Yeah, the most sus people on this waggon are me and Jae. I state a reason, dunno if it's that viable or not, but Jae just votes AA9 up. He's third vote for AA9 and apparently thats a cool scum spot. So far here are my reads on people.
Very Much Town:
Fluffy
Tywin
I really don't know yet:
AA9
GIF
Tier
Very Much so Scummy:
8uny
Jae
Radiant
When it comes to Fluffy and Tywin, I think they're town because they are trying to find scum. As in trying to play the game. If anyone I think they are the most vocal people atm.
With AA9, I really don't know. She's leaning more towards town for me, but I just don't know. Maybe she could be a scum partner for reasons others pointed out, but I voted in hopes that I could try to get a clearer read on her.
GIF I'll get back to in another post. Need to ISO him to figure this out more.
When it comes to Tier, I just don't really know yet. He's leaning towards Scum for me, mostly for reasons that Jae pointed out. But also to me, Radiant like a dog on a bone to use his example. And I really don't know what about his reads on people, but they just seem really offputting. Maybe it's he didn't explain much as to why. For some reason it just bothers me.
8uny for.
8uny and Radiant may just need replacements, I asked for a prod on 8uny and I haven't seen him post assuming he was prodded. Same goes for Radiant.
I think Jae is scummy. Why?
In post 208, JaeReed wrote:
Kinda hard to explain, tbh. AA9's initial reaction and response to me with the RVS felt like an overreaction of sorts when reading emotionally. I can see an argument for that being either town or scum, especially with the response to me thinking the reaction was interesting as I do still read it as aggressive over sarcastic (isn't sarcasm a form of aggression anyway?) because the vote doesn't look like RVS, but I can also see a world in which is it and I'm just misinterpreting that. Anyway if it is sarcastic as a response over aggressive then the response is a net null (maybe nullscum since players better than I have noted sarcastic posts early on to be a scumtell in the past and been right with their reads). If it's aggressive I can see arguments for it being town aggression or arguments for it being scum aggression and in the case of it being town aggression I really wouldn't want to push on it and end up in a tunnel today. If she's scum then she still has a partner and I can re-evaluate her tomorrow.
I might be as bad at reading sarcasm as I am at picking it up from my mother irl
I could be approaching this wrong.
I also didn't particularly love her giving GiF a meta townread and seemingly handwaving others reads on him when I believe there was content to read him off. Like, despite agreeing that he's town I feel like it was a soft discredit of others townreads AND the meta is stale (didn't they say it had been a year or something?) so it doesn't read as completely genuine but also I feel like that is another thing that could come from town with an ego.
idunno, as I said, I'm not confident in my townread but I'm not sure I'd be willing to lynch her today at this point and time, which is why she's on the townread side rather than the scumlean side.
After saying that last bit, he jumps on the waggon for AA9 on the third spot. First of all, third spot for hoping onto a waggon seems scummy to me. Second of all, he doesn't add anything when adding AA9 to the waggon. And lastly, he contradicts himself by voting her up as soon as the waggon started. And when GIF is saying that we're doing this all wrong, he just responds
Hell, by even letting me off the hook as someone who is playing really scummily for a VT, that in itself seems scummy to me mostly because you claim you want to let me operate a bit better under pressure, yet I think you changed your vote so that you can keep me alive as a townie that'll just get lynched for acting like a scum. Saves you one less NK.
VOTE JaeReed
