Okay I finished reading the links and all I saw was the one for lane and all I got was he'said scummy for defending your slot.In post 521, Not Chara wrote:nevermind that for now.In post 520, Charloux wrote:Hello! Don't worry about getting hammered, the only guy who does that was recently replaced!
Btw what's there to claim again?
do you have any thoughts on my reads?
I am having a hard time reading mcmenno, what did you see in his posts that made you think he is town?In post 521, Not Chara wrote: do you have any thoughts on my reads?
Need a bit more time since i had Dark as scum... I'm getting town-vibes from Chara so far. The thing that's conflicting me the most is that i don't really think scum would pretend to have a scumread on the only person who is townreading them(Lane).In post 531, BNL wrote:Charloux, still scumreading Chara?
it's difficult to explain, being more of a tonal/feel read than a logical one. 220 looks like town due to the matter-of-factness of it. scum might (not saying they would always, but) feel the need to explain more about the read. or even, do more than simply say what i feel is exactly what happened. Mcmenno saw some towny posts, some scummy posts, etc. so didn't come out with an exceptionally strong read either way. but, didn't go out of his way to point out these facts as though he is trying to fling suspicion on Charloux without giving a stance. just giving honest thoughts. i don't know how else to explain it, if i'm still not making sense to you.In post 529, BNL wrote:My instinct to Chara's first posts is that I feel they're genuine (town).
Some questions:
I have a hard time reading McMenno, and after you explained to Charloux I still don't understand. What is town about #220?
i didn't have a problem with that post in particular. Mohis has other bad posts, such as the ones before and directly after the Map Wolf lynch. what did you think of those? i remember there being others, i would have to go looking.
why are you getting townvibes? is it only because i'm scumreading lane, or is it something else?In post 532, Charloux wrote:Need a bit more time since i had Dark as scum... I'm getting town-vibes from Chara so far. The thing that's conflicting me the most is that i don't really think scum would pretend to have a scumread on the only person who is townreading them(Lane).In post 531, BNL wrote:Charloux, still scumreading Chara?
to expand: iIn post 534, Not Chara wrote:why are you getting townvibes? is it only because i'm scumreading lane, or is it something else?In post 532, Charloux wrote:Need a bit more time since i had Dark as scum... I'm getting town-vibes from Chara so far. The thing that's conflicting me the most is that i don't really think scum would pretend to have a scumread on the only person who is townreading them(Lane).In post 531, BNL wrote:Charloux, still scumreading Chara?
on lane:appearsto be on my slot's side. but still making sure to underline that the kill could have been done only by our slot or to incriminate us. his posts seem designed to make him be seen as the one who was townreading us. why couldn't Davsto have been killed just for being obvious town? only darklight was scumreading him, true, but that doesn't mean the kill could only have been made entirely with darklight in mind. (or by darklight)
Scumreading Not Chara just more on BNL bad instincts.In post 529, BNL wrote:My instinct to Chara's first posts is that I feel they're genuine (town).
Some questions:
I have a hard time reading McMenno, and after you explained to Charloux I still don't understand. What is town about #220?
In post 536, My Other Head Is Scum wrote:Scumreading Not Chara just more on BNL bad instincts.In post 529, BNL wrote:My instinct to Chara's first posts is that I feel they're genuine (town).
Some questions:
I have a hard time reading McMenno, and after you explained to Charloux I still don't understand. What is town about #220?
~Fire
Of course I thought about it. But I find it hard to believe conversation went like thisIn post 535, Not Chara wrote:to expand: iIn post 534, Not Chara wrote:why are you getting townvibes? is it only because i'm scumreading lane, or is it something else?In post 532, Charloux wrote:Need a bit more time since i had Dark as scum... I'm getting town-vibes from Chara so far. The thing that's conflicting me the most is that i don't really think scum would pretend to have a scumread on the only person who is townreading them(Lane).In post 531, BNL wrote:Charloux, still scumreading Chara?
on lane:appearsto be on my slot's side. but still making sure to underline that the kill could have been done only by our slot or to incriminate us. his posts seem designed to make him be seen as the one who was townreading us. why couldn't Davsto have been killed just for being obvious town? only darklight was scumreading him, true, but that doesn't mean the kill could only have been made entirely with darklight in mind. (or by darklight)dobelieve it's likely that Davsto was killed exactly for that reason. but would someone who doesn't know darklight's alignment not consider the third option too? that Davsto was killed for being highly townread.
lane: if you did think about that option and i missed it. feel free to speak up.
You say that your read on McMenno isn't very strong, but "McMenno is town. or i'm reading him very badly." seems to suggest otherwise. Explain?In post 533, Not Chara wrote:it's difficult to explain, being more of a tonal/feel read than a logical one. 220 looks like town due to the matter-of-factness of it. scum might (not saying they would always, but) feel the need to explain more about the read. or even, do more than simply say what i feel is exactly what happened. Mcmenno saw some towny posts, some scummy posts, etc. so didn't come out with an exceptionally strong read either way. but, didn't go out of his way to point out these facts as though he is trying to fling suspicion on Charloux without giving a stance. just giving honest thoughts. i don't know how else to explain it, if i'm still not making sense to you.In post 529, BNL wrote:My instinct to Chara's first posts is that I feel they're genuine (town).
