Mini Normal 1797 Probably Not Actually Normal Mafia [GG]

[MURDERCAT]

Ego/I'm not scum. Can explain the replace out but I'd rather not.

[MURDERCAT]

Catchup comes in like an hour.

[MURDERCAT]

also i forgot my role again, whoops

no mafia PT so I can't be mafia.

either third party or town I guess, I vaguely remember being town but I'm not so sure

Has to do with this, not talking about it more unless there's intent on me. Catching up now.

[MURDERCAT]

nahdia - refusal to RVS in 6. I remember the first game on this site I read Nadia was scum and was weird about RVS.

Fire - probably not scum with sick after 9 and the following conversation.

Nahdia - also probably not scum with sick after 26.

Dramonic - 30 Also probably not scum with sick, but I could see this as a hop on by a second scum faction

inspector - 47 town motivation to try RQS to get the game going or scum motivation to keep it stalled on irrelevant content? Because he’s new I say lean town.

Dwlee - 51 agreed

necrogirl - 53 same as 47, could be commenting on game content but is instead talking about useless stuff. No pass for being new for you, asking the questions is an attempt to get the gaming going, but answering them is a great opportunity for scum to like they are doing something. No comments on anything else is also suspicious.

Nahdia - 63 I care less about the RQS answers from nahdia because she contributed about other things also.

NM - in a recent game I agreed with everything NM said and we were both town. I completely disagree with 87. NM doesn’t produce a lot of content so this will have to be worthy of a scum read.

nahdia 102 town

(side note, holy shit sick is so scum, I see why it only took a few pages)

dramonic - 147 through 156 I feel like I should have a read on these posts but I don’t. almost definitely not scum with sick though

almost - 174 fucking called it. Will look at this again later

snoe 177 Kappy is double voter though…………

cooldog - 178 good shit here

nm - 179 ughhhh don’t like it, how are you not on sick right now

cooldog - 180 disagree, probably nm

GOT brb 1 hour

hype hype hype

[MURDERCAT]

Ugh stream sucks whatever I'll watch it later

[MURDERCAT]

Where was I?

Dwlee99 - 207 Is this a joke? I’ve at least one of your games dwlee, I but I can’t tell if this is a joke. If not this post is terrible

211 This is bad too dwlee

snoe - 230 Maybe a scum obeying? Not believing he is just now seeing the double vote.

necro - 240 so bad, necro and dwlee are scum together

snoe - weird back and forth on kappy 243

cooldog - 250 thank you

inspector - 285 I don’t think it’s fake

snoe - 338 agree with this

cooldog - 343 mm I'm feeling you cooldog

blah blah blah ok

time to look at the wagon, then a reads lists.

[MURDERCAT]

I know I need to find 5 scum, but I only have 3 for you guys right now.

{cooldog,fire}
{dram,nahdia}
{snoe,inspector}
{Dwlee99,Necro,NM}

ugh who's the worst?

VOTE: Dwlee

Happy to vote the others too.

[MURDERCAT]

Cool, join me on necrogirl

Actually if there's a wagon I guess I should join that so my vote is doing something

VOTE: necro

They are scum together I think

[MURDERCAT]

also i forgot my role again, whoops

no mafia PT so I can't be mafia.

either third party or town I guess, I vaguely remember being town but I'm not so sure

Has to do with this, not talking about it more unless there's intent on me. Catching up now.

[MURDERCAT]

You think there's scum double voter in a normal? What made you change your mind?

[MURDERCAT]

And why snoe?

[MURDERCAT]

Well you can agree necro looks bad right now with the obvious sheep on you right? I'm town so vote there.

[MURDERCAT]

I'll go through the whole ISO for you.

well in answer to those questions

1. Necrogirl just sounds cool and has a nice ring to it I think.
2. I've only played twice on this site so far, this is my first game outside of road to rome, one of the 2 games was as scum.

Noob scum doesn't know how to get involved, but she can answer these irrelevant questions.

well it's proven that Kappy is a doublevoter, if they are scum they are simply too big a risk to keep in the game since they can hammer more easily, therefore they get my vote for now

Vote: Kappa

You may have changed your mind, but this is still a sheep on your reasoning. Still doesn't know how to get involved as scum.

hmm i'm not quite sure why everyone is convinced sickofit is scum, doesn't look like anything i'll say can change your mind though.

