself. When someone says something super scummy it is NOT a sane response to declare that those voting on it are suddenly scum. That is pointless circular logic. You end up town reading those that say scummy shit.

That makes no sense.

[Nahdia]

What he said wasn't scummy at all though and anyone who is like, insisting everyone else vote them or something is clearly scum just trying to make the most justifiable mislynch. But if you actually use your freaking brain and look at Bait's post, it's obvious he's human. What fucking alien makes an entrance like that? Read his goddamn name, dude. It's

bait

.

[Nahdia]

On that note:

VOTE: Cake Effect

[Varsoon]

Can someone explain how/where bait scumclaimed? I'm not really seeing it.

@curiouskarmadog: What question about Party Boat?

[beeboy]

Can someone explain how/where bait scumclaimed? I'm not really seeing it.

@curiouskarmadog: What question about Party Boat?

He didn't scum claim, he made a completely unproductive post and didn't follow up on it. He also still hasn't made any pro town content outside saying the person defending him is the only intelligent player. He is obviously reading the game and he isn't doing anything.

[Varsoon]

@beeboy: So you think we should lynch him?
Also, I'm fine with going along with your plan but, honestly, I'm the only person who's likely to die N1.

[Bait]

Can someone explain how/where bait scumclaimed? I'm not really seeing it.

@curiouskarmadog: What question about Party Boat?

He didn't scum claim, he made a completely unproductive post and didn't follow up on it. He also still hasn't made any pro town content outside saying the person defending him is the only intelligent player. He is obviously reading the game and he isn't doing anything.

This is a rather gross misrepresentation.

Firstly, how was it unproductive? Even if it were, how is it indicative of my alignment? What is your reasoning behind saying I didn't follow up, and even if I did not, once again how would that be alignment indicative?

Secondly, I'm not calling Nahdia smart because she's defending me. It's because she actually has a brain and is probably human-friendly.

Lastly, that last line of yours is unproven slander written with the intent of mislynching.

Beeboy can join Cake on my list of Nine.

[curiouskarmadog]

varsoon, I only have a handful of posts you had to go though.

not sure why you "keep" missing it.

VOTE: TTH

what about what she said made you vote her?


also
VOTE: party boat

this looks like more fun.

Not a huge fan of people piling on to vote FA_Q2 because of the replace-out.

Huh..lets check the tape.

Post 87 DGB votes FA
Post 114, TTH votes FA
Post 116...you post but no TTH vote.
Post 118 party boat votes FA
Post 126...you post but no TTH vote.
Post 134 I vote TTH
Post 142 you vote TTH.

Soooo, why did FA get a vote for “piling on a vote” but party boat didnt?

And...who exactly was “piling on votes” at that point?

your reasoning doesnt ring true. explain to me why it is.

VOTE: TTH

also
VOTE: party boat

this looks like more fun.

you are on the path to an enjoyable game my friend.

do you believe I'm likely to not be in or aligned with your faction? Or do you just think what you've seen of my play so far is likely to be a liability to the town? or am i just being annoying enough to justify voting?
something else is fine too

(dont know, probably)( no? given the set up, how do you define town?)( no)( maybe? or maybe gut...i really love gut voting.).

or...you could just ask me why I am voting you.

[Varsoon]

....do you mean "why did TTH get a vote when Party Boat didn't?"

[curiouskarmadog]

Can someone explain how/where bait scumclaimed? I'm not really seeing it.

@curiouskarmadog: What question about Party Boat?

He didn't scum claim, he made a completely unproductive post and didn't follow up on it. He also still hasn't made any pro town content outside saying the person defending him is the only intelligent player. He is obviously reading the game and he isn't doing anything.

This is a rather gross misrepresentation.

Firstly, how was it unproductive? Even if it were, how is it indicative of my alignment? What is your reasoning behind saying I didn't follow up, and even if I did not, once again how would that be alignment indicative?

Secondly, I'm not calling Nahdia smart because she's defending me. It's because she actually has a brain and is probably human-friendly.

Lastly, that last line of yours is unproven slander written with the intent of mislynching.

Beeboy can join Cake on my list of Nine.

I am voting you.

what is my brain and friendliness to humans status.

[curiouskarmadog]

EDIT

Soooo, why did

FA

TTH get a vote for “piling on a vote” but party boat didnt?

jesus fuck...answer the question.

[TellTaleHeart]

Tell me what valid conclusions you can draw from an outright scumclaim like that.

the people who are pushing super hard on him as having scumclaimed are probably scum trying to get an easy mislynch off.

Pushing super hard?
Not a lot of pushing as the statement speaks for itself. When someone says something super scummy it is NOT a sane response to declare that those voting on it are suddenly scum. That is pointless circular logic. You end up town reading those that say scummy shit.

That makes no sense.

This is scum.

[Dwlee99]

FA maybe if you were reading youd see me stating how bait scum claimed (asking to kill all humans)

[Varsoon]

@curiouskarmadog: Probably between gut, TTH being second on the pile-on, the nature of TTH's vote vs Party Boat's, and the fact you voted TTH which made the TTH wagon more realistic?
If that doesn't satisfy you, I don't have an answer that will.

[Varsoon]

@Dwlee: Just like how BBT scumclaimed in Cyberpunk?

[Dwlee99]

Wait what did bbt do? I cant remember.

[Party Boat]

words

Bait, what exactly did you expect to be the reaction to your thought experiment? Because I don't see any reaction from the game as a whole that could have come out of it that would have been beneficial to humans, and people who are humans (or at the verrry least are claiming to be human or claiming to be win with them) voting you was pretty obviously going to happen from suggesting it.