Mini 1859: D&D Curse of Strahd Mafia - Game Over

[drealmerz7]

not now that they know that success is guaranteed on our first adventure, as long as I'm alive...

now they'll stop at nothing to make sure I'm dead, I'm sure

like you're doing

[drealmerz7]

LAMIST! I called in 30 mins late to work (and the woman there right now is totally cool with it) just so I could try and get this clear (because it occurred to me in the shower you might have been looking for the Ranger of the _________ words

[Shaziro]

"Success is guaranteed" says the one caught faking a role PM and now trying to back out by saying "Oh there might be more and I'm just not saying". And then when we had some bad shit happen, you'd either say "Oh, well my power made it so it wasn't -as- bad" or "Oh, my power must have been blocked!". I'm not buying it.

[drealmerz7]

of course you're not, you're scum

you have to keep selling your narrative

I assure you all, it's true!! I'm uber

[Shaziro]

You were effectively caught when you started making up reads and put the name of somebody not even in the damn game, this is just -sad- at this point. Fucking hell at the scumflail.

[Pine]

Shaziro, don't get comfy with the notion that all Town roles have an archetype with them. Mine is simply given as 'Cleric.'

That said, there are a lot of inconsistencies with what drealmerz is saying, and the massive amount of AtE he's throwing out screams scum to me

[Shaziro]

You should be a cleric of a particular god, that is your "archetype".

[Shaziro]

More specifically, a god and that god's relevant "Domain".

[Pine]

Yeah, I agree that's how it should have been designed, and it's how I'd have written the role PM, but it wasn't. It just says that I am the Cleric of the Adventurers, and that my Cure Wounds spell will be helpful. It gives a few more details about how it works, and details the lesser 1-shot I have, but none of the flavor details I'd have liked.

[Pine]

A Pelorite cleric would have been boss, but alas.

[Shaziro]

Hm.

[drealmerz7]

point out inconsistencies please I'd like to clarify them if they actually are there

(checking in from work! hah! someone messed up all my hardwork of many hours and days and so I'm just doing nothing)

[kuror0]

While drealmz attitude is not my cup of tea I have to say his claim looks real. I know 3 adventurers role pms. Creature one said you are name lastname but didn't had a specific class. Jasson one was fighter/eldritch knight which means class/subdivision? and mine does not follow any of those 2 pms so far. So for now it holds true. If we believe Pine's claim aswell that means we got at least 4 types of pm which means this whole thing is pointless. Time will tell.

@Shaziro besides this whole thing would you mind providing us some reads on other players? I don't have a clue where you stand on many slots because you have been mostly focused on drealmz and delivering lore.(not that I hate it and I even asked for some of it but your posts have been mostly focusing on that) so I want to know what you think about other players leaving lore aside.

@clumsy Happy birthday have a nice day. And what an awkward day to be born.

[SlySly]

greedy evil fucks want to collect items and power

good adventurers want to go on missions and destroy evil

Smart adventurers know that to succeed, they must remain living. Item collection is not always about greed.

[shaddowez]

UNVOTE:

I'm not town reading dreal, but want to parse through this whole interaction again. Something's not sitting right.

Shaz

- to add on to kuror's question, can you actually provide a succinct scum read on dreal that has nothing to do with his flavor claim?

[Vince McMahon]

oh fucking hell, man, not like I trust you anyway, but I'm just a Ranger, with a capital R and a small ANGER

lol
VOTE: Dreal

[KuroiXHF]

oh fucking hell, man, not like I trust you anyway, but I'm just a Ranger, with a capital R and a small ANGER

lol
VOTE: Dreal

^ Crap. That was an alt slip by me.

[SlySly]

Pine - self healer (protective), if town, scum won't target at night. if town, i would think scum would be hopping on this wagon
drealmz - (protective), has seemed like frustrated townie the entire game, makes sense to me that scum would want to lynch a protective role
kuror0 - (investigative) - scummy partial claim with, questionable, at best, "results"

Get off the protectors and protectors don't waste your protection on kuror0.

[Dunnstral]

SlySly, let's assume town has 3 town protectors

Ok. Scum have a strongman.

I'm saying "scum would be hopping on pine" is a dumb thing to come up with

[SlySly]

I'm saying "scum would be hopping on pine" is a dumb thing to come up with

Dumb or not, it's what I believe.

Pine's only going out if he gets lynched.
If Pine's town, scum aren't going to waste a NK attempt on him because of his self healing claim.
If Pine's scum, they wouldn't target him period.

If drealmz is town, scum will jump on this wagon to get rid of a protective role.

[SlySly]

Because of the current wagon situation, my gut is telling me drealmz is more likely town than Pine.

[Pine]

Look, too much is being made of me being able to self-heal. I am allowed to self-target, but I would forego healing someone else to do so.

Rephrase it this way: I am a limited-shot Doctor without the standard prohibition against self-targeting. A D&D cleric that can't heal themselves is basically a walking healing potion that bleeds.

[SlySly]

I am a limited-shot Doctor

...with a recharging item, that scum didn't target last night.

[Pine]

...due to the threat of self-targeting, which would waste their shot

[SlySly]

...due to the threat of self-targeting, which would waste their shot

Welcome to what i've been saying all along. Convenient threat claim to hide behind.