Mini 1815: Game of Thrones S1E1 GAME OVER

[Dwlee99]

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=23&t=65594

[mhsmith0]

As a side note that n1 kill is ALSO outside my wolf range. Especially with a janitor on hand the odds of me signing off on a kill of the declared ic are approximately zero. Feel free to meta me on this. I don't think I've ever taken a shot as bad as that one as a wolf (Though in fairness I don't have many shots to my name). Heartless talked about ic+watcher being town-sided, but the janitor power makes it really obvious that someone other than the ic should have been shot. For instance Beeboy claiming a confirmable role would have been a good shot.

[mhsmith0]

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=23&t=65594

Was link a town role? If so that still follows the idea of Zelda as a good safe claim but not a crazy good safe claim.

[Dwlee99]

Yes Link was town.

[Dwlee99]

Zelda was the scum's actual flavor though not a fake claim.

[KuroiXHF]

I'm Jon Snow. For those unfamiliar w the series, he's the bastard child of house stark (sort of)

Well yeah. For the purposes of flavor, he's absolutely Stark-aligned and if Stark are the good guys (which is pretty much confirmed), he's a good guy.

Any flavor could be a fakeclaim lol

Yep.

Catelyn is actually a mean safe claim to give since she (like the tracker guy) dies and comes back kinda evil (though catelyn less than the tracker).

Not in the TV-series, which this game seems to be based off. Also, I understand that you're trying to scum hunt, but could you possibly do it in a spoiler-free way?

anyhow, as much as an inner voice is telling me to vote smith, i'll be staying on kuroi

If you have to, can you at least promise me you'll kill Dwlee tomorrow? I'm really trying to be calm here, but with all the work I have drawing out the fucking picture and the fact that I'm trying to curb my edginess because of my work load, promise me you'll kill Dwlee. I guarantee you, he'll be alive tomorrow. Gorkington and Smith, listen too. One of you will die and Dwlee will be alive tomorrow.

[Wisdom]

i dont think random harddefended his buddy

[KuroiXHF]

Gork, Smith, please don't hammer quite yet. I think we have some talking to do first.

[Wisdom]

What talking?

[KuroiXHF]

What talking?

I posted a wall of points. I think people have some responding to do. Plus, you didn't answer my last post about promising to vote Dwlee when I'm dead.

[Wisdom]

I did

[Wisdom]

i dont think random harddefended his buddy

aka I wont be voting dwlee

if its not you, its smith

[mhsmith0]

I'd lynch dwlee over wisdom about 10 times out of 10. If it's gork vs dwlee I'm less sure. Probably I'd see who can demonstrate a track record of quality kills as scum and/or evaluate potential claims. Then again given stated suspicion on me it might not be my decision to make *shrugs*.

[KuroiXHF]

If you want my order of scum to not scum, here it is:

Dwlee >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Wisdom>Gork>>Smith.

It's not Smith. Wisdom, did you need me to go through today? Is today where you think Smith is more likely to be scum than not?

[Wisdom]

no, it's poe because its not dwlee and i dont think its gork

[KuroiXHF]

no, it's poe because its not dwlee and i dont think its gork

Dwlee isn't fucking clear.

Scum, please do us all a favor and kill Wisdom tonight so he can't screw it up for us tomorrow.

[KuroiXHF]

no, it's poe because its not dwlee and i dont think its gork

Dwlee isn't fucking clear.

Scum, please do us all a favor and kill Wisdom tonight so he can't screw it up for us tomorrow.

Unless it's Wisdom in which case, we're possibly fucked anyway.

[mhsmith0]

If you want my order of scum to not scum, here it is:

Dwlee >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Wisdom>Gork>>Smith.

It's not Smith. Wisdom, did you need me to go through today? Is today where you think Smith is more likely to be scum than not?

Bottom line for us the clear case on me gork and wisdom as you understand it

[KuroiXHF]

Can you rephrase that please?

[mhsmith0]

Quick summary of why each of me gork and wisdom are clear

[Dwlee99]

I'm p obvi not scum tbh

[KuroiXHF]

Quick summary of why each of me gork and wisdom are clear

Woah - please do NOT use that word. I never said you're clear. I just said I suspect you both least.

But to put it in about a line or two each...

Gork - Gork has been wrong so often. My biggest complaints about him are less about his scumminess and more about the accuracy of his reads. The one line I really didn't like and I think was glossed over a bit easily was 591.

You - You are without a doubt the towniest player here, and that's an issue. I agree with Wisdom that there is such a thing as

too townie

. Another issue which perhaps ties in with the too townie issue is that you don't seem to make assertions as much as you should. You aren't aggressive and you're inquisitive. You ask a lot of questions and they're good questions, which is why it's easy to townread you, but you don't seem to do all so much with all this info.

But to repeat myself, and this better not be skimmed over or taken light,

neither

of you are clear. I just don't think it's Gork and I definitely don't think it's you.

[Wisdom]

I definitely don't think it's you.

your paragraph about him seems to suggest you do think it could be him

[mhsmith0]

Sorry. If you were asking us to promise a dwlee lynch I figured you had the rest of us as clear.

[KuroiXHF]

I definitely don't think it's you.

your paragraph about him seems to suggest you do think it could be him

You're voting, which means you think it's me. Which means that if you're right, the game is over after I'm lynched. You needn't worry.