This post literally says nothing. More non-commitment.

[MURDERCAT]

Necro, post reads please.

[MURDERCAT]

Fire, thoughts? I don't like being on a wagon with a bunch of scum reads but there's probably 2 factions so I think it's fine.

[MURDERCAT]

I don't really see the town motivation in going to L-1 when she hasn't even posted on day 2 yet....

[MURDERCAT]

Was that a hammer!?

[MURDERCAT]

Seems premature, but I guess the odds are good at least lol.

[MURDERCAT]

Oh man I forget everything about this game. I'll look at stuff later. Anyone think it's interesting no scum have died at night?

[MURDERCAT]

3 to 4 yeah I guess we are.

[MURDERCAT]

We town are outnumbered 4 to 3

[MURDERCAT]

There's no way we lynch two scum of the same faction and still end up in lylo, there must be something else going on.

[MURDERCAT]

Can we setup spec? What else makes sense?

[MURDERCAT]

Don't power lynch me please I can be confirmed town.

[MURDERCAT]

I wouldn't do that normally but this game has been crazy and my slot is scummy as fuck

[MURDERCAT]

Do you want me to claim right now?

[MURDERCAT]

VOTE: dramonic

[MURDERCAT]

wait jk that assumes you are town UNVOTE:

[MURDERCAT]

I'm actually not sure how town wins this game unless there are traitors in the set up.

[MURDERCAT]

Right, but that is a scenario where we could lynch scum all three days and still lose which I really don't think is the case.

[MURDERCAT]

Maybe it's like 7-3-Traitor-Traitor-SK?

[MURDERCAT]

I disagree, I think town deserves at least one mislynch.

[MURDERCAT]

I fell like it's really unlikely that we would be in this scenario if there were two mafia teams.

[MURDERCAT]

I'm a mason. I was waiting for partner but whatever I already soft claimed. I'll wait for my partner to reveal themselves if they want to. I have a crumb I'll wait to post.

[MURDERCAT]

KTS admitted in mason thread after a long time he didn't read role pm so he was basically worthless as a mason, hence the replace (I think I don't know for sure).

[MURDERCAT]

That assumes you are town though.

[MURDERCAT]

KTS admitted in mason thread after a long time he didn't read role pm so he was basically worthless as a mason, hence the replace (I think I don't know for sure).

this doesn't make sense to me but ok

He said he didn't read role pm until Friday after the game started so like 5 days.

[MURDERCAT]

It's a bit different in a game where there's 6 anti town roles.

[MURDERCAT]

If you are the one townie left then the game is solved for you, please convince me and my partner you are town and we can still win. Hopefully last townie is a PR and the three of you are all scum.

[MURDERCAT]

We are mass claiming today, don't claim yet though I want to set an order.

[MURDERCAT]

Yeah, why wouldn't we?

[MURDERCAT]

It seems like we are somewhere near Mylo/lylo

[MURDERCAT]

I have a crumb scumhead my partner will confirm.

[MURDERCAT]

I won't let my partner die

[MURDERCAT]

just tell us if who we're about to lynch is your partner.

Will do

[MURDERCAT]

There's plenty of scum to lynch, no reason to lynch us yet.

[MURDERCAT]

Mason partner is still alive.

[MURDERCAT]

I really think traitors are in the game.

[MURDERCAT]

Yeah, I said to, waiting on partner. He will post my crumb.

[MURDERCAT]

Win with scum or endgamed I believe, at least that's what it says on the wiki.

[MURDERCAT]

He's not here though, I want him to say he's ok with claiming.

[MURDERCAT]

Well still it's not confirmed. He was here like 20 mins ago, I don't know where he went.

[MURDERCAT]

I'm thinking 7 - 3 - traitor - traitor - SK

[MURDERCAT]

7-3-3 is nowhere near balanced, right? Like if there's day 1 town lynch and 2 night kills then it's 4-3-3 and town still has no info. Seems really hard to win as town in 7-3-3.

[MURDERCAT]

4-3-1 is basically lylo, we should be careful with votes.

[MURDERCAT]

3-3-1*

[MURDERCAT]

Lol ok he's not showing up so yeah snoe is partner. He will post crumb eventually.

