Mass Effect Mafia - [Game Over]

[Cake Effect]

I was not kidding. Bait is town through and through and the people who are pushing super hard on him as having scumclaimed are probably scum trying to get an easy mislynch off.

Bait didn't even scumclaim. They asked people thought of an idea, making no assertions about their own alignment.

What he said wasn't scummy at all though and anyone who is like, insisting everyone else vote them or something is clearly scum just trying to make the most justifiable mislynch. But if you actually use your freaking brain and look at Bait's post, it's obvious he's human. What fucking alien makes an entrance like that? Read his goddamn name, dude. It's

bait

.

Developing a scum read on Nahdia. Completely illogical to get a Human read on Bait after he suggested trying to massacre all Humans. If it was a reaction test it was godawful.

-SC

[Cake Effect]

Haster/Muriel, why no vote?

People and Reactions to them: Final thoughts also posted

Varsoon is a straight out of the gate thinker. In my opinion that strategy for all of its flawed nature and incorrect ideas about game play mechanics suggest that he is not in the KSG because I feel like no mafiaesque faction would let one of their players out of the gate with that kind of questioning mindset. So probably aligned with the town.post 52 I believe that this is the right mindset. If town and aligned factions of town were to look with that perspective then for a time there would be a larger majority against a much smaller team. This will begin to fail when people need one faction to win, but for the time being, this is good day play.

Claim made, positive feelings solidified.

Cake Effect suggests the negative right away. While I agree that would be the negative. (Post 15) It is also not the right mind set to look at the game because worrying about what one hand is doing will sink your own team and everyone else. Therefore, I tend to find this comment scum motivated because it keeps people from thinking or discussing Varsoon's strategy.

Feelings do not mesh, not a potential ally at this time

Ana and Elsa: post 29 Day phases are important because they give a chance for the town and thos aligned with the town to sort out the alignments of others. Day phases act in order to see relationship profiles between people and look for links in communication and game perspective. The linking of ideas will allow us a great web of information to draw from as town. Wanting only night phases until some kind of majority is reached is scum motivated. post 54 This comment is scummy because wanting one faction to die is not really indicative of scumminess as that is the total goal of this game? post 63 This is a ridiculous comment because it gives which ever faction does not win with him a free night kill.

Scum all the way...

Thoughts on Set up:

Their cop actions can't be redirected/framed, i kinda doubt anything else exists to dilute them. and the race numbers are public. I don't know Mass Effect THAT well (played with 1 and 2 once) but half-breeds doesn't ring any bells.

Why would there not be things to dilute them. I have to assume there is at least a roleblocker in this game. Or it would not be beyond the stretch of imagination.

-There was a boring fight on page 4 about Beeboy's meta-
(Through Page 5)

What the heck is this "positive feelings/not a potential ally at this time" stuff?

-SC

[Suzune]

Player read by through pages 5-10

Yume: A little effort would be appreciated. While I can respect poetry, I also think an opinion is worth more.

Could use more content...

Party Boat: I can appreciated your attitude towards the game.

I'm kind of apathetic towards this slot

Cake Effect: post 154This is a post I can get behind. Makes a lot of sense and is also my way of looking at the game.

Quick a polarizing mix of feelings here

Nos: post 158I disagree while it is not one hundred percent a good plan, at the same time it isolates the number of people with private topics from the number of people without. Since town wins without and has the most people in the faction it makes sense to balance out that way when attempting to scum hunt, especially when scum hunting as town post 168While we cannot all win together early games alignments and mutual scum hunting will be the way to win. If we go into this seeing only enemies then we lose early. The enemy of my enemy is my friend, but they remain my enemy.

Would lynch here

FAQ2: post 233Set up wise you are correct that Varsoon and Beeboy should be enemies. However, depends on what the plan is. Varsoon needs townies on his side and Beeboy does too. at this stage of the game it is best for them to hit the only mafia faction they have in common as an enemy because of the night kill power of said faction.

Just interesting for now

Bait: post 243 Is the point of the thought experiment to figure out how people respond to this. To see who might be silly enough to agree or the fess our all the townie who will turn this down. Seems like an awfully big gamble.

