Mini 1855: Questionable Content Mafia - Game Over!

[Socrates]

IF Nacho is scum:

Camn, LUV, and Jae are all town.
I'll need to take another look at MOI.
Heavy odds on Ari being scum.

[JaeReed]

^ Why? Nacho is pushing Ari, so why would he be scum if Nacho is scum?

[camn]

Nacho came out and placed an initial vote on Ari. Perchance he intended to move that vote...'on catchup'
The wagon expanded. Perhaps to Nacho's chagrin?

[Socrates]

We are not allowing Aristophanes to die without posting.

Replace him, if need be.

[MagnaofIllusion]

This is a note to say I’ve seen 561 and I’m specifically not responding unless someone in my Town reads feels it is important. I think the discussion back and forth has reached the point where it is clear we aren’t going to reach any sort of common ground and I’m not going to waste time debating things with him (for example that Tone reading is crap) that leads nowhere given neither of us are going to change our philosophies. Jae remains a strong scum read for me.

I also want to note about 561 – it establishes that Jae and LUV are not likely partners.

Waiting for Pisskop, Nacho (although he’s more or less claimed it but I’d like a straight out flavor claim rather than TeeHee look at my crumbs posting on the issue), LLD, Ari and LUV to finish the mass flavor only claim at this stage so I can evaluate what Dunn’s motives were when he explains the reasons.

--

This lays groundwork for the mass flavor claim business, so if you were surprised about it, you shouldn't have been.

Who shouldn’t be surprised? You are quoting Dunn who is the one who started the flavor claim so I’m sure he wasn’t surprised ….

MoI I would invite you to join but we all know you move when you're damn ready and I know you have a particular dislike for continuous promises and repeated not doing shit and you're about to get two handfuls of that shortly.

Answer me this on Jae then Nacho – do you really see him as that strongly Town. If Ari is scum (which I’ve given him enough time to demonstrate he isn’t by not playing directly to his scum meta) what do you think of Jae’s “maybe I’ve vote Ari who I have no actual scum read on or maybe I’ll vote MoI who I’ve called scum repeatedly” dithering as coming from Town?

--

Hey Moi what was this about?

It’s one of my two character breadcrumbs I laid down on the first page.

Here’s the link to the strip in question Library Spider

Are you still avoiding answer those questions I asked in 460 for a reason?

Also, what made you ask this 500+ posts later?

--

We are not allowing Aristophanes to die without posting.

Replace him, if need be.

Where is my dislike button for this post ….

[MagnaofIllusion]

As said above I am on board with Ari scum - he's basically playing to his scum meta which I've identified him by in the past. The only reason I'm not voting him or saying "Intent" is DS hasn't posted a Vote Count in awhile and I'm not for Lolhammering.

Mod: There haven't been enough votes for me to deem it necessary but since you request, I'll post one ASAP.

[kraska77]

Hey dunn if ure what I think u are then target uzi tonight thx I'll put a role stopper on you

[Nachomamma8]

LLD, SpyreX, JaeReed, let's lynch some scum; MoI I would invite you to join but we all know you move when you're damn ready and I know you have a particular dislike for continuous promises and repeated not doing shit and you're about to get two handfuls of that shortly. JaeReed I know you probably want some guidance to rescue you from that dark world of your MoI world but as I still haven't caught up with the game completely I need you to talk about MoI before I can make that dream a reality.

So where am I to you? Null? Scum?

town. why would i ask you to vote ari with me when you're already voting ari?

[Nachomamma8]

JaeReed I know you probably want some guidance to rescue you from that dark world of your MoI world but as I still haven't caught up with the game completely I need you to talk about MoI before I can make that dream a reality.

Nacho, I'm going to make this perfectly clear: I don't townread you. Stop trying to buddy up to me.

dark world of that MoI read*
I'm not trying to buddy you; when buddying, I try to aim for more "lovable" and "charming" and less "obnoxious substanceless asshole". Instead, since I thought you were in the business of attempting to read me, I tried to open up a line of communication by challenging you on your MoI read; why didn't you talk about your read there?

[Nachomamma8]

I never said that 77's laughing about the claim would be alignment indicative, just thought it be something that Jae could've mentioned if they were unsure of what to comment on in since they weren't factoring the miller claim at the time.

When someone says they are "unsure of what to comment on", typically they mean that they don't see anything alignment-indicative to comment on.
Why would they care about commenting on anything else?