Dram is only scum if you are town. If you are town, everyone else is confirmed scum.

[MURDERCAT]

Need snoe's thoughts.

[MURDERCAT]

I'll read ISOs today and form an opinion.

[MURDERCAT]

Don't worry guys I solved the game (assuming we are in 7-3-3, otherwise these reads all suck). Dwlee town, Nahdia mafia, CD/dram/fire are werewolf.

[MURDERCAT]

Waiting on snoe's input now.

[MURDERCAT]

I am least sure of dwlee and nahdia. Either way we need to lynch werewolf so you are both safe.

[MURDERCAT]

Because I think CD/dram/fire are werewolf. Maybe Dram is last mafia and nahdia is werewolf. I think we should lynch fire personally.

[MURDERCAT]

Spoiler: votes

Vote Count 1.01

Almost50

CooLDoG
Firebringer -1 (

sickofit

)

Kappy

dramonic - 1 (firebringer)
Nahdia

Not_Mafia

Killthestory

Necrogirl

sickofit1138

snoe

Dwlee99

inspectorscout

Not voting -

Almost50

, CooLDoG,

Kappy

, dramonic, Nahdia,

Not_Mafia

,

Killthestory

,

Necrogirl

,

snoe

, Dwlee99,

inspectorscout

With 13 alive, it's 7 to lynch!

Mod Notes: None

Day 1 ends in: (expired on 2016-06-06 15:06:00)

Vote Count 1.02

Almost50

CooLDoG
Firebringer - 2 (

sickofit

,

inspectorscout

)

Kappy

dramonic - 1 (firebringer)
Nahdia

Not_Mafia

Killthestory

Necrogirl

sickofit1138

- 2 (nahdia, dramonic)

snoe

Dwlee99

inspectorscout

Not voting -

Almost50

, CooLDoG,

Kappy

,

Not_Mafia

,

Killthestory

,

Necrogirl

,

snoe

, Dwlee99

With 13 alive, it's 7 to lynch!

Mod Notes: None

Day 1 ends in: (expired on 2016-06-06 15:06:00)

Vote Count 1.03

Almost50

CooLDoG
Firebringer - 2 (

sickofit

,

inspectorscout

)

Kappy

dramonic
Nahdia

Not_Mafia

Killthestory

Necrogirl

sickofit1138

- 2 (nahdia, dramonic)

snoe

Dwlee99

inspectorscout

- 2 (Dwlee99, firebringer)

Not voting -

Almost50

, CooLDoG,

Kappy

,

Not_Mafia

,

Killthestory

,

Necrogirl

,

snoe

With 13 alive, it's 7 to lynch!

Mod Notes: None

Day 1 ends in: (expired on 2016-06-06 15:06:00)

Vote Count 1.04

Almost50

CooLDoG
Firebringer - 2 (

sickofit

,

inspectorscout

)

Kappy

dramonic
Nahdia - 1 (Dwlee99)

Not_Mafia

- 1 (

Almost50

)

Killthestory

- 2 (

Kappy

,

Kappy

)

Necrogirl

sickofit1138

- 2 (nahdia, dramonic)

snoe

Dwlee99

inspectorscout

- 2 (firebringer,

Not_Mafia

)

Not voting - CooLDoG,

Killthestory

,

Necrogirl

,

snoe

With 13 alive, it's 7 to lynch!

Mod Notes: None

Day 1 ends in: (expired on 2016-06-06 15:06:00)

Vote Count 1.05

Almost50

CooLDoG
Firebringer - 1 (

inspectorscout

)

Kappy

dramonic
Nahdia - 1 (Dwlee99)

Not_Mafia

- 1 (

Almost50

)

Killthestory

- 3 (

Kappy

,

Kappy

,

sickofit

)

Necrogirl

sickofit1138

- 3 (

Killthestory

nahdia, dramonic)

snoe

Dwlee99

inspectorscout

- 2 (firebringer,

Not_Mafia

)

Not voting - CooLDoG,

Necrogirl

,

snoe

With 13 alive, it's 7 to lynch!

