Guardian wrote:Re: that.
Kison really hasn't done anything scummy all game. And everyone is saying I must be scum -- with him. Think about that. I think Kison is objectively very likely to be town.
My subjective opinion is that Kison is objectively very likely...
Kison also really doesn't make sense, he has played really townlike, and is v. unlikely to be scum.
Explain why.
Seriously, predicating your attack on me with Kison being scum is ludicrous. Kison has had so many opportunities in this game to support easy lynches, and hasn't. Really, Fonz/Korlash, if you think I am a good lynch because you think it is me-Kison, think again. That doesn't even make sense.
AS I believe has been addressed, the issue isn't 'Kison must be scum' it's 'Guardian is scum because of his claim, and the inconsistencies in it, etc, and from certain people's perspectives he must be Guardian's buddy.'
Sure, Jenter or ChronX could be scum with me. But that isn't the case. Why would I attack them?
WIFOM, and you know it.
Me not interpreting my results was very regrettable. Sorry.
Your not interpreting your results, if town, is not regrettable, but UNFORGIVABLE. When I replace in as an investigative role, the VERY FIRST thing I do is look at my predecessor's results, see if the investigatees are still alive, and if specifically tracker, who they targetted, and what can be gleaned from that. Instead, you came in, and in your first post, attacked the very player your results should have suggested most likely to be town. Can you not see why that appears to be almost as strong evidence as possible that your claim is baloney?
But Fonz, honestly, your logic about why I wouldn't interpret them correctly as scum is bullshit. If I was scum, I'd be
more
careful to have results that make sense and also to interpret them carefully. I'd discuss them with the other mafia at night, and make sure that tracker was a good claim or whatever.
THAT'S bullshit. If it were true, scum would never mess up their fakeclaims. Which they do reasonably often.
Look, Guardian, this goes to the heart of why some people get pissed off with your playstyle. You claim at the point in the game when it makes most sense for scum to do so, your claim doesn't add up, and you act like it's almost inconceivable that people could possibly disbelieve you. Then you seem to throw any old BS argument against the fan, in the hope one will stick.
With regard to Guardian/Jenter's claims and game balance:
Goon-RB-Scum Mason vs Cop/Doc/Tracker is reasonably balanced.
Goon-RB-GF vs Cop/Masons/Doc is also balanced.
So we can't make any assumptions about who is scum from game balance. What I would say is there is far more chance of GF if Guardian is scum than if Jenter is.
KorlasH: I really don't understand your ChronX vote. We KNOW one of Guardian and JB is scum, and we're almost certainly at LYLo. Looking at ANYTHING else right now can only be seen as an attempt to confuse the town.
Also, a big f-you to whoever requested prodding me whilst I was on V/LA.