The boring thing. Generally, town end up sticking their necks out someway, somehow. This is what make their posts interesting. When they don't, their posts are boring. Now, sometimes I give people the benefit of the doubt; some people have a way of viewing the world that doesn't mesh with mine and doesn't pique their interest. However, the people who view the world like that and people who would name themselves Lil Uzi Vert typically don't interact much. Does that answer your question?

[Nachomamma8]

^ Why? Nacho is pushing Ari, so why would he be scum if Nacho is scum?

Every couple of years, there comes a player who as scum is very, very uncomfortable playing scum and not so uncomfortable playing town. When they play town, the relief in their posts in tangible; they are not particularly difficult to find. When they play scum.... promises of catch up and good posts and then more promises of catch up and good posts and then nothing. That's what you're seeing here. You can wait as long as you'd like for evidence to stack up, but this is the sort of lynch that you thank the shiny mafia gods is happening for the good of your team because being completely unable to defend a partner because there is no good counterargument to "this is their scumgame" sucks ass.

[Nachomamma8]

Nacho came out and placed an initial vote on Ari. Perchance he intended to move that vote...'on catchup'
The wagon expanded. Perhaps to Nacho's chagrin?

If I vote a partner, I'm willing to lynch a partner.
If you're posturing for suspicion on me, I'd recommend dropping your "sheep to read" method and instead going all-in on getting me lynched; my dancing partners of late have been more frustrating than competent and it'd be a nice change of pace to deal with someone with a sense of rhythm. That invitation extends to LLD, of course, although I would be a bit surprised if her scumread still holds once she's comfortable in the game again.

[Nachomamma8]

IF Nacho is scum:

Camn, LUV, and Jae are all town.
I'll need to take another look at MOI.
Heavy odds on Ari being scum.

You're absolutely correct that I would bus the shit out of Ari if I were scum here; in addition, I wouldn't push a lynch like this unless I had a level of confidence that was particularly unusual for mafia games. Why have you decided to vote me for it? Because I'm not giving Aristo enough time? That implies the argument that everyone needs a set amount of days before lynching them, and no, I don't really think that's the case; experience can dictate otherwise and here it does.

[Nachomamma8]

We are not allowing Aristophanes to die without posting.

Replace him, if need be.

You do realize he does have 12 posts... right?

[pisskop]

he has an abysmal level of content

[kraska77]

At this point the persisten lack of content is intentional
Which is sad bcs lynch tells us nothing but whatever he's scum here

[Nachomamma8]

Who shouldn’t be surprised? You are quoting Dunn who is the one who started the flavor claim so I’m sure he wasn’t surprised ….

That was a general "you".

Answer me this on Jae then Nacho – do you really see him as that strongly Town. If Ari is scum (which I’ve given him enough time to demonstrate he isn’t by not playing directly to his scum meta) what do you think of Jae’s “maybe I’ve vote Ari who I have no actual scum read on or maybe I’ll vote MoI who I’ve called scum repeatedly” dithering as coming from Town?

I can't say I care considering it's sure as shit not going to save him and it's sure as shit not going to buy Jae cred - sometimes town dithers over an easy decision even when the answer is hitting them in the face, and sometimes, in the special case of Socrates, town takes a very simple decision and does something... weird? Inexplicable?

[Nachomamma8]

he has an abysmal level of content

god damn it pisskop

socrates was supposed to say "but he hasn't done anything!" and then i was going to post a picture of spike

[Nachomamma8]

At this point the persisten lack of content is intentional
Which is sad bcs lynch tells us nothing but whatever he's scum here

no, it's not sad at all.
every once in a while the mafia gods give you a free lynch. when you get them you take them because they won't last forever and when the gravy train ends you're going to get your world fucking rocked.

[pisskop]

"but he hasn't done anything!

[Nachomamma8]

[Nachomamma8]

you know i thought that wouldn't feel good but it still felt good
thanks kop

[kraska77]

At this point the persisten lack of content is intentional
Which is sad bcs lynch tells us nothing but whatever he's scum here

no, it's not sad at all.
every once in a while the mafia gods give you a free lynch. when you get them you take them because they won't last forever and when the gravy train ends you're going to get your world fucking rocked.

K thx for letting me know. I will praise and exalt the mafia gods for making my lyf easier

[Nachomamma8]

I love it when someone engages me directly,

treat others how you want to be treated
if i voted you and didn't say why then started talking about other people's alignment i'm sure you wouldn't be tickled by my approach

[Nachomamma8]

VOTE: jawreed

This is Charlie Brown and the football all over again

Just looked up the reference (and yes I know of Charlie Brown, I just never read most of it).

Why did you perceive what was happening there to be reminiscent of that strip?

when you want something and it looks like it's happening and then it's dragged away from you at the last moment