Mini Normal 1844 Firework Mafia. Game Over

[Transcend]

No worries, impoetic my role PM is as green as a shit you take after eating too many Froot Loops

[Transcend]

Mhsmith had a good beginning of the game, started out fairly towny but now i kinda have him null because i dunno if the over analyzingof things that didn't need over analyzing was genuine.

[Transcend]

Alright assuming there's 3 mafia like there usually is I'm gonna go for 3/5 in luv, rb, smith, burger and hermie.

Ccc can possibly be scum but i don't think he's scum with luv and luv is my best scum read.

I also think after careful thinking that rb is scum.

Thoughts?

[Impoetic]

you're saying like everything I'm thinking. Now that I think about it more, some of your posts are almost too towny in the "seem to be focusing on how they're perceived" sense so I'm not totally set on your alignment but nonetheless I fail if you're scum because I don't SR you this game, at least as of yet, but I did in past games where we were both town lol

predit: those are mostly my null/scumreads except cloud but idk how well cloud can towntell as scum so I might not be giving him enough credit.

[Transcend]

Yeah i always give off a bad vibe when I'm tryhard town.

[Impoetic]

oh wait there's an actual CCC in this game whose posts I totally forgot about lmao.

I think I'd lynch Hermie today before LUV so far but I wouldn't be opposed to a LUV lynch either.

[Transcend]

Like the games on here i had the best reads, i got d1ed or d2ed. The games on here i had shitty reads and half assed it, i got endgamed look.

[Transcend]

What don't you like about hermie

[JaeReed]

that pretty much seems perf to me, transcend. I mean I am not as hot on Io as you are but I'm trusting that you wouldn't dun goof up that hard with your hardest tr. Wasn't super hot on smith but he dropped from your tr's so atm they're almost in line with mine.

Was on the fence about impo until her post about her needing to change her scum meta.
rb and hermie are my stronger sr's, lesser in smith & ccc. burger is possibly town but needs a vig shot to the head (soz mate)
luv hasn't done anything to make me think your read on him could be wrong so I'm cool with lynching there.

[JaeReed]

Now that I think about it more, some of your posts are almost too towny in the "seem to be focusing on how they're perceived" sense so I'm not totally set on your alignment but nonetheless I fail if you're scum because I don't SR you this game, at least as of yet, but I did in past games where we were both town lol

stop fos'ing my strongest townread in scummy ways lol

[Transcend]

Actually JR, Io has been town and I've been scum with her every game I've played so this is the first time I'm legitimately reading her without actually knowing her alignment. I don't think she's playing like her scum self in open 655.

[Transcend]

Hermie is just a dead null for me. I've just dismissed him as bad, don't really know his alignment.

[JaeReed]

hm ok. I don't have much meta on Io so as I said just trusting your read there. My only scum!Io meta was I think her first newbie on site and she was more focused on appearing true newb i think. I think she was town in donner party but i was vig there and tunneled on town all d1 before i got nk'ed so i couldn't really tell you about it lol.

Hermie might be bad but his first two posts were pure filler, not even the good tonereading kind. third was asking about the mason thing which makes me uneasy. then if you compare 366 to 376, and 389 the whole "rb is fillery but maybe just plays that way but i'm voting transcend for fillering" is absolutely awful in a way i feel is actually AI. I won't even drag out 379 as evidence because that could just be a misunderstanding based on wording but it's factored in to that read and how i felt he didn't genuinely sr you.

[Transcend]

I think his vote was bad but i think he might have genuinely fosed me. Idk yo.

[Lil Uzi Vert]

I got a couple of reads but I definitely need to check the shelfs again.

[Impoetic]

Now that I think about it more, some of your posts are almost too towny in the "seem to be focusing on how they're perceived" sense so I'm not totally set on your alignment but nonetheless I fail if you're scum because I don't SR you this game, at least as of yet, but I did in past games where we were both town lol

stop fos'ing my strongest townread in scummy ways lol

that wasn't an fos, that was my acknowledging that my tr could be wrong. Fricker.

[Impoetic]

I think his vote was bad but i think he might have genuinely fosed me. Idk yo.

seemed disingenuous enough to me which was basically why I brought him up but idk I'll look back at this later.

[Hermie]

Okay so I am trying to catch up. I really am not picking anything up on my gut radar other than burger is spoiling for a fight and everyone claims lil Uzi is scum. Transcend seems to be town so I guess VOTE: lil Uzi

[Hermie]

Transcemd what do you look for for scum tells in a player? You didn't seem to like my list... What do you use?

[Transcend]

I use gut, look for contradictions, try to decide whether the person is genuinely developing the reads they have or if they're bsing, and i read tone. I mainly use the third one.

[Transcend]

Filler is nai (non alignment indicative) as both alignments do it. Same thing with giant posts with lots of fat that could be trimmed.

[Hermie]

Ha well then I look scummy as hell. I haven't developed one read yet this game.

[Hermie]

I don't really like wallotex posts because I feel like it' s an unnecessary way of trying to make your point look more valid than anyone else's

[Transcend]

Lack of development isn't scummy imo. Even i sometimes have trouble.

Pedit: neither lol

[Hermie]

I try to read tone but in this game the first 20 pages were so much trash I just couldn't figure anything out. I will try to step up my activity and see what I can come up with but as of now my best bet is just to hop on a band wagon like I did with LUV