Mod Notes: None

Day 1 ends in: (expired on 2016-06-06 15:06:00)

Vote Count 1.06

Almost50

CooLDoG
Firebringer - 1 (

inspectorscout

)

Kappy

dramonic - 1 (

sickofit

)
Nahdia - 1 (Dwlee99)

Not_Mafia

- 1 (

Almost50

)

Killthestory

- 2 (

Kappy

,

Kappy

)

Necrogirl

sickofit1138

- 3 (

Killthestory

nahdia, dramonic)

snoe

Dwlee99

inspectorscout

- 2 (firebringer,

Not_Mafia

)

Not voting - CooLDoG,

Necrogirl

,

snoe

With 13 alive, it's 7 to lynch!

Mod Notes: None

Day 1 ends in: (expired on 2016-06-06 15:06:00)

Vote Count 1.08

Almost50

CooLDoG
Firebringer - 1 (

sickofit

)

Kappy

- 2 (

Almost50

,

Necrogirl

)
dramonic - 0
Nahdia

Not_Mafia

- 1 (

inspectorscout

)

Killthestory

Necrogirl

sickofit1138

- 7 ( nahdia, dramonic, CooLDoG,

Not_Mafia

, firebringer,

Kappy

,

Kappy

)

snoe

- 1 (Dwlee99)
Dwlee99 - 1 (

Killthestory

)

inspectorscout

- 0

Not voting -

snoe

Mod Notes: None

sickofit1138

has been lynched. He was a

Mafia Goon

Night Actions are due by: (expired on 2016-06-05 09:11:00)

Vote Count 2.01

CooLDoG
Firebringer
dramonic
Nahdia

Not_Mafia

MURDERCAT

2 - firebringer,

Necrogirl

6 -

Not_Mafia

,

snoe

,

MURDERCAT

,

inspectorscout

, dramonic, dlwee,

snoe

Dwlee99 1

inspectorscout

Not voting - CooLDoG, Nahdia,

Necrogirl

With 10 alive, it's 6 to lynch!

Mod Notes: None

Necrogirl

has been lynched. She was a

Mafia Goon

Night Actions are due by: (expired on 2016-06-08 15:16:00)

[MURDERCAT]

So whoever is the last mafia bussed.

[MURDERCAT]

Dwlee and dram are least likely to be mafia.

[MURDERCAT]

VOTE: Dramonic

Claim please.

[MURDERCAT]

You should literally be fine lynching anyone but yourself.

[MURDERCAT]

They way you are reacting makes me like the vote.

[MURDERCAT]

VOTE: Cooldog
Him and fire are least likely to be mafia.

Why? I think you misunderstood.

[MURDERCAT]

You are werewolf

[MURDERCAT]

I think this is the safest lynch.

[MURDERCAT]

Anyone could be mafia. Your argument is based on the fact that you are town which makes it useless.

[MURDERCAT]

Uh we don't know you are town, make an argument that doesn't assume you are town and we can talk.

[MURDERCAT]

Dwlee, why were you so casual about hammering yesterday but so nervous now?

[MURDERCAT]

Dram please claim.

[MURDERCAT]

Dwlee, the fact dram hasn't been hammered means he's werewolf.

[MURDERCAT]

Dwlee? Little help?

[MURDERCAT]

Still town, hope we're right.

[MURDERCAT]

Tell me one of you has a crumb...

I'll think about this more later. Also how is fire confirmed scum? Can't he just come in here and say you guys claiming doc is some no kill gambit? Whatever he is still obv scum but if he is actually confirmed I'd like to know why.

Also can I just say I fucking called this game so hard. Called the werewolf team and I called there being a doc in the mason thread.

[MURDERCAT]

Dwlee what were your other night actions? Nahdia explain why dram please.

And please tell me one of you crumbed.

[MURDERCAT]

Crumbs, please I'm so hungry.

And other night actions and why.

Also why would you jailkeep nahdia instead of me that makes no fucking sense.

[MURDERCAT]

Unless Nahdia, is doc and one of the teams has 4 players? That wouldn't make sense....but then again is this supposed to? lol.

Explain why nahdia isn't confirmed scum please.

[MURDERCAT]

Everyone give their top two scum reads please and let's just lynch someone.

I still say chilled and infinity.

[MURDERCAT]

Lol wtf wrong game.

[MURDERCAT]

Yeah I know.

But what also doesn't make sense is why you would no protect night 1 when Kappy was alive...

