Mini 1851 : Order of the Stick Mafia - Epilogue

[Infinity 324]

Actually it's ok if you no comment on that

[Wisdom]

Correct.

Why? He was as defensive in the previous ones too. What's different now?

[Wisdom]

My only reason Leon might be scum is because I'm tonwreading so many people right now.

Any scumreads?

[Infinity 324]

Correct.

Why? He was as defensive in the previous ones too. What's different now?

He was a little defensive about a small issue, now he's showing a level of concern and a level of words dedicated to defending himself that wasn't there before. The issue isn't defending himself, townies can defend themselves, it's the overreaction to his wagon. Town would probably approach it like "I'm suspicious that 4 people just jumped on a lurker wagon" or "Can you guys explain why you scumread me" not what he did.

[Wisdom]

meh
I still find it disturbing how easily you 180'd based on a single post but whatever

[Infinity 324]

It's been happening the whole game if you haven't noticed

[Wisdom]

What is your take on Grey since you keep asking about him?

[Infinity 324]

He's still leaning scum

[Kagami]

Kagami's reasoning is seriously "there's three people townreading Inf, one must be scum!" jfc

So Kagami either has townreads on Wisdom and Wraith now or they're scum.

Wait, why is cakez town?

[Kagami]

Btw, if anyone's a miller (i.e. is evil-aligned), they should have said so by now.

Day 2+ miller reveals => lynch.

[PeregrineV]

My only reason Leon might be scum is because I'm tonwreading so many people right now.

Any scumreads?

Yeah, but not much changed from before, and mostly from lack of townreading them.


2. Leonshade
3. shaddowez
4. Bulbazak
12. SirCakez
13. GreyICE replaced Wraith

[PeregrineV]

Btw, if anyone's a miller (i.e. is evil-aligned), they should have said so by now.

Day 2+ miller reveals => lynch.

Not a miller.

[Kagami]

Kagami's reasoning is seriously "there's three people townreading Inf, one must be scum!" jfc

So Kagami either has townreads on Wisdom and Wraith now or they're scum.

Wait, why is cakez town?

ok, nvm. You think you were the third player, whereas I had completely forgotten that you also claimed a townread on inf in your first post.

That has absolutely nothing to do with my vote on you.

[GreyICE]

Hey Wisdom.

Did you lie again?

[Infinity 324]

The fact that everyone has these same scumreads is good but also a little worrying.

This is an interesting turning point in the game for a couple reasons that I'll talk about later.

[Kagami]

Farside may have had the best reads. There are shenanigans afoot, I feel.

[GreyICE]

Why not talk about them now?

[Kagami]

Doesn't seem necessary.

I like the current gamestate, though I'm getting a bit impatient about a few thing.

[Infinity 324]

Farside may have had the best reads.

What does this mean?

Why not talk about them now?

Because I don't want to give advice to the scumteam

[Leonshade]

I've already been using "genuine" in my townreads a lot, but

Tammy

reads really genuine to me.

Nacho

strikes me as a very good and experienced player (between his own posts and what other people are saying here), so I will be reluctant to give them an easy townread. For now, I'm ready to townlean them for his general play.

Wisdom's SR on me makes a lot more sense now that I know his reads, PoE + what he perceives as defensiveness are reasonable for a scumread (and I will admit my last couple posts were defensive, but I still don't see why my posts regarding Inf were defensive).

I don't feel strongly about

Wraith's

posting as scummy. Kinda leaning town on him, really. I see where his thought processes are coming from, even if I don't always agree with them. Nothing scummy in GreyICE's posts so far, either.

I haven't read

SirCakez

yet, his walls made my eyes glaze over. Will try to sort him later.

I could see

farside

as scum for going aggressively after my top townread in Infinity. Going aggressive, then apologizing and toning it down could be scum trying to placate people too.

Nothing caught my eye with

PeregrineV

or

Bulbazak

yet.

Almost forgot about

shaddowez

when putting together his post. His posts seem like a bunch of white noise. The questions he's asking are all a bunch of softballs that never lead to anything of interest to the game. And, uhhh, despite claiming to have two scumreads, he still hasn't moved his vote from RVS. Yeah, this seems like scum trying to not rock the boat.

Town

Infinity
Wisdom
Tammy
Kagami

Townlean

Nacho
kraska
Wraith

Null

SirCakez (need to read)
Bulbazal
PeregrineV

Scumlean

farside

Scum

shaddowez

[Leonshade]

@Kagami: If your vote on me isn't due to the "Inf townread is suspicious, one has to be scum" PoE, then what is your reason for voting me?

[Leonshade]

VOTE: shaddowez

[Kagami]

I found your 584 to be a special sort of ridiculous, but in large part it was because voting you seemed more useful than voting wraith or shadow at the time.

[Kagami]

Hiya grey. Are you looking for someone?

I'm going to assume the answer to this is "no," which makes for a pretty astonishing coincidence.

[Leonshade]

Right, I forgot my wagon started after that post.

But you also expressed a scumread on me in 202, what was your reason for scumreading me then?