Newbie 1747 (Game Over)

[Blawb]

Ugh, so much to respond to. Was kinda hoping that my case would've been good enough to seal the deal on Thor; it looked like it last time I checked. I know it's dumb to make IRL excuses, but I'm a senior in high school and the Early Action deadline for college applications is coming up (November 1st), so I'm admittedly slacking on here as of right now. That being said, I still think it's Thor. I'm willing to switch my vote to PP, but I don't agree with it. I still fully support the notion of lynching Thor; he resonates experienced scum to me. I'll dig into his interactions with Creeps a bit more when I have the chance, because I doubt it's plain cut as it seems. Hermie, I'd also like to hear a bit more from you on the offensive side; you seem to be expecting a mislynch, not caring who it is. I cleared you, but don't be mindless.

I'll hammer PP tomorrow if none of you will budge. And Thor, I meant none of what I said to be offensive towards you as a player. But you already knew that. Unlike the rest, I'm not so easily swayed by emotions.

[Hermie]

Blawb I shouldn't have voted Thor I have gut read him as town all game. I have thought pp was slightly town-null-slight scum-probably scum in that order. As to you I'm undecided, Persephone hadn't left much to go off of other then a post with a townish tone. Your case against Thor had holes but that isn't necessarily a scum trait but it would have a scum lean to it. As to mhsmith I feel he is town based on activity. For me as scum I always slip up if i try to be super active and mh seems to be fairly consistent all game. If algebra wasn't conf-town I would be suspicious of him but he is proven town.

[algebra]

Catching up

[Thor665]

I still think it's Thor. I'm willing to switch my vote to PP, but I don't agree with it.

Why would you vote for something you don't support?

I still fully support the notion of lynching Thor; he resonates experienced scum to me.

This is an odd comment 'experienced' scum.
Of course I'm experienced - that goes without saying.
What you need to explain is why I'm experienced *scum* as opposed to experienced *town*.

And Thor, I meant none of what I said to be offensive towards you as a player. But you already knew that. Unlike the rest, I'm not so easily swayed by emotions.

Naw, that's hooey.
Look, you either think I'm being a bad IC - in which case you should *immediately* report me to the list mod.
Or you were just generically attacking me over nothing trying to push your case - in which case, regardless of your alignment, it's a BS play and an attack on my character rather than my alignment play.
Which was it?

[Hermie]

The more I read the more I wonder if blawb is scum. He seems to be rather sure that pp is gonna flip town, and he wants to pin that flip on Thor. Creeps had no interaction at all with perse, not even to try to prod him.

My lynch pool atm is pp or blawb and since pp is l-1 I will leave my vote on him, but I will switch in a heartbeat.

[Thor665]

The worst I can say for Blawb is that some of his attacks are extremely surface level paired with some personal attacks.
But the level of effort into those cases feels townish to me - I (sadly) think he's being honest.

[Thor665]

Compare/contrast with PP's extremely lazy attack on me.

[Hermie]

The thread is slowing down... I think the time has come for a hammer. Pp sits at l-1, who gets to do the honors?

[Hermie]

Mistange and algebra! You guys are conf-town you need to be giving your thoughts.

[PenguinPower]

VOTE: Thor

If I'm going out, at least it will be with a vote on scum.

[Hermie]

Thor and pp now both sit at l-1. Choose ye this day!

[Thor665]

If not a case
After all - the case would convince people.
Maybe before you die you should post it?
Y'know, the case...that you already have conceived?

[Thor665]

Thor and pp now both sit at l-1. Choose ye this day!

I'm at L-2.

[mhsmith0]

VOTE: penguinpower

Fwiw I mainly get a "giving up" sense from PP, which is null currently (unfortunately), but I think he was trying to protect creeps d1 by not voting and at the end awkwardly hammered his buddy. Overall likeliest scum IMO.

[mhsmith0]

Btw if penguin flips red all post game posts must begin with "smith GOAT"

[PenguinPower]

Sorry. VT.

[mhsmith0]

[Thor665]

Do you still feel Blawb or Thor?

[mhsmith0]

Talk more in why you think it's Thor in twilight? I haven't gone through your links yet; anything more you want to specify?

[PenguinPower]

I actually think I was being overly emotional about Thor based on his defense of Hermie's crap post 50, as he defended my crap case against Loopdan in 1725. I called out Thor as scum, correctly, based on his play in 1724 as his interactions there were substantially similar to 1725. Upon re-reading, he's been playing differently in this game, overall, then he did in either of those games. My emotion is why I wanted to get some other takes on it.

Scum is between Thor and Blawb. Gut still says Thor, but it's probably blawb.

[Hermie]

So I'm a bad counter. I was thinking 3 was a hammer not 4. Pp sits at l-1 right now and ripe for the hammer. For some reason I think he knows that already tho.

[mhsmith0]

So I'm a bad counter. I was thinking 3 was a hammer not 4. Pp sits at l-1 right now and ripe for the hammer. For some reason I think he knows that already tho.

I agree w basically all of this.

[Hermie]

Hello? Anyone here?

[mhsmith0]

At this point we should either get a hammer or a good reason not to. Penguins still my top scum read at this point. And I still need to know if I was awesome enough to call the whole scum team in like my 4th post

[PenguinPower]

Well, in all honesty, I thought I was hammered. I'm fine to move my dying vote to...

VOTE: Blawb

...since my read on Thor was off. It's still, most likely, between those two.