Hi all. Sorry about my horrendous participation so far. I've just not been able to get into the game yet—I'll get better as it progresses, I promise. For now I feel like I have very little information, so I'll do what I usually when I feel like that, and that is to go player by player. So, in no particular but a very particular order, here we go:
BNLP: The townread of Davsto in
76 and
77 is town play. I especially like the "townslip" read—while I'm not sure about the slip itself, I give BNLP towncreds for pointing it out. In 77 I like that he townreads Davsto for the scumhunting while questioning the content. This indicates that he's legitimately interested in finding town. The rest of the content is also good. Overall: Town
Charloux: Ugh. There's a lot of scumminess going on here. He's spent most of the game going on about how he's lynchbait, and retracting what he's already said: "Ouch i made a mistake with posting." Seems to react intensely to even light pressure, but I'm guessing may be part of the whole lynchbait thing.
86 and
87 are bad. He's linking to games where he's been town and using them to justify that he's being lynchbait this time. The problem is that in many of those games he wasn't actually lynchbait as he himself describes. What bugs me more is that, given this loose description, why is he only bringing up town games? In Newbie 1713 he was "lynchbait" as scum day 1 to the point of self-hammering. Why is this not worthy of mention? It's like he's trying to appear town by hiding the possibility of him being scum, and that feels really really scummy. Overall: Scum
Davsto: I don't like how he's decided that I'm scum based on one post of mine and is basing his other posts on it: "even with my logic that DarkLight is scum" (82). There's both elements that I like and don't like in the posts. A coin could do as good a job as myself. Null.
farside22: Lots of content, but I'm having a hard time picking out too much information. Regardless, weak town.
I'd just like a bit of clarification:
In post 149, farside22 wrote:I liked Dav points about dark.
I don't see map/dark scum together.
I was thinking map/mohis but Vedith just confused me.
Thinking......
Vote: darklight
@farside
when you say the "Dav points about dark" do you mean the post with the two points about me that he posted along with his vote? or is it just in general?
Lane: Starts off suggesting a strategy he made in an earlier game, and drops it just as quickly. Apparently ninja'd me with my comments about Charloux. He's a weak townlean.
Lucky: Contentless posts and seems happy to get away with it. Weak scumlean.
Map Wolf: Contrary to what it seems everyone thinks, I'm not putting too much in the RVS vote. It was just the best place to place my vote at that moment. What I hate though, is this post:
In post 139, Map Wolf wrote:So yeah this game has stalled too much. This game really needs more activity. If anyone has got questions i will be willing to answer them.
And I hate that so so so so so so much. After 90 posts of inactivity that's all he has to comment on? That's really really bad and it seems like he's trying to skate along. I'd see a town player either (a) doing something productive or (b) apologizing for inactivity and promising to deliver. Not blaming it on everyone else and brushing it off. I also don't like that Charloux didn't comment on this and rather actually asked him a question—I feel like this also shows Charloux trying too hard to fit in. Scum.
McMenno: Nothing either way. Null.
Mohis: I actually quite like Fire's play. The push on farside and mcmenno, while I may not entirely agree, I think seems genuine. Weak town.
So Charloux and Map Wolf are scum. /solved
My vote is already parked.
