Mini 1806 : DotA Mafia [Round 1 - SD] (Game Over ?!)

[Frozen Angel]

Vote Count 2.11

Radical Rat (2) : Maqeurade , thenewearth
Ircher (2) : Dunnstral , Shiro
hiplop (2) : Radical Rat , Ircher
Dunnstral (1) : Fire Assassin

Not Voting (1) : hiplop

With 8 players alive it takes 5 votes to lynch.

Day 2 ends in (expired on 2016-07-21 12:00:00)

[Shiro]

This is a shitty wagon

Hiplop will.you assist me from.the after life to win for town?

[hiplop]

im not gonna die dw

vote rat with me?

[hiplop]

VOTE: rat

[Frozen Angel]

Vote Count 2.12

Radical Rat (2) : Maqeurade , thenewearth
Ircher (2) : Dunnstral , Shiro
hiplop (2) : Radical Rat , Ircher
Dunnstral (1) : Fire Assassin

Not Voting (1) : hiplop

With 8 players alive it takes 5 votes to lynch.

Day 2 ends in (expired on 2016-07-21 12:00:00)

[Shiro]

I am far more confident with Ircher though hiplop.

[Ircher]

We're not lynching Radical today because of Hiplop.

I want a Hiplop lynch and I can do a Dunn lynch.

[Masquerade]

VOTE: Ircher

Rat used his power for the day already, he won't be able to perform the kill. Might as well lynch his buddy first.

[hiplop]

VOTE: irchrr

Why not

[Radical Rat]

im literally confirmed town

How, exactly?

[Radical Rat]

VOTE: irchrr

Why not

You still can't vote.

[Ircher]

Considering that Enfeeble was used during the day, and the kill is a night ability, Rat could still perform the nk.

[hiplop]

im literally confirmed town

How, exactly?

my play

[Ircher]

Has been awful.

[Ircher]

Yume did literally nothing and all you have done is claim to be confirmed town, state that you think Dunn is scum too, yet tells me to **** off when I ask for reasons and then hop on to me when you see there is resistance to the Rat wagon.

I'm going to ask you again : Where did your scumread of Dunn go and why did you scumread Dunn in the first place?

[hiplop]

dunnstral is scum. We get him tomorrow.

I'm a bad lynch today. I find scum or bus them. Either way I'll give you dead mafiosos

[Ircher]

Outline your case; you've quoted only 1 post that you said was a scumclaim.

[hiplop]

it was pretty self evident

[Frozen Angel]

Vote Count 2.13

Ircher (3) : Dunnstral , Shiro , Maqeurade
hiplop (2) : Radical Rat , Ircher
Radical Rat (1) : thenewearth
Dunnstral (1) : Fire Assassin

Not Voting (1) : hiplop

With 8 players alive it takes 5 votes to lynch.

Day 2 ends in (expired on 2016-07-21 12:00:00)

[Fire Assassin]

I am unsure of a ircher lynch right now to be honest.
I would prefer ircher to radical, but this one just getting way more traction...I guess that shouldn't make me nervous, but Ircher reaction to hiplop of frustration of his reads and attitude kind of feel "scummy" in the sense he feels he is pushing against a brick wall and feels like he has superior reasoning for pushing his "reads" but is getting nowhere and can't understand why its not working.

I have felt this attitude before when I tried to push Titus for a mislynch once when my arguments were I felt more solid, and RC just had a gut townread on her that was stronger than my "reasoning"

[Dunnstral]

VOTE: hiplop

He's either trying to bus Ircher or Ircher is townand hiplop is trying to vote whoever isn't him basically (to L-1)

[hiplop]

^ scumclaim

[Ircher]

I'm here

Waiting for people to do things

I've given my stance

hiplop is probably scum for coasting

scumclaim

This is your case, Hiplop.

Ok, not the towniest post in the world, but how is this post scum-motivated rather than apathy motivated? The game reached a standstill with very split opinions as can be seen by the vcs, and while simply saying "I'm here" isn't necessarily town-motivated, given the game state, I wouldn't call it scum-motivated.

