Open 638: Friends and Enemies! (And Enemies!) - GAME OVER!

[Ozymandias]

Who do you think is Ranger's buddy, Karnos?

[karnos]

Is it really rolefishing to discuss a claimed role and the validity of it? Anyway, whatever, if you trust him I guess that is good enough for me.

And yes, I see the case against Masq. Seems solid. I'll hold on voting because I don't see any point in rushing it.

[Ozymandias]

Town:
Me
Kill
Kasu
Kop, maybe? Depends if Mason, really. Putting him here for now, if he is not Mason, put him at the bottom of the group below:

Probably Town, ordered from most trusted to less:
Karnos
Charloux
Creature

Probably Scum:
Joe

Scum:
Masquerade

[Creature]

but I don't want to play the waiting game, I feel like we have discussed enough.

[Ozymandias]

I agree.

Karnos, put your vote down, Masquerade has only two votes on him anyway.

[karnos]

Who do you think is Ranger's buddy, Karnos?

If I were to ignore the mason claims, and/or assume they are a complete lie?

kop was very low activity early game, and still doesn't seem to post much, makes me think he was partnered with *someone*, and obviously isn't a real mason

KTS I already post this earlier in the thread, I thought then that scumKTS may have picked ranger as a "mason" because ranger was his scum partner. the absurdity of it is exactly why it works, nobody suspects KTS of being anything but town because what scum would do that? obviously this theory is useless if KTS is a real mason - I don't need to pursue it, because the real masons know the truth.

creature on review, it seems creature and ranger mostly rated each other as solid town, and creature repeatedly defended ranger when ranger was accused of scummy behavior. other than ranger interactions, I don't have much of a read on creature, he is a bit of a wildcard so it's possible he is the other mafia.

javajoe, already mentioned by others as a possibility: sure. maybe. not my first pick though.

Others: I eliminated some from consideration because I don't think scum would bus hard in this setup, of course I could be wrong on that. I am also eliminating obv town or masons from consideration.

[karnos]

I agree.

Karnos, put your vote down, Masquerade has only two votes on him anyway.

Fine.

VOTE: Masquerade

[Ozymandias]

Who do you think is Ranger's buddy, Karnos?

If I were to ignore the mason claims, and/or assume they are a complete lie?

kop was very low activity early game, and still doesn't seem to post much, makes me think he was partnered with *someone*, and obviously isn't a real mason

KTS I already post this earlier in the thread, I thought then that scumKTS may have picked ranger as a "mason" because ranger was his scum partner. the absurdity of it is exactly why it works, nobody suspects KTS of being anything but town because what scum would do that? obviously this theory is useless if KTS is a real mason - I don't need to pursue it, because the real masons know the truth.

creature on review, it seems creature and ranger mostly rated each other as solid town, and creature repeatedly defended ranger when ranger was accused of scummy behavior. other than ranger interactions, I don't have much of a read on creature, he is a bit of a wildcard so it's possible he is the other mafia.

javajoe, already mentioned by others as a possibility: sure. maybe. not my first pick though.

Others: I eliminated some from consideration because I don't think scum would bus hard in this setup, of course I could be wrong on that. I am also eliminating obv town or masons from consideration.

I have yet to look into Creature/Ranger, but I don't really think Creature would do the whole deal with Ranger about putting the Moderator in the reads list, if they were scumbuddies. Other than that, I don't think they have had many interactions as far as I remember, so you have a point there. If Joe flips Town, they are the next one I would look into, probably.

So, do you consider Charloux obvious Town?

[Creature]

I feel confident Javajoe will flip scum.

[Ozymandias]

Ye, probably will.

[karnos]

So, do you consider Charloux obvious Town?

No. I didn't see much posting from him at all, and even when he did post it seemed like half of it was complaining about some real life situation he was in.

So, he is also a wildcard, but without the ranger interactions seen from creature I didn't rate him higher as a likely scum. If all of my above scum reads turn out false, I'd consider charloux the next possibility, but I think he is probably just a VT with some real life distractions keeping him from focusing fully on the game.

[Ozymandias]

Alright, I feel similarly, I do believe them to be Town, barring surprise from Masq and/or Joe. Well, I believe everyone but Joe and Masquerade to be Town, honestly, simply to varying degrees of confidence.

VOTE: Masquerade

Someone hammer this.

[Ozymandias]

Everyone who wanted to talk, talked; besides Kop, but we may be stuck waiting a while there.

I would rather work on Joe tomorrow, with the confirm that Masquerade is Werewolf and one more Town flip.

[Creature]

We should vote for a nightskip.

[Ozymandias]

Can we?

[Creature]

I think so.

[Charloux]

VOTE: Masquerade
@Scum: Kill me tonight please <3

[Charloux]

I'm okay with a night skip.
VOTE: Nightskip

[Ozymandias]

VOTE: Masquerade
@Scum: Kill me tonight please <3

You are not getting your rhyme.

[Creature]

Well, now we wait Kuroi who's at the wedding

[Ozymandias]

Oh right, I forgot.

[Creature]

Choose your own adventure

You're Joe, full name's Java Joe Parker. You're home choosing who to kill.
(a) Kill obvious town
(b) Find the real mason
(c) Stay 2 days breathing before the final lynch
(d) Go to Kuroi's wedding

[Ozymandias]

Like a bird on the wire,
like a drunk in a midnight choir
I have tried in my way to be free.

I want this as my epigraph, Kuroi.

[Ozymandias]

Choose your own adventure

You're Joe, full name's Java Joe Parker. You're home choosing who to kill.
(a) Kill obvious town
(b) Find the real mason
(c) Stay 2 days breathing before the final lynch
(d) Go to Kuroi's wedding

Lol.

[Masquerade]

Was that hammer?