Death Note Mafia (Game Over!)

[Nero Cain]

Ettiquette

this is shit btw. Just look at it Maria, its CR all over again.

[Harkonnen97]

wagoning creature created discussion. i dont understand why people insist it was a bad thing

[Nero Cain]

b/c they are scum defending him and/or scum pocketing him.

[Not_Mafia]

What is pocketing?

[Gamma Emerald]

I'm actually pretty much over it. I think Nero is probably town, and have null-town on Synik.

[Nero Cain]

back in my day we just called it buddying but its the same thing I think. Scum defending town for towncred or scum defending town to get on their good side.

[Harkonnen97]

b/c they are scum defending him and/or scum pocketing him.

if you think the people defending creatureslot are scum regardless of the slot's alignment, why is your vote still parked on creature?

[Harkonnen97]

wouldnt they be bigger scumreads to you from your pov?

[Nero Cain]

I've thought about trying to derail the creatureslot wagon but is it really the best idea right now? Who would even vote Basic with me? I only have 1 vote and am ok with lynching any scum.

[kraska77]

Synik's posting has been robotic and awkward
He's barely interacting with the people pushing for his lynch
Barely even acknowledged his wagon at all
Every bit of this looks like cornered scum and yet gamma and basic still call this a mislynch

[Harkonnen97]

b/c they are scum defending him and/or scum pocketing him.

but this implies that you arent that sure on creature's flip, and your scumread on his defenders is bigger

i understand that initially your vote on creature was pure pressure

i dont understand why are you still pressure voting instead of pushing your top scumread. isnt that the idea itself behind pressuring - creating scumreads?

"my scumreads are generally townread, i cant lynch them waah waah qq" is lazy at best, posturing at worst

[Gamma Emerald]

Synik's posting has been robotic and awkward
He's barely interacting with the people pushing for his lynch
Barely even acknowledged his wagon at all
Every bit of this looks like cornered scum and yet gamma and basic still call this a mislynch

Not so much that, as I don't like YOUR method of trying to get Synik lynched.

[Nero Cain]

I have a scumread on Synik's. I don't see the point in derailing a wagon on scum.

[Basic]

I was never town reading Creature.
But i still dont understand why the slot is todays lynch of the day.
You have your opinion. And i have mine.

Then i asked your opinion on Spynik.
Who has actually posted.

I expect you to marginally suspect me. Talk to me about Ank and the wagon.
I mean i get, THE WAGON, but what and who on it?
But for the time being and since we actually appear to have had some sort of actual converstaion instead of quote wars

UNVOTE: Nero

If you were scum i dont think you'd be as..... loud and given me as much ammo as you did.
Im not liking your posts but they dont make sense as scum for me. Also, the lack of a push from the Ooba stand point.
Which i actually do feel you should have gotten, subsequent frustration and eager to lynch attitude im thinking your probstown.
Maybe wrongtown but definitely probstown.
And i feel slightly better for it.

This fits for now.
VOTE: IAI

Ninja'd.
@Hark. Its not necessarily a bad thing. Out from the fact he's L-2 iirc.
Itll create even more discussion if he's lynched.

Ninja'd x2. Buddying is superior to pocketing.

Ninja'd x3. I dont like how it happened sure.
But essentially i find its a wagon on a coin toss.

[Nero Cain]

your votes are trash Basic. Still waiting on you to show me an example of you throwing hate on players that were voting a replaced slot.

[Almost Chara]

SirCakez is could be town.

and 128 is strange. especially at the point of the game it came in, when the number of alignment indicative posts can be counted on one hand. it just looks like searching for things that aren't there.

Harkonnen's paranoia in 142 is town, i think. edit: possibly not, in hindsight it's an easy reaction.

not a fan of ooba.

153: have you... never been in a private topic before?

iraonavp is town.

168: yes. i love it.

175: i wouldn't have noticed this if it hadn't been pointed out. but i still don't think it was a slip.

i don't understand the bad feelings about I am Innocent. i can't read them either way right now, but both Wisdom and Vecna pointed out a really innocuous statement that seems more style-based than anything else.

dislike Gamma Emerald. but on second thought, that might just be how he is.

327:do players misread iraon a lot?

Creature is town.

361: the reasoning for Cakez here doesn't make sense to me. it's just following a bad case by Sondam.

this will get too long if i keep doing it like this. enjoy a fresh new compact look, that is probably more difficult to read. Narna is probably town. less sure on Cakez town, can't explain for because. i don't understand what Wisdom is basing his reads on.
579 is weird.
767: i... okay.
781: why?
809: what's with the apology here.
basic is probably town. i forget who they replaced. but the vote on Nero is bad. you look like you've based it on your dislike of wagoning players who are replacing in. that's a personal issue, and not alignment indicative. no one would change how they feel about that sort of behaviour depending on their alignment in a game.
824: no, pressure voting is useless when you say it's pressure voting.