The only other thing you could have that is an issue with this post is Dunn's scumread on you. If that's the case, why are you omgusing Dunn? Your slot truly has done nothing so far and its obvious that you dont intend to change that. Yume did jack squat. All you've done so far is 1) Make friendly banter with Shiro (null) 2) Stall and complain about the game state while doing nothing to change it (Scum) 3) Claim you are confirmed town based on play (Scum) and 4) Attack anyone who isn't you, especially if they cast suspicion on you/vote you/etc. (Scum) -- You OMGUS'd Dunn and whenever he calls you scum, you state thats a scum claim. When I asked for your Dunn case, you simply tell me to **** off which is in itself an omgus attack. You are happy to hop to whatever wagon seems viable, yet when someone asks for your reasoning, you simply omgus / ignore them in return.

Explain to me how the above is town-motivated, much less confirms you as town.

[Ircher]

For those who would like to see the full iso of Yume/Hiplop:

Spoiler: Hiplop ISO

Hi. I am sorry, but I felt ill yesterday. Will talk more later.

Stalling and pretty much null.

I am here.

More stalling. Again, pretty much null.

Will catch scum after my nap

Useless post that is null.

Welcome, New Yume!

This is pretty rude. Hiplop is no yume.

I have awoken.

did we claim discards or

Weird question to ask; what made you think about discards at that moment? That said, benefit of the doubt that you haven't looked at the thread much yet so nullish.

im literally the worst dota hero wtf yume

Soft-claim perhaps; again, null.

Hi hiplop, that's quite the nap you are taking! I'm looking forward to reading your thoughts.

dude I can sleep for days.

Sorry, little bit of a delay. Probably tonight I'll catch the scum

Stalling. I guess null....

Hiiiii

shiro is conftown from this

Friendly banter/joking/playing, so pretty null.

has the survivor claimed?

Now asking about the survivor whos dead.... Posts are starting to become borderline fluff at this point (which is scum motivated)

guys can we kick some activity into this game or?

Says the one who is just stalling, asking stupid Qs, not reading the thread, and otherwise doing nothing useful. Scum trying to look townish by seeming to care about the game state, yet doing nothing to improve it.

guys can we kick some activity into this game or?

Your slot has posted the least.

Instead of attacking me:

Someone give me a catchup. i'm going to read back but help a guy build some momentum

More stalling, and having been called out for hypocrisy, attempts to cover it up and blame it on everyone else. It's a team effort, yes, but EVERYONE must play their parts. Your catchup for such a small thread should not require the support of others.

VOTE: dunnstral

OMGUS vote? (See below)

I'm here

Waiting for people to do things

I've given my stance

hiplop is probably scum for coasting

scumclaim

Flimsy case thats either an OMGUS or an attempt to use the game state to paint someone as scum. Null motivation for this particular post.

Ill give yoi rat today, you give me dunn tomorrow?

Leads one to believe it's Hiplop/Dunn with Hiplop trying to bus Dunn. Still, the post is kinda nullish.

VOTE: rat

Unexplained vote, but I imagine another OMGUS attack. The OMGUS doesnt feel like paranoia, but more like deliberate and desperate.

enfeeble?

Null.

also trust if i was scum you wouldnt catch me

AtE and meta usage. Not buying it.

fuck off ircher

Another OMGUS attack -- It is in response to when I said I want to hear the Dunn case. Ok, maybe I should've dbl-checked before asking, but still, you could at least just quote the case rather than resort to flaming and trying to avoid the subject completely. Very anti-town response, and I really don't see town playing this way at all; aka, this is scum trying to avoid being caught. Again, suggests Dunn/Hiplop team.

im literally confirmed town

Cannot prove the claim; I guess null tho?

im not gonna die dw

vote rat with me?

Why wont you die today? The wording strikes me as scum rather than town-motivated.

VOTE: rat

Trying to ressurect the wagon.

VOTE: irchrr

Why not

Compromise vote? Meh.

im literally confirmed town

How, exactly?

my play

Absolutely not. Nullish I guess.

dunnstral is scum. We get him tomorrow.

I'm a bad lynch today. I find scum or bus them. Either way I'll give you dead mafiosos

Good to know that if you flip scum (which you probably will), Dunn is likely your partner.

it was pretty self evident

Not really, and it's very weak too (for one to suggest a lynch there)

^ scumclaim

Another OMGUS attack.

[Dunnstral]

Why are you trying to paint me as his partner...?

Because he's pushing on me? Your case is flimsy too and I want you dead after hiplop