Wake's Massive Role Madness - Game Over

[RachMarie]

I am here I am here

uggh

On top of everything else last Thurs was out doing wound care and shopping and came down with some kind of viral bug I am so far behind on everything now

[RachMarie]

For better or worse I hope I am making the right decision
because I would so HATE to lose this game after everything I put into it.


VOTE: Elyse

[Elyse]

Are you kidding me

[Elyse]

I'm sorry Rach but you're gonna have to explain yourself.

Did you not see Almost just flip his vote? He was soooo positive I was SK and then he saw an opening and flipped to Narna. And then Narna responded to his points and he ignored him.

Did you ever think about why you're still alive? Why on god's green earth would I bring you to MyLo???

I'm sorry I'm not trying to be rude but it's really frustrating for me to work hard in this MyLo phase, finally feel like I've proven that Almost is SK, and then you come in and just vote me with no explanation.

[RachMarie]

UNVOTE:

I will reread

SIGH I hate being sick

[mhsmith0]

Official Vote Count

Day 12 VC 2

Almost50

(1): Elyse

Not Voting

(3): RachMarie, Narna, Almost50

With 4 alive, it takes 3 to lynch.

Deadline

: (expired on 2016-10-08 16:00:00)[/quote]

[Narna]

Seriously a50, why no response to a single thing I said. You even kept your vote on me despite not having a rebutle.

VOTE: Almost50

Enjoy the win Elyse.

[mhsmith0]

Official Vote Count

Day 12 VC 3

Almost50

(2): Elyse, Narna

Not Voting

(2): RachMarie, Almost50

With 4 alive, it takes 3 to lynch.

Deadline

: (expired on 2016-10-08 16:00:00)

[Narna]

Elyse do you think town is too overpowered with a vig, backup, and 2-shot vig?

[Narna]

Same question for Rach.

[Almost50]

If it wasn't for my great consideration for Rach's feelings, I would have hammered myself right here and now and blames the stupid town of Narna/Elyse for the loss. Whichever of you is actually town should be ashamed of their below par IQ.

So, one (Elyse): Thinks a Nurse with a Doctor in play is unlikely, but a Deputy that has NOT inherited any Cop duties is fine??
The other (Narna): Thinks it's more likely to have 2 vigs AND a backup Vig over a Doctor/Nurse combination?? Like, who taught you to play??

It is OBVIOUS that ONLY ONE of you is legit, and the other is faking. I say Narna is more likely faking, bc a backup Doc "partially" compensates for the overkill cause by the extra vig (who still shot 2 Townies), but a Deputy w/o a Cop isn't something I'd actually expect Wake to use in his setup to begin with, and does not call for and extended Doctor protection (i.e. a Nurse that will replace the dead Cop).

It's true I hate Elyse's play. It's true that if I could I would have lynched her ages ago. It is also true that I hammered Gollum and I'm not even sorry I did. If they lived to LyLo/MyLo I suspect they would've been voting Rach right now with all the nonsense they were spewing. Finally, I took the wrong turn leading the wagon on PV, but it would've still been the same situation if we lynched Elyse first (unless Elyse IS actually the SK).

I think the best we can do here is NO LYNCH. The SK will have one of 3 options:

1- Kill Rach in hopes the OTHER bad player will still vote me tomorrow (I like this scenario, btw, bc then neither myself nor Rach will have caused the defeat).

2- Kill ME and try to pin it on the other.

3- No Kill and we are right where we are.

Over to you Rach.

[Almost50]

Here's what we have:

A Nurse claim, with a Doctor in play, a Deputy claim with no FULL Cop, and a 2-shot Vig claim, with a Vig and Backup Vig in play.

TWO are true, and one is false. Ask yourself which of them is more likely to be included in a game like this. Ask yourself: If YOU were a mod and was picking roles, which of them you would be more likely to use.

THEN you will see clearly that I cannot be the SK by any measures.

VOTE: Narna

If I'm correct, we win. If I'm wrong, well.. part of the loss is on me. I'm I'm the lynchee, then I take no responsibility in the defeat.

[Narna]

You literally put us in this position by deciding to mislynch twice in a row instead of lynching obvscum. One of those time you even admitted to having a 90% scumread on the actual scum player. I'm trying really hard to get at the 2-shot vig claim who plays like an sk, but I'd have to accept that you've been playing like an idiot for three day phases.

Also a coin flip pegged you as sk.

[Narna]

And you are wrong. Deputy without a cop is not unheard of.

This role does not necessarily make any guarantee about the existence of a Cop in the setup to begin with. If there is no Cop, this role is effectively a Named Townie. On the other hand, if there are multiple Cops in the setup, the Deputy will traditionally inherit the sanity of the first deceased Cop.

oh shit better mislynch our vig, miller, and deputy because I don't understand how named townies work.

[Narna]

Why on earth is a 2 shot vig more believable than a regular vig given the supposed vig has killed red and blue scum in the mid to late game anyway?

[Almost50]

I didn't mislynch PV on my own. I didn't even make the push early enough. Math did and I followed down that path, and your phrasing above accusing me of lynching PV IS a scumtell all in and by itself.

I know how named townies work. I was asking each player to think if they would use it. Failing to understand my clear phrasing on this very subject is another scumtell.

Finally, getting too touchy and easily irritated at this ponit doesn't help. It IS a scumtell as well.

So, 3 scumtells in your last 3 posts. GOOD LUCK!

[Narna]

If you're town, you need to not flail so hard my friend. I'm confident Rach isn't going to mislynch me. Given this phase, unless she is the sk, I doubt Elyse will mislynch me either.

So yeah, I needed luck with that coin flip.

[Almost50]

And the continuous use of the word 'mislynch" is another Scumtell aimed at the subconscious of others to cement the idea that 'lynching" you is a 'mislynch". << YOU'RE IT, NO DOUBT ABOUT IT! My vote stays.

[Elyse]

Elyse do you think town is too overpowered with a vig, backup, and 2-shot vig?

In a game this size, yes.

Rach needs to catch up.

@Almost
This is a 42 P game. I'd expect some weird roles and combinations. My reason for suspecting you is the strongman SK theory with Rach still alive.

[Almost50]

@Elyse:

That is not what I asked. What I'm asking is: If YOU were modding, which role(s) would likely include/omit from your own setup, given the option between a Deputy with no Cop, a 2X Vig with a full Vig AND a back-up Vig, and a Nurse with a Doctor in play. Please pick the one YOU would most likely include, and the one YOU would least likely use.

[Elyse]

I know that's not what you asked.

I agree that your role seems most likely and mine or Narna's seems least likely. But lynching based on that is stupid.

[Almost50]

I know that's not what you asked.

I agree that your role seems most likely and mine or Narna's seems least likely. But lynching based on that is stupid.

Thank you.

[Narna]

And the continuous use of the word 'mislynch" is another Scumtell aimed at the subconscious of others to cement the idea that 'lynching" you is a 'mislynch". << YOU'RE IT, NO DOUBT ABOUT IT! My vote stays.

This is flimsy. Town can throw out "mislynch" as well, and we are in Mylo.

[RachMarie]

uggh I am now in analysis paralysis I never thought I would make it this long

we could go for No Lynch and see where we are tomorrow

uggh I am so sorry I lost all momentum with the vla then being sick and now I am like paranoid of everyone and overanalyzing everything because I don't want to pick wrong.

But I know the clock is ticking here

VOTE: No Lynch

[Narna]

It's a crapshoot now, and it will be a crapshoot tomorrow. I feel like we should just end the game. Share what's making you paranoid. It's not like you can incriminate yourself as a mason.