Narna's self-consciousness (872) is something i've felt as town too. but saying so out loud is interesting. might just be Narna being a different sort of person. i don't know if scum would say that so openly.
879: well, you've ruined it with that by saying as much. if you'd done it before, why would you say that out loud?
i thought Wisdom's accusation of Synik being an alt was a joke, until the next few posts. ...really?
JasonWazza could be scum.
Ankamius's defense of Synix, i don't get. i don't know if he's scum, it's more that i simply don't understanding the wording in 968.
=but why isn't kraska's meta argument on Creature strong to you? SirCakez said the same thing from modding a game with him.

town: SirCakez, Nero Cain (is oddly reminding me of Titus. though they have very different tones), Ankamius, I am Innocent, Wisdom, Broseidon
unsure: Hark, basic, iraonavp, kraska
scum: Sondam, Snarky, JasonWazza, Synik, Vecna

i skipped a lot in this post. talk to me about reads/thoughts, i dislike catching up.

is Synik at L-1?

~Chara

[Basic]

Then you will have to wait patiently Nero.

[Almost Chara]

Synik's posting has been robotic and awkward
He's barely interacting with the people pushing for his lynch
Barely even acknowledged his wagon at all
Every bit of this looks like cornered scum and yet gamma and basic still call this a mislynch

Not so much that, as I don't like YOUR method of trying to get Synik lynched.

you said you were null-town reading Synik. what's the difference?

also, kraska should be at town in the list. i don't know why she's in 'unsure'.
~Chara

[Gamma Emerald]

Synik's posting has been robotic and awkward
He's barely interacting with the people pushing for his lynch
Barely even acknowledged his wagon at all
Every bit of this looks like cornered scum and yet gamma and basic still call this a mislynch

Not so much that, as I don't like YOUR method of trying to get Synik lynched.

you said you were null-town reading Synik. what's the difference?

also, kraska should be at town in the list. i don't know why she's in 'unsure'.
~Chara

As I said, I didn't like kraska's methods.

[Nero Cain]

I should lynch you for even comparing me to Titus.

Synik is L-2

[Almost Chara]

I should lynch you for even comparing me to Titus.

Synik is L-2

how do i know that the reaction would be something like that? :>

VOTE: Synik

that's l-1. obviously.

Synik: is either a very chill player at all times, or is purposely trying to act 'normal' despite their wagon.

Gamma: yes, i got that. why do you think scum would post like that on a wagon that you think will flip town? it looks confident and easygoing more than anything else. would scum advertise their commitment to a town wagon?
and, a general point: i've noticed you're quick to take other players on their word. often, with minor meta comments. i'd either disregard those comments or meta-dive in order to check them. usually, i do the former. you seem quick to trust what opinions you here and run with them instead of thinking about them on your own. not all the time. the example i can think of right now is regarding someone (Cakez?) being a day 3 player.
i could see this from new town as well. is the thing.
~Chara

[Gamma Emerald]

I should lynch you for even comparing me to Titus.

Synik is L-2

how do i know that the reaction would be something like that? :>

VOTE: Synik

that's l-1. obviously.

Synik: is either a very chill player at all times, or is purposely trying to act 'normal' despite their wagon.

Gamma: yes, i got that. why do you think scum would post like that on a wagon that you think will flip town? it looks confident and easygoing more than anything else. would scum advertise their commitment to a town wagon?
and, a general point: i've noticed you're quick to take other players on their word. often, with minor meta comments. i'd either disregard those comments or meta-dive in order to check them. usually, i do the former. you seem quick to trust what opinions you here and run with them instead of thinking about them on your own. not all the time. the example i can think of right now is regarding someone (Cakez?) being a day 3 player.
i could see this from new town as well. is the thing.
~Chara

Hm. Good point.
UNVOTE:
Feeling more like kraska is bad town now.

[Basic]

.....
If Creature is town in your post..... mid way through admittedly.
Why is synik scum in your scum reads?

[Almost Chara]

.....
If Creature is town in your post..... mid way through admittedly.
Why is synik scum in your scum reads?

Creature made a post that looked town part way through. it was early on.
...as you just said. :>
~Chara

[Almost Chara]

Okay then.

I've now caught up.

Scum reads on Dan, Ank and IAI.

This genuinely might be the stupidest theory I've ever seen.

Plus just signing up to be a replacement of a game you're already in breaks site rules.

So who is scum?
You dont seem to particularly care youre about to be lynched

I know my iso is large but I believe in you.

why haven't your reads changed at all since 937? barring the late addition of Bro. particularly, why is Ank scum to you?
~Chara