Some questions:
I have a hard time reading McMenno, and after you explained to Charloux I still don't understand. What is town about #220?
again, not a very strong read.
how do you feel about McMenno's comment towards me when i replaced in, and his comment toward Charloux? he told both of us 'i don't want to lynch you today'.i didn't have a problem with that post in particular. Mohis has other bad posts, such as the ones before and directly after the Map Wolf lynch. what did you think of those? i remember there being others, i would have to go looking.
In post 273, lane0168 wrote:@davsto, I think they were pretty biased. I actually liked his reads with reasons. There were parts I agreed with, and parts that I didn't really care about, but nothing that looked scummy to me. I'll tell you what I think about your reads. I'm never on computer but I'll try my best to make it coherent
This maybe out of order.In post 539, lane0168 wrote:Farside, I'm probably not going to do this with you again. Davsto made a bunch of crap arguments, and I refuted them because davsto asked. And I didn't agree with them.
I'm not going down this road again. Not with you
it's particularly the way you presented it, actually. i confess i didn't record my thoughts here properly.In post 538, lane0168 wrote:Of course I thought about it. But I find it hard to believe conversation went like thisIn post 535, Not Chara wrote:to expand: iIn post 534, Not Chara wrote:why are you getting townvibes? is it only because i'm scumreading lane, or is it something else?In post 532, Charloux wrote:Need a bit more time since i had Dark as scum... I'm getting town-vibes from Chara so far. The thing that's conflicting me the most is that i don't really think scum would pretend to have a scumread on the only person who is townreading them(Lane).In post 531, BNL wrote:Charloux, still scumreading Chara?
on lane:appearsto be on my slot's side. but still making sure to underline that the kill could have been done only by our slot or to incriminate us. his posts seem designed to make him be seen as the one who was townreading us. why couldn't Davsto have been killed just for being obvious town? only darklight was scumreading him, true, but that doesn't mean the kill could only have been made entirely with darklight in mind. (or by darklight)dobelieve it's likely that Davsto was killed exactly for that reason. but would someone who doesn't know darklight's alignment not consider the third option too? that Davsto was killed for being highly townread.
lane: if you did think about that option and i missed it. feel free to speak up.
Scum 1: we should kill davsto cause he's Towniest
Scum 2: good idea,kill davsto
There was more than that. Scum discuss who is best kill and why. It's not as simple as that. At least that's what I imagine. I've never been team scum that participated in a night kill I don't think.
Why aren't you questioning everyone that doesn't consider davsto was killed for more than being just scum? I wasnt convinced. Not with the way he thought Darklight was scum. I even rolecopped him
the read isn't very strong because i'm aware i could be reading him very badly. does that help? none of the thoughts i've put down for McMenno town would convinceIn post 541, BNL wrote:You say that your read on McMenno isn't very strong, but "McMenno is town. or i'm reading him very badly." seems to suggest otherwise. Explain?In post 533, Not Chara wrote:it's difficult to explain, being more of a tonal/feel read than a logical one. 220 looks like town due to the matter-of-factness of it. scum might (not saying they would always, but) feel the need to explain more about the read. or even, do more than simply say what i feel is exactly what happened. Mcmenno saw some towny posts, some scummy posts, etc. so didn't come out with an exceptionally strong read either way. but, didn't go out of his way to point out these facts as though he is trying to fling suspicion on Charloux without giving a stance. just giving honest thoughts. i don't know how else to explain it, if i'm still not making sense to you.In post 529, BNL wrote:My instinct to Chara's first posts is that I feel they're genuine (town).
Some questions:
I have a hard time reading McMenno, and after you explained to Charloux I still don't understand. What is town about #220?
again, not a very strong read.
how do you feel about McMenno's comment towards me when i replaced in, and his comment toward Charloux? he told both of us 'i don't want to lynch you today'.i didn't have a problem with that post in particular. Mohis has other bad posts, such as the ones before and directly after the Map Wolf lynch. what did you think of those? i remember there being others, i would have to go looking.
I find McMenno's comments null, they just don't strike me either way.
513 is one of the posts that is Fire's nonsense posting which I associate with his scum posting (though I'm not sure of the truth about this), which is why it pinged me. I do agree though that some of his other posts were worse though, like the L-1 vote on Map Wolf (his townread).
why? that's a very simplistic view. surely it could have also been a combination? you're the one who told me there was an entire conversation about it.In post 545, lane0168 wrote: Pedit, because I don't think your third option is an option. I think he was killed for a reason other than just being town. The two options I presented are the only options I believe possible
what does this mean?In post 546, McMenno wrote:I haven't really been feeling bnl's presence in this game even though he has 60 posts
that's a bad sign