Actually that goes for all of you. Why is Kappy dead?

[MURDERCAT]

I think I have a plan. I'm going to wait to share though, I have to talk to snoe.

[MURDERCAT]

I need more info from them.

[MURDERCAT]

Yeah to you. Things are different if either of them have a crumb though. Honestly I want you to be town so bad though because that means I called the game yesterday.

[MURDERCAT]

Yeah I think you are town, but I'm going to be very deliberate about this because I want this win real fucking bad.

[MURDERCAT]

But what happens if we kill doc and they both shoot town?

[MURDERCAT]

Also just a reminder that no one should try to talk to mod in thread about endgame scenarios. Please don't get modkilled, that would really suck.

[MURDERCAT]

It's honestly not as clear as that quote makes it seem. Obviously, cross killing loses for both of them, so they have to trust each other to shoot town.

[MURDERCAT]

How does town win if they go to 1-1?

[MURDERCAT]

We can go into 3-1 tomorrow if fire is scum.

[MURDERCAT]

No it's guaranteed 3-1. We say dwlee protect me, nahdia protect snoe and scum can't kill without outing themselves.

[MURDERCAT]

I like the odds in 3-1 better than trusting scum to cross kill.

[MURDERCAT]

And I'm almost positive fire is scum.

[MURDERCAT]

Dwlee protects murdercat.

Nahdia protects snoe.

Please confirm you read this and know what you are doing. If the person you are protecting dies, we will lynch you.

[MURDERCAT]

Yeah but I have another person to talk to that I know is town and that is really nice.

[MURDERCAT]

Ok fire is scum, I have snoe's blessing, let's do this.

VOTE: fire

if he's town, scum cross kill pls.

[MURDERCAT]

Dwlee we are pretty sure we're gunna lynch you.

[MURDERCAT]

Nahdia you never said if you had a crumb or anything

[MURDERCAT]

So you have nothing for me?

[MURDERCAT]

Can you show me anywhere you had a town doctor mindset?

[MURDERCAT]

I'm not sure how the dram thing is a smoking gun.

[MURDERCAT]

I had Dwlee as town doc before he claimed.

VOTE: Nahdia

GG, dwlee I hope your win condition matches mine. Sorry, Nahdia.

[MURDERCAT]

Snoe should show up eventually to hammer.

[MURDERCAT]

I'm busy for a while, if snoe is having doubts he can choose not to hammer.

[MURDERCAT]

After you knew a doctor was in the game.

[MURDERCAT]

No way

[MURDERCAT]

Wow crazy set up.

[MURDERCAT]

I was definitely confused because you didn't seem like a wolf based on interaction. I said in mason thread that I would trust dwlee if he claimed doctor and that's what happened.

[MURDERCAT]

You'll see in mason thread we went through the game and decided we were going to lynch you. Out of respect for your scum game I knew I wanted to decide and not let you get in my head. And to me your main points on dwlee didn't really sway me at all which says more about dwlee's town tells than you.

[MURDERCAT]

Thanks of course to mod for modding and my wonderful mason partner.

[MURDERCAT]

If you kill dwlee we would have been in 2-1-1, correct? In that case we have to no lynch and hope scum cross kill.

[MURDERCAT]

Town literally lynched all the scum except 1 and still barely won lol.

[MURDERCAT]

If you kill dwlee we would have been in 2-1-1, correct? In that case we have to no lynch and hope scum cross kill.

i trust firebringer to be honorable and kill you.

SK definitely deserves to win in that situation.

[MURDERCAT]

I didn't sign up! I just walked into a normal game as a replacement! Very fun set up, despite how crazy it is.

[MURDERCAT]

I don't think town should win 2-1-1.

[MURDERCAT]

I mean dwlee had posts that pinged me at the time that he could be a PR, so it's not really a fair comparison.

[MURDERCAT]

I'm really happy and suprised that in a 4 faction game each team had a horse in the race pretty deep in.

[MURDERCAT]

Also fire, I hate to lynch someone like that but I was never going to believe the jailkeeper claim.

[MURDERCAT]

Yeah, he definitely had to, but jailing nahdia didn't make sense.

[MURDERCAT]

Really you should be mad at dwlee.

[MURDERCAT]

Mafia topic?