The Resistance (O3P1 - Replacement Needed)

[Something_Smart]

I believe Radja is town. Not as sure on KTS, but I think I'll accept it anyway. (Not positive yet, though.)

[mykonian]

How do you know why Radja picked me?

I have no clue, he's around to argue my way of seeing it obviously. But surely midget, kitu (I don't think you came through on your promise!), N, klick were all better choices than you, with ease.

[Something_Smart]

Why?

[mykonian]

Wait, we can't debate during the voting phase?

To clarify, yes you can.

oooh, in that case.

I don't get how Radja picks Something Smart here. Even if you disagree with the reasons why he looks scummy, posts like Post 33 have to have your head scratching. The game was barely started, it's too early to go with factions. I get Radja thinks I'm scum, and fair enough, I know I trip people's gut playing like this (but it's so fun!), but picking S_S just because your scumread thinks he's scum, is not smart at this point. With 4 pages in, there were a couple of players who were totally clean. Why not take a risk there in stead?

I think Radja still plays mafia, so it's not his mishmash thinking either that sets up that alliance there. Wouldn't want to lock into a theory how this makes Radja scum, but it reeks.

[Something_Smart]

So... he should pick the "totally clean" (i.e. null or close to null) players rather than the ones he townreads?

*scratches head*

[mykonian]

do you have a particular complaint about click, midget, kitu or N? I don't have seen too many voiced either. You otoh, make posts like #33. Even if he townreads you, that should add some reservation.

So yeah, I'd have picked any of those 4, whichever he likes best, over you. Seems logical to me.

otoh, you are probably pleased at least someone picks you.

[mykonian]

then again, that's for Radja. Faalcon could pick N and me and I don't know if I want it :/ I guess at that point I don't know the game well enough, but I don't really want a team with faalcon to pass anymore than one with S_S.

[Faalcon]

Dob't worry about that, I would not pick you or N right now.

[Elekitu]

S_S is in my scumpool, he already has a strong opinion about almost everyone and seems way too sure about them, which is weird when we just started the game. That's why I'm voting to reject the team

[Klick]

It feels like there is a lot of distancing going on here.

What makes you think this?

At the moment the team I most support is Radja/Killthestory/Something_Smart.

I'd like an answer to this question. Radja seems to have read this post and based his pick on it, but he never answered the question (unless I missed it somewhere).

[Radja]

I think talking publically about accepting/rejecting works in scum's favor, so I suggest we don't do this.

About the question: It is a gut feeling. People were scumreading others really hard based on single posts, which seems to be very forced.

The reason I sent this team is I want to see how the votes land. This is an all-town team for me.

[Klick]

Can I assume your reads list you posted with your team submission is also largely gut-based?

I'm not saying that's a bad thing, my reads are gut most of the time is well, but I'm trying to understand your thought process.

[Something_Smart]

Rejecting that.

Why

the quick send

didn't you put any spies on it? Weren't you wondering why people wanted to rush earlier?

FTFY

Elekitu, how do you know how strong my opinions are?

[Killthestory]

I believe Radja is town. Not as sure on KTS, but I think I'll accept it anyway. (Not positive yet, though.)

if youre not sure on me I'M GOING TO DENY THIS.

PICK A READ SS

PICK ONE

[Something_Smart]

I picked one, but I agree with what Radja said about not discussing our votes. You should vote independently of how you think I will vote.

[Killthestory]

i'm gonna sheep because you told me to think independently

[Klick]

I think talking publically about accepting/rejecting works in scum's favor, so I suggest we don't do this.

I picked one, but I agree with what Radja said about not discussing our votes. You should vote independently of how you think I will vote.

100% disagree. If I think a team should be rejected and would like to express this, I should be able to say, "Hey, I think this team should be rejected."

[Killthestory]

I REFUSE TO BE ON A TEAM WITH SCUM

[Ircher]

I think we should reject this team.

[N]

I think talking publically about accepting/rejecting works in scum's favor, so I suggest we don't do this.

aka "I don't have answers to your questions"

[Ircher]

Seriously, why isn't this phase over yet?

Who hasn't submitted their vote yet and why?

[Something_Smart]

I think we should reject this team.

Why?

[Ircher]

~Reasons.

[JDGA]

The votes are in, and the result is...

Spoiler: Non-Image Version

Yes:

Radja
Something_Smart

No:

Faalcon
Killthestory
Ircher
randomidget
mykonian
Elekitu
Klick
N

By a vote of 2-8, the proposed team is rejected.

[JDGA]

The second attempt at selecting a team is given to Faalcon. Three people are needed for the operation, all of whom must pass it for the operation to succeed.
The deadline is (expired on 2016-08-21 00:00:00).