Mini 1849 : DotA Mafia [R2 - SD] Game Over?!!

[MathBlade]

I have errands to run. Will respond to outstanding questions on my return.

[Radical Rat]

@Rat:

I guess I'm willing to compromise on Bratnz but I still prefer Sickofit or Sonia.

We have hard evidence on BRantz though. Sonia and Sick have a few scummy posts, yes, but they haven't been directly caught in a lie

BRantz has yet to be caught in a lie, with FA's roleblock ability there's still reasonable doubt.

I'm lawyering BRantz but I consider him an acceptable lynch for today, but the actual reason you're SRing him is nonsense.

I just realized that BRantz is L-1. Sonia, we've already had a quickhammer this game, please claim L-1.

I was the one who out him at L-1.

Wait, I did bring up the possibility. And Rat quoted the post, but cropped out the part where I argued against his vote.

@Rat:

Why didn't you respond to the possibility of Fire Assassin roleblocking BRantz?

...That's not the same post.

But the posts were still back to back, and RR didn't respond to it, so the question remains.

Because I forgot FA was even in this game, and meant to come back to that after checking FA's role/ISO, which I never did

[Leonshade]

Hmm. I really want to believe that RR is town. I haven't felt any scum motivation in his play, especially if he's mostly been playing by phone this entire time (as blending in/being someone's buddy by POE would be the only reasons to SR him at this point).

[Leonshade]

If Creature is scum, it's with LLD or Vedith.

Why not Math/RR
Math Sonia?

These are not in your rules out scum pairs but yet Creature scum = LDD/Vedith?

Hmm? Math might be scum if Creature and LLD are both town (I would actually consider it likely at that point). If Creature is scum, it's either with you or LLD. I don't see Math bussing Creature this hard if they're buddies.

[Frozen Angel]

I need to decide about a recent event.

The game and all the related threads are closed. Don't chat with any of the players regarding this.

[Frozen Angel]

Because of a recent event, I have absolutely no choice but to force replace Vedith and MathBlade. I definitely can't discuss this decision any further. Please post pond any comments or possible criticizes about this till end game.

Thanks for your consideration

[Creature]

RIP

[xSoniaNevermindx]

I don't see how you can make me scum with sickofit slot when I brought up some scum meta on me that no one knew about but oook

[Frozen Angel]

Nahdia replaces Radical Rat; Effective Immediately.

Still searching for a replacement for vedith and MathBlade slots.

[xSoniaNevermindx]

NATTTTTT

You could be scum but
NATTTTTTTTTTTTT <3

[Nahdia]

i am not scum.

[Nahdia]

i'm here to save the day. catch me up to speed.

[Leonshade]

Welcome!

We haven't caught any scum yet. Half the town (myself included) has been attempting to lynch Lady Lambdadelta since D1. On D1, her wagon got to L-1, but a rival wagon on Vaxkiller started and the Frizzy Cola/TwizTed/Vedith/replacement slot quickhammered the wagon despite having LLD as their top scumread. That's why I'm reading the slot as LLD's most likely partner, if LLD is scum.

The D2 lynch was BRantz, who was mostly a lurker/non-factor, after the latter half of the day was filled with mechanics/night action analysis BS (thanks partly to me) and apathy.

Today MathBlade replaced the Sickofit slot and pushed hard on Creature, who hadn't been scumread up to that point. It got other players to take a closer look at Creature, including me, who had TR'd him since D1.

Today's lynch so far has looked like it will be between Creature, Sonia and LLD, but nothing is set in stone and town is pretty divided on reads.

[Leonshade]

Teams I'm ruling out:

Sonia-LLD
LLD-Math (I think these are both obvious)
Creature-RR (I don't feel it's possible for both to be scum)
Creature-Math (Math's push doesn't feel like a bus)
Vedith-Math (the slots have been at odds for too long)

If Creature is scum, it's with LLD or Vedith. If Creature is town and LLD is scum, the team is LLD-Vedith or possibly LLD-RR (I haven't spent much time thinking about this team). If both are town, either Math is scum or it's Vedith-RR (haven't spent much time thinking about this team either, don't see it as likely but I'll throw the idea out there).

My reads, as they stand. Your slot is probably town.

[Leonshade]

Sonia and LLD is one of the least likely teams because Sonia spent D1 fighting against LLD's lynch when no one else was doing so and when she looked like the likely lynch. This was followed by her flipping on the slot D2, with the two having a back-and-forth that didn't look like scum theater.

Sickofit was passionate in calling for LLD's head all game, didn't look like a bus at all.

[Nahdia]

So my predecessor did a truly awful job allocating spells but oh well. Looking through some ISO's. I glanced at my "team" chat (is that what we're calling it?) and already have a scumread from there.

Help me help you help me, Leonshade. If you would be so kind, give me a brief rundown of your read progression on Creature. Or, if it's in your ISO, just point to it. Thank you very much.

[Creature]

We call it clan.

[Nahdia]

Creature, status report.

[Creature]

Radical Rat - Lina, targeted LLD, aka someone must've visited LLD, also gave a flower to LLD
Creature - Rubick, targeted no one so far, got nothing so far
Leonshade - Luna, confirms LLD as Windranger
xSoniaNevermindx - Templar Assassin, anything else?
Mathblade - Vengeful spirit, anything else?
Veidth - Faceless Void, used Time Walk
Lady Lambdadelta - Windranger by Leonshade, used ShackleShot on Vedith, aka if someone visited Vedith, their action failed
BRantz - Enchantress, made RR become a flower vendor for one night

Yeah, last night we used glyph and everyone was untargetable.

[Creature]

Also, there was an 1v1 with Vedith and MathBlade, but I thought it were TvT. I think the scumteam is Sonia - LLD by PoE.

[Nahdia]

Thank you.

[Creature]

What's your opinion on MathBlade pushing hard for both Vedith and my lynch but not seeing us as a scumteam?

[Nahdia]

What's yours?

[Creature]

I was townreading Sickofit hard, I just find that weird, though I think it's usual for Math.

[Nahdia]

Then why are you asking me?