Musician Mafia: Guitarists GAME OVER

[NoPowerOverMe]

The 3 guitarists are Holcomb, Mansoor, and Bowen?

[a2rudeboy]

Bois, Murphy, and GEtgood were also guitarists for a long period

[NoPowerOverMe]

You don't know which 3 specifically?

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

Am I the only sane one left in this game? I think the answer must be yes because it was just me and DGB and some idiot killed her....

yes let the hate flow through you

[pisskop]

Who is scum. Can we not play the willing victim here?

Since I have currently voted Dave, one would believe that that is who I think is scum.

lol

VOTE: dave dave is scummy enough

[pisskop]

Ok. Here we go.

Fuck it.

I am Josh Bowen from Periphery. I am a Big Brain VT. The big brain means i know the other two guitarists of Periphery are role flavour in the game. They are not my alignment.

[Almost50]

So, maybe I wasn't paying much attention before, and I think it'd be damn too hard for me to reread 200+ pages, so I decided to read from where I am, and mix that with some logic (at least it's logic from MY PoV).

- Gamma: Very likely Town. Proof: I am still alive
- Pooky: Who the hell knows with this guy. He's "good company" regardless, but I can't read him for shit
- Lav: Town: Reason: Inexplicable visit claim to FGB which instantly made the latter conf!Town her. I'll go with that.
- Bambi: Again, who the hell knows? His win con could literally be "Love long enough to have used up all your abilities and you leave the game a winner"
- TD: Nothing so far. I remember having TR's him earlier, but I don't remember why. Currently NULL
- Grendel: I remember he made a string entrance to the game that doesn't come from Scum IMHO. Ton Lean
- NPOM: The Towniest Townie that has ever Towned in this game. This "untidy" thought process combined with such loudness and a touch of "not caring how it looks on me" NEVER comes from Scum. Lacking conviction and flip/flopping is also more likely a Town trait, because there simply doesn't seem to be any agenda or pre-planned objective behind it.
- A50: That guys is scummy to me. He barely beats Lavender activity-wise.
- pisskop: Overall, that's a townie slot. Don't ask for specifics because with PK everything can be interpreted either way. It's probably WHEN he says/does things that matter, so it's more of a matter of conception rather than solid reasoning
- Drew: Believe it or not I can't make up my mind about this one. He sometimes comes across as pretty townie and other times comes across as vaguely scummy.
- rude: I don't remember why exactly I town!binned this guy, but it has been a steady read all over and I never had him below a Town Lean, so not gonna go for his elimination any time soon. (Gun-to-head he's my 2nd strongest TR after NPOM)
- dave: He's been town!binned just because it's easier that way. With dave I do NOT look for "town tells"m but rather for "SCUM tells" and he hasn't shown any (unless I missed it while skimming)

Som you see my dilemma is still that I have nothing solid to push anyone in particular, and way too few SRs than O probably should have.

I probably should do some ISOing next, although I suck at it (reading posts out of context and natural sequence is often misleading to me), but I shall try anyhow.

[Almost50]

Btw, I probably shouldn't count this game towards my stats either way because I really didn't actually play in it. Maybe I can change that and consequently convince myself I did something on D6?? Remains to be seen

[Almost50]

Well... why not be that ray of light who'll jump start thread activity?

Im sure you could if you pushed yourself.

Sure. How about we cross-vote and have a fight (and I mean the "you, no you" kind of fight that leads to nowhere)?

[Almost50]

Ok. Here we go.

Fuck it.

I am Josh Bowen from Periphery. I am a Big Brain VT. The big brain means i know the other two guitarists of Periphery are role flavour in the game. They are not my alignment.

Juicy! Did anyone flip from that band yet?

P-edit: I guess not. So a massclaim of flavour should do the trick. Yes?

[davesaz]

A massclaim of flavor might have worked before the reveal. Doesn't work now for what should be obvious reasons.

[TiphaineDeath]

Holdup, did rude just say that he has role info that NPOM is scum and hasn't been voting him? What? I am so lost :/

[davesaz]

No, rude said he has flavor information that two other flavors (from a set of larger possible flavors) are in the game and different alignment.
I think this implies 3p must be in the game so would be a good idea to look at rude for evidence of either pushing or dismissing the idea of 3p.

[Almost50]

Holdup, did rude just say that he has role info that NPOM is scum and hasn't been voting him? What? I am so lost :/

That's not how I interpreted it, although I can see that as a valid interpretation from your PoV.

What I got is "3 guitarists of the same band are in-play, and they're not ALL aligned", so it's a 50-50? It could also be that rude thinks one of them could be scum and the other is 3P (i.e. NONE of them is aligned with the other 2).

Yeah, I would appreciate an explanation from rude there, although I am inclined to think he has "more info than he is telling us" based on his D1/D2 behaviour towards NPOM. This is also where I thought rude was hinting NPOM might be 3P (and precisely a Jester, iirc).

But anyway, NPOM already said his flavour is NOT the same as rude's, so that is now mute.

Disclaimer: I am responding from memory, so I can't guarantee everything I said was 100% spot on. Better be checking facts if you intend to use any or all of what I said as basis to make a case one way or another.

[a2rudeboy]

I thought rude was hinting NPOM might be 3P (and precisely a Jester, iirc).

Exactly.

[TiphaineDeath]

Rude, according to the info you have, NPOM MUST be either 3P or Scum, given that you are town, yes? Either that or you are lying to us? Is there a third option here I am missing?

[a2rudeboy]

Rude, according to the info you have, NPOM MUST be either 3P or Scum, given that you are town, yes? Either that or you are lying to us? Is there a third option here I am missing?

False. NPOM's claimed flavour does not match mine.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

npom as jester would make a lot of sense

[a2rudeboy]

npom as jester would make a lot of sense

particularly the part he spent just saying "get rid of me"

[Grendel]

Ok. Here we go.

Fuck it.

I am Josh Bowen from Periphery. I am a Big Brain VT. The big brain means i know the other two guitarists of Periphery are role flavour in the game. They are not my alignment.

VOTE: Rude

Im Misha Mansoor from Periphery! Im also have the "Big brain" modifier, I was also informed that the other two guitarists from Periphery were not of my alignment.

Im not VT, but i have no reason to out what PR i am.

[Grendel]

SO I WAS RIGHT ABOUT NO POWER AND RUDE FLAVOR STUFF???!

Where the heck did No power get that obscure Japanese guitarist he outs his flavor to be the other page?!

[TiphaineDeath]

Well, I'm going to say I was 100% wrong about both Grendel and Rude being scum xD.

All aboard!

[Grendel]

what ever, we should flip one then the other. I dont really know what my preference is???

If one is 3rd party i guess they should cliam. but its entirely possible that they could both be scum.

[Grendel]

God! I feel so dumb for hard town reading both of them for like 90% of the game! lol

[pisskop]

lol i guess that we solved the mystery.

1v1 grendel and rude

gogogogo