Mini 1859: D&D Curse of Strahd Mafia - Game Over

[Shaziro]

Christ's sake if this bites me in the ass...

Let me look over Dreal.

[culted]

I'm not gonna front, he's alright scum, there's things in there you'll probably townread him for.

Don't fall for it.

[Andrius]

drealmers is more likely town.
Cannot yet discern whether culted's push on him is town-driven or scum-driven.

[Shaziro]

Looking back at things, I don't really know how I feel about Dreal's read progression. I can't decide if it seems more to me like he was just trying to get reactions from the people he was pushing on, or from others. If it is from the people he is pushing on, that is towny to me, he wants to see if the person is scum by putting them under some pressure and seeing how they react. If from others, then it's him basically trying to see who he can get a lynch rolling on by gauging town. Does that make sense to anyone else?

[Andrius]

"Buddying" SlySly would mean that we're not already best buds from a previous conflict.
Which we are.

[KuroiXHF]

OK. I'm off V/LA. I'll catch up soon.

[KuroiXHF]

Agree with drealmerz that Persivul's 503 is terrible.

Why? Do you even understand the context of the post?

Yes

To clarify, Andrius, you're saying that it's my posts that are coming across non-genuious?

And yes

You're on creature - you're in no position to criticize anyone for the wagon they're on. Creature's playstyle makes him a horrible D1 lynch.

I'M ASKING A FUCKING QUESTION TRYING TO UNDERSTAND YOUR VIEW OMG

lynch this guy pls

I don't really understand Drealmerz's anger. It's coming out of nowhere, it seems. I know Pervisul is someone who aggravates people extremely easily, but this seems forced. But yeah. I'll consider a lynch on Drealmerz.

I'm quiet right now because I've been drinking...which si good for the game where it's manadtroy, but not good here

sshhhhhhh

kinda hate this game too

I don't know how I feel about this. I'm tempted to town read this because even though he posted minutes after he was mentioned, he was honest about this interaction with a really dumb reason to not post.

but srsly fuck percival

LOL

Again, I'm also ok lynching Persivul.

Why? I feel like a town wanting scum lynched would give us a barebones reasoning on this.

802 is a town-post.

Might be, but Shaddowez tends to post like this when scum. For more information, check out GoT Mafia: Episode 2.

he pings minor-medium in many posts but the major thing that is scumdicative at this point is his complete lack of involvement

I just did an ISO and, he seems much more scummy in it than I was initially reading him

I mean:

You should be more worried about bringing meaningful content as opposed to just posting more.

he hasn't posted a single thing of content up to this point ^

and this is his comment? scummy no doubt - scum? not so sure

comments after this feel like "safe" and non-committal

then the previous post I made was supposed to be copy/pasted after here

Wonderful. Like I said, and like Creature has said now, I find my niche in due time. But I'm trying to catch up now.

Is Kuroi also a level 1 lynchbait?

I'm most definitely lynch bait. I haven't played with many of you before, but the one person here who can back me up is Shaddowez - although in that game, I was scum. But yeah, I'm definitely scum-read a lot.

[KuroiXHF]

drealmers is more likely town.
Cannot yet discern whether culted's push on him is town-driven or scum-driven.

For what it's worth, I don't like Culted either. Perhaps that player deserves my vote.

[culted]

Looking back at things, I don't really know how I feel about Dreal's read progression.

His read progression on who? Just his reads in general?

[Shaziro]

The way his reads overall have moved. He said dunn was scummy, then I was scummy, etc. It gives a vibe of "I'm gonna make shade throwing posts until one gets really picked up on by others, and go with that", but it could easily also be him just looking at people that give him a ping and pressuring them to try and see if they scumclaim.

[culted]

No, I'm defending a townread of mine.
Also, if you look at my 803 again you'll notice that you and shadow both occupy a second group that isn't scum.
Yes, I didn't like his vote on Pine.
But I'm not scumreading him, you both are in a secondary tier of TOWN.

Next time label your readslist and you won't need to patronize people.

You still took shaddow voting pine for reasons that weren't his -- you explicitly gave an abridged misrepped version of the case on pine, which came from dunn's terrible vote beginning of phase 3, and used that as leverage in your reads. That's the point.

