So you're saying you were arguing from a completely premise from the start? Jesus. I clearly can't learn whatever it is you're looking for since I'm not you...In post 447, Robbnva wrote:I think I understand your pov but I don't necessarily agree with it. I think we learn much more from a creature lynch, at least I would. Would help me figure out at least 2 people plus he's scummy
Creature is scummy because what he has done is best explained by defending a scum buddy. If you're town, this assumption is wrong. If you're scum, this assumption is most likely correct. There's no 4 options.In post 448, Eggman wrote:Smithereens: how would you feel about the scumminess of Creature's defense if, hypothetically:
a. we were both town
d. I was town, and it was mafioso
b. we were both mafiosos
c. I was mafioso, and it was town
(I think that we're both town, and the "scummy" part of Creature's defense is just it misremembering stuff (I do that a lot as town, too).)
if you are referring to the creature being scum thing, well it's pretty obvious they look to be connected.In post 454, Dwlee99 wrote:the fact they came in at the same time with a similar message.. uhhh
In post 448, Eggman wrote:Smithereens: how would you feel about the scumminess of Creature's defense if, hypothetically:
a. we were both town
d. I was town, and it was mafioso
b. we were both mafiosos
c. I was mafioso, and it was town
(I think that we're both town, and the "scummy" part of Creature's defense is just it misremembering stuff (I do that a lot as town, too).)
3 minutes apart..In post 449, Creature wrote:How much would your opinion on Eggman change then?
You say you don't have a case for creature yet your iso is full of reasons why you are suspicious of him and not as many reasons for egg so that looks like it could be compiled into a case if you wanted to.In post 456, Smithereens wrote:@Robb, my entire suggestion is that we lynch Eggman -> Creature. My ordering makes more sense because I don't have a case against Creature if it turns out that Eggman is town.
@Dwlee fucking well spotted lol.
Who said they would lynch egg anyway if you flip town? Smitherines nor I said thatIn post 461, Creature wrote:I find it so anti-town saying that if I flip town you're going to lynch Eggman anyway, either your logic is bad or I got a reason to change my view on you.
I must have missed that retractionIn post 462, Smithereens wrote:From what I recall I publically retracted my earlier reasoning vs Creature and replaced with the argument that he's clearly defending a scum buddy in Eggman.
I'm going to sleep, If the Eggman wagon doesn't go ahead, I'm fine for killing Creature.
Or every active player so farIn post 426, Robbnva wrote:I have had quite a few posts. You haven't been able to get a stronger read on me yet?In post 417, atm487 wrote:so far, no, i'm still looking at all the posts, but other than Robb(only slight read) i can't think of anyone
That chart was literally the post before you posted that... The only explanation I have for that is that you were on a different page and didn't even check if I had posted anything....In post 416, Eggman wrote:Crabman:In your 401, you said you'd make a chart later today. Well, it's later - did you chart it out?
WIFOM I believe.In post 436, Robbnva wrote:Also you think me putting somebody to l-1 is hopping the wagon without suspicion? If I'm wrong about egg and he flips town historically people look at the people who joined the wagon late so if anything I've put a bigger spotlight on myself especially when I said earlier that we should take our time and now a day or 2 later I'm putting him back to l-1.
What made you question your decision?
Sometimes more information can be gained by lynching someone who could flp either way, like in my last and first game the tojam lynch would provide valuable information no matter how he flipped, and it led to my investigation of LicketyQuickety, which ultimatly led to scums downfall.In post 445, Robbnva wrote:But if you are more suspicious of creature your vote should be on creature. You even thought he was lying about eggs games and I proved he was and you don't vote him?
That just strikes me as weird. Id like to see creature get a few more votes on him.
Pretty sure all of my reasonings have been posted. Finish catching up and if you still can't tell I'll point them out. I'm heading out to pick up my son.
This looks like an SvS interaction.In post 472, Robbnva wrote:Pretty sure all of my reasonings have been posted. Finish catching up and if you still can't tell I'll point them out. I'm heading out to pick up my son.
If you posted them within the past few pages, I have no idea where they are.In post 472, Robbnva wrote:Pretty sure all of my reasonings have been posted. Finish catching up and if you still can't tell I'll point them out. I'm heading out to pick up my son.
