Mini 1806 : DotA Mafia [Round 1 - SD] (Game Over ?!)

[Frozen Angel]

Vote Count 1.6

Radical Rat (4) : Fire Assassin , thenewearth , Shiro , Vedith
SnarkySnowman (3) : Ircher , Masquerade , Radical Rat
Vedith (1) : Dunnstral

Not Voting (2) : Yume , SnarkySnowman

With 10 players alive it takes 6 votes to lynch.

Day 1 ends in (expired on 2016-07-09 05:30:00)

In case of emergency just deny yourself.

[Ircher]

It's a problem cuz there's always those people who lolhammer as either alignment.

And those people are anti town regardless and need dealing with.
I've not seen it in any games I've read up on recently. Not to say it won't happen though.

Some of them are decent even if they are a pain in the neck. It's more common than you think.

[Vedith]

Some of them are decent even if they are a pain in the neck. It's more common than you think.

Yeah I'm not arguing how commend they are, as it's actually down to the style of player you have in the game than not imo.
I'm just saying I haven't seen it since I've been back.

I can see your concern, I just feel that L2 means nothing now days.

[thenewearth]

How ironic is that a survivor is survivor hunting.

Bzzt

[Fire Assassin]

How ironic is that a survivor is survivor hunting.

Bzzt

Am I missing some context here? What you referring to?

[Radical Rat]

No one said they are lynching you right now. Why are you so paranoid?

I just got called a valid lynch, and votes started piling on.

[Ircher]

How ironic is that a survivor is survivor hunting.

Bzzt

Am I missing some context here? What you referring to?

Same

[Masquerade]

Hey Vedith, why do you want a lynch so badly?
Do you have strong reads on Snarky, Yume and maybe Shiro? Snarky and Yume have not said anything about reads, how is a lynch going to help sort them?

I'll get back to this later, gtg now.

I want the game to progress. It's been a few days without any actual content or anything that has changed my mind on anything.
What are you hoping to gain in 3/4 days from Yume/Snarky/Shiro which hasn't been provided already?

Best case scenario we can use WotC to get them replaced rn. Not Shiro necessarily, she posted, but Yume and Snarky, please, get someone in that wants to play.

I'm ok with lynching Radical, his reads were pretty off as mentioned before. But I would very much like for Yume and Snarky to take a stance on him. At the very least.

[Masquerade]

Just to be clear: I am not stating intent here. I do not have intent, I will have intent once Snarky and Yume (or their respective replacements) have given a read on at least Rat but preferably more.

[Masquerade]

How is it even that someone thinks oh let me sign up for that game, and then don't play? What are they doing here? What's the fun in being asked constantly for providing input? In Snarky's case (because I don't know Yume) what's the fun in getting mislynched in most of your games because you just won't play?
Seriously, explain it to me because I don't get it!

[Frozen Angel]

I'm not sure what should I do about Yume as she said she is sick in her last post but she is in prod range.

I will prod her 24 hour late. (mean tomorrow)

[Radical Rat]

Technically, I did hit L-1, and I said I would claim. I worry this will get me NKed, but if I get lynched that won't matter anyway.

I'm Town Bane, with current abilities Enfeeble and Brain Sap, both of which allow me to mess with the votes. Enfeeble will let me remove someone's voting ability, and Brain Sap will let me redirect votes off of me.

I don't think anyone on my wagon is lynch-worthy ( Lynching Survivor is a dick move imo, and I feel like actual Scum is either Yume, Snarky, or both ), and while removing a vote is tempting, I'd rather the votes on me be moved somewhere useful.

[Fire Assassin]

Can I ask you what the purpose is of revealing roles in this? It only gives scum more info if we decided not to lynch you and you are town. Can you explain why this was a necessity?

You aren't more town based on your role. Or anything.

[Radical Rat]

I'm hoping it explains some of the odd things about my play.

But if you didn't want me to claim, you should have said something earlier when I said I would claim at L-1.

[Fire Assassin]

It actually would have been better to give us discards imo then role.
Meh.

I didn't read that part about you going to claim, would have said something.

[Vedith]

@Radical - I can easily see scum in Yume or Snarky (I would expect more Snarky) but I'm doubtful on both of them.
So out of the remaining players, who do you see as higher potential scum?

Also, I have no issue with the claim personally. Although I'm surprised you did it at L2.
Can someone confirm if the setup was 100% random on roles and align? Because if not I can see it being swayed to have more of possibility as a town role rather than a scum role.

[Fire Assassin]

Can someone confirm if the setup was 100% random on roles and align? Because if not I can see it being swayed to have more of possibility as a town role rather than a scum role.

3 picks were randomly assigned.
The teams were randomly distributed
The players got all of these randomly.

The thing players pick are one of the roles they have out of the 3 given.

[Vedith]

Then yeah I guess we can only work out if roles are scum or town by events in the game and how they use it.

[Radical Rat]

Out of the remaining players, it'd have to be either you, Shiro, or FA.

Though it should be noted that this is D1, and it's all subject to change as more information comes out.

[Vedith]

Out of the remaining players, it'd have to be either you, Shiro, or FA.

Though it should be noted that this is D1, and it's all subject to change as more information comes out.

By FA I assume you mean Fire, and not the Mod, right?

[Ircher]

Tbh, I think Radical just claimed to be Survivor.....

Out of those choices, I'd lynch Shiro first.

[Dunnstral]

( Lynching Survivor is a dick move imo, and I feel like actual Scum is either Yume, Snarky, or both )

This is claiming survivor right?

Survivor can win with the mafia, you're not necessarily town aligned.

That being said, I'd absolutely vote for you but also want to get vedith and I don't like how he was spinning this story where you were mafia and not survivor


Also from now on everybody gets to be in awe of my scumhunting skills this game

[Dunnstral]

@Radical - I can easily see scum in Yume or Snarky (I would expect more Snarky)

Why snarky more than Yume?

[Radical Rat]

That was not claiming survivor. I said earlier that I thought Vedith was Survivor, and that but was my explanation for not Brain Sapping him.

[thenewearth]

Why the fuck did someone claim on L-2?

Why the fuck would they say "surviror lynching is a dick move"?