Uh, no.
I lost alot of content when I lost my post with the first 17-18 pages of reading.

And were there any non-surface level thoughts you lost taht you'd like to share?

Also no one wants to read an old-school replace-in wall of text so I changed my style.

You changed your playstyle for just this occasion? I thought it was because you lost the post?

I wanted to know why you prefer drealmerz over two options I listed. Both scumreads of mine.

All he's doing at this point is flailing. I'm genuinely curious why you think the slot is town. I realize half the game is lynchbait, you having most of them in your scumpool doesn't impress me.

Will have to look back at kuror0's case again.

Have you done this yet btw?

I have come to expect a bit of eccentricity from drealmerz.

That's all I can say.

And that's obvious to anyone reading this game. The question is is it town eccentric or scum eccentric.

[culted]

The way his reads overall have moved. He said dunn was scummy, then I was scummy, etc. It gives a vibe of "I'm gonna make shade throwing posts until one gets really picked up on by others, and go with that", but it could easily also be him just looking at people that give him a ping and pressuring them to try and see if they scumclaim.

Now that you mention it, he has scumread a good number of people.

And I think pressuring people is more reserved for if you aren't really sure about your read on the slot.
So the question now is, is he content on his reads (the progressions you're seeing) or not while he's pushing them?

And does he ever truly move on?

[culted]

I'll be glad to engage you once you're "with it" (:

And he never did.

Until it was -now-

[Dunnstral]

Andrius is town
culted is town
Persivul is towny to me
Wouldn't lynch Shaziro unless I really thought he was scum because of the role knowledge thing

The rest I don't really care about

I'll lynch pine or drealmerz preferrably but we have 4 days left and I'll try to be more active during them

[Shaziro]

VOTE: Drealm

I expect you all to remember this if Creature turns out to be scum and slips by.

[Dunnstral]

What does drealmerz have to do with creature

[Shaziro]

Because I'm switching -off- of Creature, because I'm being told that we will "get to that later", exactly the same as we did in the other game I had with the bugger.

[Dunnstral]

And you switched off because?

I mean I know I'm convincing that's all you gotta say

[shaddowez]

Working on catching up.

dreal

- was your 700 just a waste of time, or did you intend to follow up on responses to it?

Need to reread Kuroi, but it doesn't look like there's much to go on there. I don't know if I want to lynch based on lurker activity at this point though. Want to reread dreal as well - last time I did so I wasn't finding anything to base a scum read on, so not really sure what's going on there.

Still willing to vote Dunn, my scum read on Pine in waning though still there, and I'd probably be willing to vote Jasonif it was the only wagon we had.

[SlySly]

I'm on page 18 in my review...

Dunn, Shaz, Jason all gaining scum points.

culted, drealmz are looking town.

[Dunnstral]

Willing to lynch slysly and shaddowez too

[drealmerz7]

I'm not gonna front, he's alright scum, there's things in there you'll probably townread him for.

Don't fall for it.

this is scum 100% tonally

[drealmerz7]

Looking back at things, I don't really know how I feel about Dreal's read progression. I can't decide if it seems more to me like he was just trying to get reactions from the people he was pushing on, or from others. If it is from the people he is pushing on, that is towny to me, he wants to see if the person is scum by putting them under some pressure and seeing how they react. If from others, then it's him basically trying to see who he can get a lynch rolling on by gauging town. Does that make sense to anyone else?

yes absolutely and it is the first one

[Clumsy]

Lynch Votecount 1.7

L-2

(5) drealmerz7 - JasonWazza, Culted, Persivul, Dunnstral, Shaziro
(2) Pine - Shaddowez, KuroiXHF
(2) Persivul - drealmerz7, Pine
(1) JasonWazza - Andrius
(1) Andrius - Creature

Not Voting:

kuror0, SlySly

With 13 alive, Majority (50%+1) is 7.

Day One Deadline is

(expired on 2016-12-16 19:00:00)

Mod notes: None[/area]

[Andrius]

OK
ONLY LIVING GAME
SLYSLY WHERE YOU AT LETS PARTY