The Resistance (O3P1 - Replacement Needed)

[Ircher]

I know you are but please don't pick people, or there will likely be at least a mafia in the team.

Please clarify this as this makes no sense...

@Myko --> I'm always that way.

[Faalcon]

@Ircher : I was answering to a bad joke of elekitu's, which randomidgrt kept on. My point was that picking now is pointless as it'll be done randomly. And chances are not in our favour.

[Something_Smart]

People I feel good about: Something_Smart, Radja, Ircher, randomidget

People I feel not so good about: mykonian, Elekitu, N

People I'm not sure about: Faalcon, Killthestory, Klick

[Killthestory]

learn to be sure about me

[Something_Smart]

Patience, young Padawan.

Do you have thoughts on who you would/wouldn't want on a mission?

[Killthestory]

SCUM OR TOWN

which one

[N]

Why would you want Radja to pick so early ? For now it's a random pick, and random is not nice to us.

this is a bad post, right after Radja said the same thing

[N]

What's the rush? I have almost 4 days left to decide?

There's no rush, but on the one hand you want people to post, on the other hand you find people quick to accuse another. You don't want it either way!

So you're saying the only way to post is to accuse others immediately?

Okay.

Welcome to my scumpool.

are you new

[N]

Why would you want Radja to pick so early ? For now it's a random pick, and random is not nice to us.

Why do you think random is spy?

So far, from what I read, Ircher seems to be the most scummy. Then again, I've never played this game or mafia before so...

Reasons?

It's mostly based on this post :

I hope our first operation doesn't end in fai

l

u

r

e! An early win is crucial for us as the game gets harder as we go on.

I just don't feel like a resistant would state that kind of obvious fact. Then again, it's just a first round hunch and is likely to change as the game goes on, if you're town oc

^ goodposting

I'd support a team with Ircher and/or mykonian on it, though I wouldn't expect Radja to pick mykonian at this rate.

Edit: I was talking about mykonian's post. Sorry. But your post is good too!

how can you say elekitu's post is good when it has comes to a completely different conclusion than yours about Ircher?

[Klick]

I meant the "your post is good too" part as more of a polite gesture than anything, to show that I didn't think Elekitu's post was necessarily

bad

even though I wasn't talking about his post. Plus, I had just woken up. Although looking at it now, I don't disagree with what I said. Although I disagree with Elekitu's conclusion, I think his post is good because of the thought process behind it. I can see the thought process behind Resistance!Elekitu having a sort of gut Spy feeling about Ircher's post #41.

[mykonian]

Why would you want Radja to pick so early ? For now it's a random pick, and random is not nice to us.

this is a bad post, right after Radja said the same thing

goodposting. Faalcon for scumpool.

[Radja]

SEND: Radja, Something_Smart, Killthestory

Townpool: Something Smart, KilltheStory, Elekitu, N
Scumpool: mykonian, Faalcon, Ircher

Rando, Klick, one on each side. Can't decide.

[Klick]

Rejecting that.

Why the quick send? Weren't you wondering why people wanted to rush earlier?

[JDGA]

(expired on 2016-08-16 21:06:04) to accept or reject. Unlike in Clash of the Mash, I don't lock the thread during this time.

[Elekitu]

Wait, we can't debate during the voting phase?

[Killthestory]

ah thanks dude, really appreciate the trust.

mmhph

[N]

i dont like it

[N]

What's the rush? I have almost 4 days left to decide?

one day later

SEND: Radja, Something_Smart, Killthestory

Townpool: Something Smart, KilltheStory, Elekitu, N
Scumpool: mykonian, Faalcon, Ircher

Rando, Klick, one on each side. Can't decide.

[N]

Why would you want Radja to pick so early ? For now it's a random pick, and random is not nice to us.

this is a bad post, right after Radja said the same thing

goodposting. Faalcon for scumpool.

Oh, I see why you're being nice now. Carry on.

[JDGA]

Wait, we can't debate during the voting phase?

To clarify, yes you can.

[Killthestory]

i dont like it

2bad

[Klick]

Townpool: Something Smart, KilltheStory, Elekitu, N
Scumpool: mykonian, Faalcon, Ircher

Can you do me a favor and explain your reasoning behind these reads? Specifically the ones on Elekitu and Faalcon?

[mykonian]

Wait, we can't debate during the voting phase?

To clarify, yes you can.

oooh, in that case.

I don't get how Radja picks Something Smart here. Even if you disagree with the reasons why he looks scummy, posts like Post 33 have to have your head scratching. The game was barely started, it's too early to go with factions. I get Radja thinks I'm scum, and fair enough, I know I trip people's gut playing like this (but it's so fun!), but picking S_S just because your scumread thinks he's scum, is not smart at this point. With 4 pages in, there were a couple of players who were totally clean. Why not take a risk there in stead?

I think Radja still plays mafia, so it's not his mishmash thinking either that sets up that alliance there. Wouldn't want to lock into a theory how this makes Radja scum, but it reeks.

[Something_Smart]

How do you know why Radja picked me?

[Randomnamechange]

I almot pulled a reverse ambidex and started writing my choice in a PM to Elekitu before I realized