Mini 1806 : DotA Mafia [Round 1 - SD] (Game Over ?!)

[Frozen Angel]

Vote Count 1.1

Fire Assassin (2) : Dunnstral , Nosferatu
Yume (1) : Fire Assassin

Not Voting (7) : Shiro , Snarky Snowman , Yume , Ircher , Radical Rat , thenewearth , Masquerade

With 10 players alive it takes 6 votes to lynch.

Day 1 ends in (expired on 2016-07-09 05:30:00)

One of the jobs of every good support , is to put down sentry wards to reveal invisible enemies and wards!

[Dunnstral]

Didn't he concede that outting discards was a bad idea anyways?

I don't understand why he claimed to have discarded naga siren, I looked at her abilities and I really can't see the point.

[Fire Assassin]

A) Assuming you told the truth, you already gave out 1 less threat to scum
B) Assuming you lied, you lied.
C) We already had the discussion and we have been saying it over and over again that discards are crap and 99.9% anti-town by now ESPECIALLY since its day 1.
C.1) That giving out discards is as good as PR fishing
C.2) Even you agreed to that, STILL you did it anyways
D) You're trying to get away from voting me and dismissing it as "miscommunication and I just thought it was scummy"

A) Thats not how roles work in general in this.
B) Okay? Why would I lie? Someone would have that pick. You realize that, right?
C) Yes, we had a discussion, and decided giving out ALL the discards was anti town, because it gives scum too much information on roles.
C.1) No, giving out a discard only gives out what roles aren't in the game. They don't give out my role or anyone else.
C.2) Yes, and I explained why.
D) Because I actually think we had horrible communication problems where both of us weren't reading each others posts.

That about sums it up.

[thenewearth]

One of the jobs of every good support , is to put down sentry wards to reveal invisible enemies and wards!

[/align]

JA NYYYYYYYYYX

NYX NYX NYX NYX NYX

[thenewearth]

This isn't gonna go anywhere anytime until someone else posts about it

But I ain't changing my vote

[Nosferatu]

Ego

[Masquerade]

Fire, what's your reasoning behind outing one of your discards? What was your goal with that? Because in our pt I felt you were town because of your hands-on approach of this game, but seeing you claim that discard, and then checking out what it is, makes me think you want us to think you are town a little too much. Do you want everybody to claim 1 discard? If not, what makes it so important that you share a discard and the rest does not?

[Ircher]

VOTE: Nos

[Ircher]

The Dire neighborhood is dead silent

[Ircher]

VOTE: Shiro

Obviously isn't reading.

[Ircher]

Fire, what's your reasoning behind outing one of your discards? What was your goal with that? Because in our pt I felt you were town because of your hands-on approach of this game, but seeing you claim that discard, and then checking out what it is, makes me think you want us to think you are town a little too much. Do you want everybody to claim 1 discard? If not, what makes it so important that you share a discard and the rest does not?

I would like to know too, BUT

@Mod - Don't the Single Draft rules state you will show all the discarded heroes, but not who discarded them?

[thenewearth]

Fire, what's your reasoning behind outing one of your discards? What was your goal with that? Because in our pt I felt you were town because of your hands-on approach of this game, but seeing you claim that discard, and then checking out what it is, makes me think you want us to think you are town a little too much. Do you want everybody to claim 1 discard? If not, what makes it so important that you share a discard and the rest does not?

I would like to know too, BUT

@Mod - Don't the Single Draft rules state you will show all the discarded heroes, but not who discarded them?

its 30 heroes, 10 players, 3 heroes each

Announcing it is basically saying "Hey here are all the roles in the game"

Which is why we had the arguement

[Ircher]

But its parts of the rules is what I'm saying.

[Frozen Angel]

Fire, what's your reasoning behind outing one of your discards? What was your goal with that? Because in our pt I felt you were town because of your hands-on approach of this game, but seeing you claim that discard, and then checking out what it is, makes me think you want us to think you are town a little too much. Do you want everybody to claim 1 discard? If not, what makes it so important that you share a discard and the rest does not?

I would like to know too, BUT

@Mod - Don't the Single Draft rules state you will show all the discarded heroes, but not who discarded them?

as I said in the sign up thread , single draft in this run is modified in a way that I won't announce the discarded heroes.

- [Modified] Single Draft : Each player then will receive 3 heroes. They must discard 2 heroes and pick 1 to pick. The discarded heroes won't be announced unlike the main version that is announced in setup thread (becuase only 30 heroes are in game so far).

[Radical Rat]

VOTE: Fire Assassin

Thought he was sketchy in the Radiant chat, and like him even less here.

[Radical Rat]

Points of suspicion are:

- Inconsistency
- Anti-Town sentiments ( Massclaiming early )
- LAMIST

[Dunnstral]

The Dire neighborhood is dead silent

Pretty much expected

Perhaps they were busy talking in their scum chat, instead?



Also Racical's vote here is ew as he has to overexplain it but wasn't actually there in the pre-game chat

[Radical Rat]

The Dire neighborhood is dead silent

Pretty much expected

Perhaps they were busy talking in their scum chat, instead?



Also Racical's vote here is ew as he has to overexplain it but wasn't actually there in the pre-game chat

Would you have preferred a naked vote?

As for why I wasn't there, may I direct your attention to my V/LA banner? Or perhaps the post I did make in the Radiant chat?

[Shiro]

VOTE: Shiro

Obviously isn't reading.

Nah man, I am reading

[Radical Rat]

Before we get too far along, I'd like to politely request that the Survivor come forward. You don't have to if you're scared, but I see no reason why either side should kill a Survivor.

And scum: don't even think about faking. I will find out, and you will be lynched.

[Radical Rat]

VOTE: Shiro

Obviously isn't reading.

Nah man, I am reading

This is Shiro's first post in the thread. What made you think they weren't reading Ircher?

[Ircher]

Clan PT

[Ircher]

Before we get too far along, I'd like to politely request that the Survivor come forward. You don't have to if you're scared, but I see no reason why either side should kill a Survivor.

And scum: don't even think about faking. I will find out, and you will be lynched.

Thats a horrible suggestion -- Doing so is against their win con since survivor cant win with town or mafia

[Radical Rat]

Before we get too far along, I'd like to politely request that the Survivor come forward. You don't have to if you're scared, but I see no reason why either side should kill a Survivor.

And scum: don't even think about faking. I will find out, and you will be lynched.

Thats a horrible suggestion -- Doing so is against their win con since survivor cant win with town or mafia

I thought all Survivor had to do was be alive at the end of the game, regardless of which faction wins?

[Radical Rat]

Clan PT

The Dire neighborhood is dead silent