Alignments formed: (Either obviously or in my eyes)
Varsoon-Beeboy

[heuristically_alone]

the guy named bait. might be baiting.

Has a point. Bait could be taking one for the team to help find others factions. Anti-humans would be less likely to vote Bait. But seriously who gives up their slot and so willingly dies. More likely scum.

VOTE: Bait

[Suzune]

What the heck is this "positive feelings/not a potential ally at this time" stuff?

So did you read my opening post or just the long one? I said that I believe that in this game is mostly a ffa. In a ffa, having early gae allies is important for making a collection of information and early support. While the removal of factions or close to it make it a hard thing to do in the long run. So I have positive feelings about your slot in this game, but I am unsure you are my ally.

[Suzune]

I have to run, I am sure there will be like another ten pages when I come back, but I will keep going and sorting people as I go.

I am going to leave my vote here

VOTE: Nos Although I still think Ana and Elsa would also be a good choice.

[Elsa and Anna]

Rc is appalled at how every single scum player is claiming scumreads on us.

[heuristically_alone]

It would appear that Nahdia is the only one with a brain.
It would also appear that Cake belongs to a party who's win condition does not involve the survival of humans.

Further analysis to follow once I've had the time to look through the thread in more detail.

Vote: Cake Effect

Doesn't know that all humans has brain. Failure to know human anatomy = obv scum

[KuroiXHF]

dayvig: Kuroi

Do town typically have dayvigs?

Vote: Kurio

I think you're overreacting on two fake actions.

Why?

So to clarify, the gladiate and dayvig actions were fake?

@mod fake actions should be deemed unacceptable, especially with vast setups like this

You are just adorable.

[heuristically_alone]

I was not kidding. Bait is town through and through and the people who are pushing super hard on him as having scumclaimed are probably scum trying to get an easy mislynch off.

So you are saying that there are 10 scum?

[heuristically_alone]

On that note:

VOTE: Cake Effect

And you happen to make the same vote Bait made which made no sense. If Bait flips scum, Nahdia should be the next to go. If flips human, well then Nahdia, I guess you're safe from lynches for the rest of the game

[Elsa and Anna]

Ha is scum as well

[Suzune]

Out of curiosity Elsa and Anna, is anyone not scum for you?

[heuristically_alone]

Wait what did bbt do? I cant remember.

In Cyberpunk, BBT was put under pressure after skirting by several days, to which he was just like, "Lol yeah I messed up my scum claim."
He later defended that it was a joke.
And it was a joke.
:/

For saying something so obviously stupid in the game, sounds like cyberpunk deserved to die. Not a great way to defend oneself

[Painbringer]

Vote: Kurio

I think you're overreacting on two fake actions.

Why?

So to clarify, the gladiate and dayvig actions were fake?

@mod fake actions should be deemed unacceptable, especially with vast setups like this

While your point of view is noted, a good mod cannot confirm if any action is fake or real. All players deserve the right to any fake claim they can create

within the rules

. I can confirm that all actions up to this point have been resolved correctly.

[beeboy]

Rc is appalled at how every single scum player is claiming scumreads on us.

If you have so many scum reads why are you hard pushing the only person with a confirmable role?

[Nahdia]

My post immediately prior to my vote should make it obvious why I'm voting there.

[Varsoon]

VOTE: Elsa and Anna
I'm more comfortable with my vote here for now.
Also, jeeze, I'm hungry and broke.
Anyone wanna buy me a pizza?

[KuroiXHF]

Vote: Kurio

I think you're overreacting on two fake actions.

Why?

VOTE: Kuri-

Wait, who the hell is Kurio?

[Spiffeh]

TTH why are you doing jack shit

[Varsoon]

I think a Kurio is, like, a rare, unusual, or intriguing object.

[Spiffeh]

Oh my God heuristically_alone is absolutely scum

[beeboy]

VOTE: E&A

meh I see RC playing like this if he isn't a godfather.

[Spiffeh]

Elsa and Anna is not getting lynched today you can all stop wasting your time.

[Varsoon]

Oh my God heuristically_alone is absolutely scum

whyso?