Open 41-Quicklynch Nightless GAME OVER!, before 492

[DeathSauce]

If nothing else this game has been a great lesson of how NOT to play mafia.

1) Don't vote yourself to prove a point
2) Don't quicklynch someone that is voting themselves to prove a point
3) Don't refuse to explain your playstyle

We are still in good shape, 5 to 2, but we can't make too many more mistakes.
I would like to see some serious analysis from Zodiac, Sir T, and Estes soon.

[Streeflo]

Many people like to think I am scum for reasons I find are very poor. It's uncanny, really.

[Porochaz]

would you expand on that point please?

[Streeflo]

No! METAGAMING IS FOR LOSERS.
Let's get back to the game.

groinhamme might have hammered jdodge because he could get away with it. Maybe.

I need to look at the replacements in this game again...

[ryan]

"Vote Count" for you still alive.

Not Voting: Streeflo, Estes, Sir Tornado, Porochaz, Deathsauce, groinhammer, Zodiac

With 7 alive it's 3 to lynch

[Zodiac]

Well, first one to post after the prod. :/

[Porochaz]

I didnt get a prod... Im still waiting for Streeflo to... do anything really...considering he made a random comment instead of posting something useful

[ryan]

I didnt get a prod... Im still waiting for Streeflo to... do anything really...considering he made a random comment instead of posting something useful

Check your messages, I sent one out to everyone around 1:17pm cst this afternoon including you.

[Porochaz]

K got it now... but just recieved within the last 2 hours

[Porochaz]

No! METAGAMING IS FOR LOSERS.
Let's get back to the game.

groinhamme might have hammered jdodge because he could get away with it. Maybe.

I need to look at the replacements in this game again...

k

vote Streeflo

for not giving me a suitable answer and then trying to pass the suspicion onto someone else. (and for also not making a post abou why he needs to lok at replacements

[Estes]

vote: Deathsauce

He didn't vote for px and somewhat defended him(without making it look like he was doing so) in this post:

When did I say you're not "allowed" to vote px? Obviously I agree that he is giving off scummy vibes, it just seems convenient for the replacements of the player I found to be the scummiest to come in and attack the player that already has the most votes on him.

It's suspicious and I'm pointing it out, that's all.

I just have a strong suspicion.

[ryan]

"Friday actually shows some progress" Vote Count.

Deathsauce (1) Estes
Streeflo (1) Porochaz


Not Voting: Streeflo, Sir Tornado, Deathsauce, groinhammer, Zodiac

With 7 alive it's 3 to lynch

[Porochaz]

very little though... looking mainly for Deathsauce's opinion of Estes last post, but really anyone posting anything will do

[MCHammer]

yeah - can see yr. point. Things have dramatically died down since we lynched Jdodge (still can't believe he didn't have a case - Urrrghhhh).

I think the that the DS quote that estes has used has been taken slightly out of context - what was being referred to was that the 1st thing that poro did after replacing the eminently suspicious IH (you've said so yr.self poro;) was to jump on the biggest bandwagon.

I think that's the only really suspicious thing that porochaz has done so far, but I remember my reasons for being suspicous of IH. The thing that's not making me vote porochaz is his posting since (which has come over as ok).

This game is going to have to take _another_ re-read for me - have coursework to finish for tues, will get on it once that is done (hopefully before tues;).

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I'm not seeing streeflo as suspicious basically b/c he stayed on the same vote (xombie) for such a long time without waivering.

Not really getting anything bad off sir/t either b/c of his early (well, until activity all but ceased) posts.

God knows what's going on with zodiac, bare minimum of content - which kinda puts my list of people to search as DS, Poro & zode.

DS for being so perfectly town in my head - i don't like the fact that I've got _such_ a strong opinion of him so need to doublecheck.

Poro for being IH

Zode for being so postshy

[DeathSauce]

There's nothing to respond to in Estes' post. True, I didn't vote for px, but I fail to see how that makes me scummy. There is no defense of px in that post, I said he was giving off scummy vibes. The rest was about Porochaz.

FoS: Zodiac for posting without content, as he has basically done all game.

[Estes]

There's nothing to respond to in Estes' post. True, I didn't vote for px, but I fail to see how that makes me scummy. There is no defense of px in that post, I said he was giving off scummy vibes. The rest was about Porochaz.

*shrug* I just have a really strong suspicion. And at least I provided some analysis, no matter how small it might have been.

Plus you being suspicious of JDodge. I don't really feel like he did anything to warrant a lynching. You should have just replaced him.

I'd be willing to bet you and groinhammer are the last two mafia. I was right about px afterall.

[MCHammer]

^^^erm...why is this? B/c we have been the two most active players in this game?? (doesn't really say allot, I really only check in once a day).

Was wondering if you wouldn't mind basing that on something...seeing as how easy it is defending against ephemeral evidence.

[Estes]

1st question: No.

2nd: With DS I've already said why. You on the other hand haven't really done anything for me to prove your scumminess; I just have a strong hunch. Ever just have an extremely strong suspicion that someone is scummy?

[Porochaz]

K quick flyby post before I go to sleep, just to show I havent forgotten about my games (better than some people in this one mind you) I think ds is scummy but not groin, Ive found him to be an active protown most of the time, lost my notes... but from what I remember I believe this to be true. Will post explanation on ds if needed but def. not tonight.

Never gonna get a proper answer from Streeflo, am I? Sir Tornado/Zodiac are we going to get anything from them? For 7 people in this game, only 4 are properly playing.

[Streeflo]

Sighh, metagaming is bad. Why must you keep laboring the point

Sometimes people just play scummy, like Oman for example, who apparently loves to bandwagon.

[Porochaz]

I like Oman, Im not really sure why, he made me laugh once... anyway, I mistook what you said, streeflo, however your comments are still slightly random. Besides as long as you dont play with meta as you primary goal for lynching people I think its ok to use to a degree. Having said that Ive only metad JDodge in this game so far.

[ryan]

Zodiac has requested replacement

[ryan]

ChronX replaces Zodiac

[ChronX]

Hi, I have been invited to replace for a long list of people most recently Zodiac. It will probably take me as much as 24 hours to properly read the game, by this time tomorrow I should have done so and you can expect me to post some thoughts.

[MCHammer]

Hey Chronx - no worries, huge long 18page monster.

Ever just have an extremely strong suspicion that someone is scummy?

Absolutely, but after the first few pages I prefer to put a little more reasoning behind them & was hoping you could at least try & do the same.

Coursework almost finished (PDEs - tricky shit, not bright enough) so will have more than a 3 line post to contribute late tommorow .

Incidentally:

I think ds is scummy but not groin, Ive found him to be an active protown most of the time

But you haven't seen DS as protown??? I find that a little strange, but like I said I'm in a desperate need to reassess & make sure I've got people straight in my head.