Undertale Mafia: Friends & Corpses [GAME OVER]

[Shiro]

That means that Shiro's version of miller is the same version of miller that mine is.

That means Narna is lying about being able to get an innocent result on Shiro, since my role PM specifically states that every investigative ability will return a guilty if I am in one of my miller states.

Nvm I noticed this.

VOTE: Narna

Maybe join me on almost instead? Narna 's actions make no sense if scum. A guilty on anybody else would have been far easier if a last mislynch was his plan. I

[Maxous]

a miller returning guilty to a psychologist would be really weird but given that

a) this game is bastard and

b) i played through Skull's Borderlands Mafia

it is something i could actually see her doing

fuck this, i'm just asking the mod myself

[Narna]

That means that Shiro's version of miller is the same version of miller that mine is.

That means Narna is lying about being able to get an innocent result on Shiro,

since my role PM specifically states that every investigative ability will return a guilty if I am in one of my miller states.

Ank, why didn't you make that clear earlier? Most millers don't work like that, and to just tack on things people show up guilty to as they appear defeats the point of claiming miller early.

You also have to imagine that a miller fakeclaim would say they are immune to all investigations once incriminating evidence presents itself, regardless of Ank's role pm.

[Creature]

Not sure why psychologist would be an exception here.

[Narna]

Not sure why psychologist would be an exception here.

I can get guilties on plenty of town roles from vigs to people who simply received a killing item. My results are different from mafia/not mafia which would fall under a usual miller's jurisdiction.

[Creature]

Psychologist: No wiki article. Mentioned only in Hard Boiled setup.

[SirCakez]

Why isn't narna dead yet???

[Nahdia]

Hey Nahdia, have you revealed who you have jailed?

zakk (I failed, obviously)

What do you mean?

I mean take a moment to look who died that night.

[Nahdia]

To everyone else: either you think Narna is scum, or you think both Shiro and I are scum.

There is

zero

room for error in this.

Not true.

If Narna asked "what result would I get if I targeted someone who was a miller, as in the traditional normal miller role", they'd get the answer they got. Skull isn't going to tell Narna the specifics of

your

role.

[Ankamius]

That means that Shiro's version of miller is the same version of miller that mine is.

That means Narna is lying about being able to get an innocent result on Shiro,

since my role PM specifically states that every investigative ability will return a guilty if I am in one of my miller states.

Ank, why didn't you make that clear earlier? Most millers don't work like that, and to just tack on things people show up guilty to as they appear defeats the point of claiming miller early.

You also have to imagine that a miller fakeclaim would say they are immune to all investigations once incriminating evidence presents itself, regardless of Ank's role pm.

What reason do I have to make that clear immediately?

If people want to know that information, they can ask. Until then, anyone who can investigate anything should be wary of this in a bastard game regardless.

[Ankamius]

To everyone else: either you think Narna is scum, or you think both Shiro and I are scum.

There is

zero

room for error in this.

Not true.

If Narna asked "what result would I get if I targeted someone who was a miller, as in the traditional normal miller role", they'd get the answer they got. Skull isn't going to tell Narna the specifics of

your

role.

I'd be more compelled to accept this if Narna's kneejerk reaction wasn't to try to discredit my role instead of trying to dispel this contradiction.

[Ankamius]

To everyone else: either you think Narna is scum, or you think both Shiro and I are scum.

There is

zero

room for error in this.

Not true.

If Narna asked "what result would I get if I targeted someone who was a miller, as in the traditional normal miller role", they'd get the answer they got. Skull isn't going to tell Narna the specifics of

your

role.

I'd be more compelled to accept this if Narna's kneejerk reaction wasn't to try to discredit my role instead of trying to dispel this contradiction.

Never mind this, I misread something.

UNVOTE: Narna

I'll wait until people get responses, then.

[Titus]

So great, we got two days until deadline

My vote will be on the highest of

Narna
Not Chara
Creature
SirCakez
Peregrine V

I do have a busy IRL. You have my scumreads.

I am not voting anyone else unless desperation. I townread everyone else.

[Nahdia]

I hesitate to bring up this point because 1) Rolefishing and 2) Bastard game but the presence of MULTIPLE global millers would suggest we've got investigative roles which allude towards alignment. But it's day 4 and it's not like anyone besides Narna has come forward with any kind of results that would be affected by millers. Unless I'm forgetting something?

[Andrius]

I mean BASTARD GAME.
I'm Frisk so I imagine there could be complications if I'm ever lynching/killing someone but that's idle speculation 100%.

[Nahdia]

Honestly, if it weren't for the Gester wingdings crap we've been getting, I'd be seriously considering the possibility that there's no scumteam. It'd fit the Undertale flavor perfectly.

[Creature]

It'd be funny if there were no scumteam.

[Nahdia]

inb4 the only way to win is to declare a draw and thus stop senselessly murdering each other.

[Firebringer]

I am the scum team.

[Firebringer]

Can't we all get along?

[Creature]

I kind of wanted to get us to abandon the game because it doesn't look fun.

[Firebringer]

I kind of wanted to get us to abandon the game because it doesn't look fun.

Kind of feel same way.
But looking at reviewers I doubt either would approve a no scum team game or no scum.

[Andrius]

inb4 the only way to win is to declare a draw and thus stop senselessly murdering each other.

This makes a lot of sense for PACIFIST FRISK

[Firebringer]

VOTE: Happily Ever After

[Andrius]

Its k.
We're lynching Shiro or Narna based on the claim once we sort it out. Today is set.

Dont fret yet, Creature.